27 ms·
This seems isolationist. Why would we want to isolate ourselves? For a country that was founded upon immigrants, that extremely benefited (and continues to) fro
by godelski 7y ago
This seems isolationist. Why would we want to isolate ourselves? For a country that was founded upon immigrants, that extremely benefited (and continues to) from diversity of thought and ideas, why would we want to stop that? I'm just under 30 and I still remember growing up how I was told that a major part of what made America great was the melting pot. In academia and at labs I've seen this be a huge benefit. But I don't really hear how great the melting pot is anymore (I can only think of a few times in the last decade). Maybe it was just childhood naivety. But it also seems to me that it isn't just the US that is becoming isolationist. So I have to imagine that there's something, at least in western culture, that is changing.
- jorblumesea 7y agoAre you familiar with US history? Isolationism runs deep and wide.
- godelski 7y agoYes and no. I don't think it is black and white. While I'd say that there are isolationist aspects it isn't like how China has been (probably deserved considering the British). There's definitely a scale. We clearly aren't North Korea, which is what people think of when they think of an isolationist country. But I also can't think of a country that isn't at least a little isolationist. So I wouldn't say that isolationism runs deep. It is definitely there, I would definitely say that it is a escarpment but that doesn't mean it is the Grand Canyon or the Marianas Trench.
- jorblumesea 7y agoI don't think you understand, the US has a long and well established history of this, even to the point of formal political policies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_non-interventionism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_non-intervention... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Doctrine_of_Unstable_Alliances https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Doctrine_of_Unstabl...
- khuey 7y agoIt's been pretty thoroughly suppressed since December 7th, 1941.
- godelski 7y agoI wouldn't really call a country that is stereotyped as meddling in the affairs of everyone else strictly (key word) isolationist. Seems like the opposite stereotype of the Hermit Kingdom.
- jorblumesea 7y agoUS history is more than just the post WW2 superpower era.
- Swizec 7y ago> So I have to imagine that there's something, at least in western culture, that is changing. Inequality, wage stagnation, slowing growth, things like that. When life gets tough, us vs them rhetoric and isolationism starts going up. It’s pretty predictable when you look at history. First the economy has a few bumps, then the lower classes start clamoring for reform, then the various isms start taking hold of politics as people vote for anyone who promises them a better life. Post ww2 up to the early 2000’s was a period of unprecedented growth in most of the west as we caught up to pre-war status (think 1910’s, not 1930’s). That growth has tapped out and we are now on a more natural growth trajectory. But compared to what was before, organic growth looks slow and scary.
- kace91 7y agoI think expanding it to Western culture is projecting a bit. Here in Europe, almost everyone I talk to considers the US a borderline hostile place to visit, let alone emigrate to... It's true that in part we're a bit spoiled by the ease of movement inside the EU, but the general experience of entering the US (including airport security) is unwelcoming to the point of being humiliating - very different to the way the American people treats foreigners once inside, since they're generally welcoming and open. It's more of an structural/institutional problem.
- beached_whale 7y agoI don't think it is spoiled. Definitely better than here in North America, but is isn't spoiled to be afforded basic human rights of not being treated like cargo when crossing an imaginary line.
- refurb 7y agoThis is a ridiculous argument. There is a huge demand for people to immigrate to the US and it has every right to screen people looking for visa’s however it wants.
- beached_whale 7y agoAll the idea of countries do is perpetuate inequality and allow for the sovereignty excuse for the abuse of their own people. Sovereignty is a tool of oppression. It codifies in law an Us and Them instead of We. Yay, I won the geographic lottery and was born to a rich country. We better enforce that at an imaginary line on the ground with weapons. The problem starts when the powerful countries mess up the lives of people outside their borders, all the while complaining that those people shouldn't be allowed to come here.
- mLuby 7y agoThis is a ridiculous argument. First, in theory any sovereign country can do whatever it wants, but it definitely shouldn't. Second, the comment is about simply visiting (or god forbid having a connecting flight in) the US, not applying for visas (which certainly deserve more thorough handling). Third, the richest and most powerful nation on Earth should be setting a high standard for humane treatment of all people, especially when that same country espouses such beliefs as freedom and human rights.
