3 ms·
In France, we have something called "droit à l'image". It means that if you can't appear on a picture without your authorization, with a few exceptions. If you
by GuB-42 7y ago
In France, we have something called "droit à l'image". It means that if you can't appear on a picture without your authorization, with a few exceptions.
If you give an authorization, it has to be for a specific purpose and not generalized. So just because you gave an authorization to appear in a movie doesn’t mean you gave an authorization for other purposes, such as face matching. Same thing for social media.
There are also copyright issues. If France, you always own copyright (droit d'auteur), you may transfer the exploitation rights but the work is still yours. It means you still retain some level of control, in particular regarding decency.
France is just one European country but that's to show that there are limits to what you can do, even with publicly available data.
- internet_user 7y agoWhat if your image has been cached by a CDN outside of France, and then downloaded and matched by someone who never interfaced with a French IP? Who is at fault here?
- GuB-42 7y agoIANAL but I don't think CDNs an IPs matter here. The question would be more among the line of "in the picture taken in France" or "has the matching been done in France or by a company that has a presence in France". And unless everything happens in France, it would be a huge mess and I don't think anything can be done. GDPR is an attempt to harmonize the rules of different countries and make them enforceable internationally. I don't know how it is done in other European countries but rules regarding personal data and authorship tend to be stronger than in the US, and freedom of speech is more controlled (ex: hate speech, libel, ...).
- karl_schlagenfu 7y agoHow does this work when tourists are taking photographs? For example at the Eiffel Tower where it's almost impossible to take a photo without people being in the shot.