5 ms·
That's pretty much what I thought as well. Most of the parenting advice is unsubstantiated claims written to make women feel guilty (over what, who knows?). As
by lordnacho 7y ago
That's pretty much what I thought as well. Most of the parenting advice is unsubstantiated claims written to make women feel guilty (over what, who knows?). As if your joy of having a kid needs to be tempered by giving up sushi. (What do people do in Japan?)
But generally the books don't even say where the claims are coming from, and everything is like you suspect, quite small effects if any, a priori.
Even the co sleeping thing seems to be fearmongering. Unless you're drunk, you're not gonna squash your kid to death. Plus the sleep benefits of letting the kid have boob on tap are enormous.
- hrktb 7y ago> giving up sushi. (What do people do in Japan?) Depending on the stage, they actualy give up sushi ... Apart from pregnancy/breast-feeding, Japan’s relation with raw fish is interesting, in that most people understand one day they’ll be unlucky and get food poisonned, but that’s just a fact of life, and nobody usually avoids raw fish just because of the risk.
- deadwisdom 7y agoThe co-sleeping seems to stem from all the SIDS research / literature which when you go and read seems especially questionable. The topic of SIDS was hit so hard by our hospital and pediatrician. It scares the shit out of you. And then you go read the sources, and it's... well underwhelming at best.
- infinite8s 7y agoSIDS basically means they have no fucking clue why the child died, so everything gets thrown into the SIDS bucket.
- Cogito 7y agoThat's why they tend to talk about Sudden Unexpected Infant Death these days. My understanding is that the primary concern is the ability of the child to breathe normally. Anything which restricts that ability can be life threatening. Having their face covered (very easy to do when they sleep between two adults who pull the covers up when they're cold) or pushing their face up against a non-breathable material (windproof bassinets, pillows, soft toys) leads to a lack of air circulation which can lead to CO2 buildup. This is particularly a problem when their muscles aren't strong enough to turn their head or roll over.
- chasd00 7y ago"sleep benefits of letting the kid have boob on tap are enormous" this cannot be overstated. We co-slept with my youngest and the difference between that experience and our first who was strictly bassinet/crib can't be put in words.
- in_cahoots 7y agoLike most things parenting related, this is probably up for debate. Many leading baby sleep books suggest that co-sleeping leads to a baby who nurses all the time, long past the point where Mom wants the bed to herself. My own child sleeps 8ish hours in a row at 3 months, which I attribute to feeding him on a flexible schedule instead of on-demand. Not to say that your experience is invalid, just that it’s hard to draw any conclusions from the limited data we have.
- checkyoursudo 7y agoMy wife has an extremely difficult time going back to sleep if she is fully wakened. Our kids co-slept. She could feed them at night without having to get up, and still be able to mostly get some sleep. As an additional benefit, she didn't have to pump for overnight, and I didn't have to get up to bottle feed. Which, I would have done! But I'm happy not to have to have done that. I am a very hard sleeper. I can sleep through anything. But I can sleep in bed with a little kid next to me just fine. I think our unconscious minds/nervous systems must have enough awareness of those little blazing furnaces.
- bubblewrap 7y agoIs it really so horrible to give up sushi for 9 months? There are plenty of other things to eat under the sun.