4 ms·
You're not wrong, but why is this the case? One hypothesis I heard was that building codes changed quite regularly, especially with regards to earthquakes, and
by throw0101a 7y ago
You're not wrong, but why is this the case?
One hypothesis I heard was that building codes changed quite regularly, especially with regards to earthquakes, and therefore people often wanted the latest designs. So when they built houses, they didn't spend as much effort because they knew after a few decades they'd be completely torn down:
> This scrap-and-build approach is a quirk of the Japanese housing market that can be explained variously by low-quality construction to quickly meet demand after the second world war, repeated building code revisions to improve earthquake resilience and a cycle of poor maintenance due to the lack of any incentive to make homes marketable for resale.
* https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusable-housing-revolution https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusabl...
* https://www.rethinktokyo.com/2018/06/06/depreciate-limited-life-span-japanese-home/1527843245 https://www.rethinktokyo.com/2018/06/06/depreciate-limited-l...
In North America, I believe we also do some mental gymnastics: we say that houses are expensive, but what's actually pricey is the dirt. It's just that we tend not to completely demolish structures: to the point that even if someone completely guts a house, replacing (e.g.) >75% of materials, we psychologically still call it an "old house" even though most of the structure except the frame is new (see Ship of Theseus).
- acchow 7y ago> especially with regards to earthquakes, and therefore people often wanted the latest designs. So when they built houses, they didn't spend as much effort because they knew after a few decades they'd be completely torn down That only explains the structure itself. But an empty, small lot of land (only big enough for one home) with no structure at all (or an abandoned, worthless structure) can be worth well over $1M in america.
- Aeolun 7y agoIt can be in Tokyo too. I have one right next door in fact. 2.2M for like 320 sqm. Following Japanese standards that fits 4 homes though :)
- WWLink 7y agoTo be fair, tract houses are usually built poorly and don't age well. The 1960s tract house I currently rent is hot garbage and it would be better/safer to tear it down and rebuild, than it would to fix it up.
- Retric 7y ago~60 years is much older than most single family homes in Japan. On average they get torn down after ~30 years.
- fpoling 7y agoFriend of mine said that before moving to US he always thought that scenes in Hollywood movies about guys and girls punching and kicking through the walls were totally ridiculous. After living in Seattle for a while he no longer thinks so. The walls are indeed much thinner than in Europe. He supposed that this was due to earthquakes. What was the point to make home heavier/more robust if it still is not enough to protect against strong earthquakes while making evacuation harder? That and the culture that prefers to rebuild from scratch rather than maintaining older things leads to houses that are only good for 30-40 years...
- pjc50 7y agoDifferential availability of materials makes a huge difference - the US has a lot of cheap wood, leading to lath-and-plaster construction, especially in milder climates. This can be found in traditional European construction ("half timbered"), but we used up the forests so many areas switched to stone or brick. E.g. this Scottish vernacular cottage: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Du2mYluV4AAipYU.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Du2mYluV4AAipYU.jpg The only piece of structural timber was the roof beam (now missing), which could be covered by branches and thatch. I think "settlement persistence" makes a difference too, as new greenfield houses in the UK tend to be poor quality, but more central ones are more durable.
- dillonmckay 7y agoI have only seen lathe and plaster in ‘quality’ built and historical homes, but the majority use drywall. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drywall https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drywall
- euske 7y agoTraditionally, all Japanese buildings were made of wood, probably due to the abundance of materials (75% of the land is still forest even today). But wooden houses didn't last long because of its monsoon climate with a lot of rainfall (things get rotten). And then, there's an earthquake. People tend to think that materials are transient and fragile, and the modern housing system in Japan might have reflected this collective belief.
- throw0101a 7y agoAlso true in North America: see prevalence of 2x4 and 2x6 frame houses. Yet my parents live in a house whose frame was built in the 1890s. Though, of course, they don't live in an earthquake zone.
- zamfi 7y agoOne piece missing in this analysis is construction cost: between permitting, regulations, unions, and Other Unknown Factors™, it can cost 2x as much to build the same structure in the USA compared with elsewhere. If construction is cheap, sure, tear down the old and build anew. But if it costs more to build a house than buy the same house (yay SF Bay Area!) you’d be crazy to do this now.
- throw0101a 7y agoThis is hyper-locale specific, but the median per square foot construction cost in the US is under $150: * https://www.newhomesource.com/guide/articles/cost-to-build-house-per-square-foot https://www.newhomesource.com/guide/articles/cost-to-build-h... Though a more realistic number, if one wants something a bit "nicer" may be up to $250: * https://www.thumbtack.com/p/home-building-cost-by-sqft https://www.thumbtack.com/p/home-building-cost-by-sqft In more (high-demand) urban areas, the price of the dirt may dwarf the price of the structure. When people say they "bought a home for $x", what's really happening is that they bought the land for $y and the structure for $z. If you look at homeowner's insurance, the coverage for rebuilding is $z and not $x.