- ncr100 7y agoI did not vote for this change, and I will vote to restore a non-isolationist paradigm in future elections.
- godzillabrennus 7y agoNativism is a reaction to the decline of the middle classes prospects. Half of America is not doing well and has been overlooked. The better educated amongst us are blinded by their own progress and weren’t looking inward. We will see more focus on nativist policies in our lifetime as automation continues to eat jobs.
- jasonlotito 7y ago> Half of America is not doing well and has been overlooked. I wasn't aware they were looking for government handouts to fix their own failings. Instead of waiting for the government to give them government jobs, they should instead take some personal responsibility for their current state. > The better educated amongst us are blinded by their own progress and weren’t looking inward. Seems to me like the better educated among us were busy taking ownership of our lives instead of doing the bare minimum and hoping nothing ever changed. > We will see more focus on nativist policies in our lifetime as automation continues to eat jobs. This has been well known for decades know, and at least for the past decade, people have been made well aware that this is coming. The previous President made this very clear that these jobs aren't coming back. This leaves people with a choice. Either life themselves up by their own bootstraps and take some personal responsibility in their lives, or give up more freedoms to government control. Seems a shame that these nativists seem to want things for free without doing the work to get it.
- dang 7y agoThis comment breaks the site guidelines. Please do not take HN threads further into ideological flamewar. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jasonlotito 7y agoThat must be newly introduced in the last few days, considering the comments and posts I still see presented here frequently. Nevertheless, I'll take it to heart and flag things that break it.
- hudon 7y agoAccording to recent UN reports, the United States is one of the countries with the most amount of resident immigrants [0]. In fact, according to their report, a whole 20% of immigrants (defined as people living somewhere they weren't born) call the US their home. Another problem with your argument is that the relationship between more thorough screening of immigration applicants and a country's "level of isolationism" is lacking evidence. Perhaps a country's capabilities in screening applicants is simply correlated to how many people are trying to immigrate there? Just a hypothesis based on the data linked above. But if I may counter your anecdote with my own: I am an immigrant in the US (Bay Area) and so are all my friends. Actually I think I interact with less than a handful of Americans regularly, everyone else is Mexican, Chinese, Slovenian, Indian, Ukranian, etc. I'm happy to have had the opportunity to find a home and work here, and I think so are they. [0] https://www.un.org/en/development/desa/population/migration/publications/populationfacts/docs/MigrationPopFacts20154.pdf https://www.un.org/en/development/desa/population/migration/...
- pugworthy 7y agoLogical, but logic does not prevail here. Nor science or reason.
- Longlius 7y agoThe US grants permanent residency to roughly a million people a year already. In the past we accepted anyone who would come because so few people were willing to come. Now too many people want to come, so the selection process has to become more rigorous. I don't want to sound nativist, but there are hard limits on how many people a country can accept at once, especially one with an increasingly small pool of jobs to fill.
- codedokode 7y agoAs I understand, those questions are for tourists too, not only for people wanting to live in US.
- jki275 7y agoThe DS-160 is the immigrant visa application as I recall.
- DarmokJalad1701 7y agoNope. Non-immigrant visa applicants -- tourist, business, work visa, student visa ... they all have to fill the DS-160.
- masonic 7y agobecause so few people were willing to come That hasn't been true for the past 250 years.
- mac01021 7y agoIt's possible to want more diversity, to believe the infusion of immigrants makes America great (or just better) and also believe we need to tightly regulate who is able to enter the country.
- godelski 7y agoI agree, but that's not really what is happening here is it? The American people clearly don't agree on how tightly to regulate.
- mac01021 7y agoIt's true that there is no consensus. But the change described in the article is, in fact, compatible with the view that we should hive more immigrants and more diversity while at the same time screening immigrants more thoroughly to eliminate specific undesirable elements.