3 ms·
Certainly interesting to think about new forms of ownership, but there's some issues with this idea. - You have to have Coase in there somehow. When is a new l
by lordnacho 7y ago
Certainly interesting to think about new forms of ownership, but there's some issues with this idea.
- You have to have Coase in there somehow. When is a new line of work a new entity? Seems to be something to do with internalizing costs, the friction of negotiating externally, and as part of that the difficulty of valuation.
- Say I'm a pro athlete. I hire a physio and a permanent PR rep to handle my social media. Now I'm in minority? Valuation has to come into it somewhere.
The problem fundamentally is how to pay people what they're worth, which in itself is a nebulous thing. Tying to some specific measure like time spent might be very wrong across different fields. The current "solution" which I'll grant is not entirely satisfying is that everyone just negotiates. If there's an amazing manager he talks everyone else into giving him a large slice of the pie. If there's a recent grad he gets a little bit, but gets his foot in the door.
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoSuch an ownership model is certainly not suitable for the examples you bring up. One simple modification that might work for the pro athlete case is that the athlete always owns 70% of the company, and the rest of the team get ownership based on time spent. Or you could even allocate percentage ownerships to each division of the company. The PR team gets 15% divided amongst themselves based on time spent, the health team gets 10% etc, where the percentages are based on some notion of the value generation by each team. The proposed model, I think is best of large companies with lots of workers - say a factory, where most people bring in roughly equal amounts of value. The high value people could negotiate earning ownership at 5x or 10x the base rate, for example. The big point is that there is a massive space of possible ownership models and exploring them is a very interesting exercise. In fact, experimenting with such models is an excellent way of exploring and understanding how much value different people in a company bring and what they are worth.