4 ms·
> democratically based on utility to the public Ok, so I want to live in the center of the city, because there the walking distance is shorter. John wants to
by Aeolun 7y ago
> democratically based on utility to the public
Ok, so I want to live in the center of the city, because there the walking distance is shorter.
John wants to do the same thing, but he gets assigned a tiny plot somewhere miles outside the center.
How will you make value judgements about people in this manner? You cannot assign randomly either, as everyone will hate the place they live.
- geofft 7y agoThere are lots of ways to do it, but yes, whatever you do, you have to make that value judgment. I have trouble believing that the value judgment "Your parents were richer than John's parents" is anywhere near the top of the list of reasonable approaches. (I have real trouble believing that the value judgment "Your grandparents shared a race with the politically powerful, who refused to sell to John's grandparents" or "Your great-grandparents shot John's great-grandparents in the face" are anywhere except right at the bottom.)
- 6nf 7y agoWhat about "I can afford to pay for the privilege because my father worked his butt off and made lots and lots of money" is that still ok?
- geofft 7y agoLess bad, but still doesn't clear the "rational" bar for me—why does what your father did have anything to do with where you should live? (If anything, since you don't have any choice in which father you get and since an ineffective or even missing father affects your life in lots of ways, there's an argument that people without hard-working, diligent fathers should have extra support from society to make up for it. But it would be better to just address the root causes of why not having great parents puts you at a disadvantage in life.)
- 6nf 7y agoWhat about "I worked my butt off for many years to be able to live here" is that ok?
- geofft 7y agoYes, that crosses the threshold of rational to me. It doesn't seem necessarily optimal, mind you—there are some interesting cases like "John worked his butt off, too, but he's been doing coal mining for thirty years and those jobs are gone, and you graduated last year with a CS degree and got a nice signing bonus from Facebook"—but at least we can argue that society for whatever reason values being a junior dev at Facebook more than coal mining and if that's wrong we should address that at the root. The biggest practical problem is that it's very difficult to distinguish "I worked my butt off" from "My father worked his butt off" and "His father had generational wealth." Money is money, and the inheritance tax is far below 100%. So simply putting land access on the free market, if the market is denominated by money, does not effectively implement this proposal: it reduces in practice to the non-rational value judgments mentioned earlier, largely because very few people can earn enough salary to compete with once-modest savings that have been invested for generations. (And money persists across the years, so if society ever mis-valued something in the past, correcting that valuation now does not affect money that's already in people's hands. I guess that's the case for reparations in a nutshell, hm.) One potential approach is to require that access to land involve the ongoing payment of money that dwarfs the one-time purchase cost (if there even is one), which approximates giving land access to those who are presently doing valuable things for society and not those who just happen to have money. If you're currently working your butt off, even if you're young, you can keep affording it; if you are relying on savings or generational wealth, it's going to run out. It occurs to me that this is approaching the Georgists' land value tax, though from a different direction.
- ZeroFries 7y agoMost of that land is sold with a mortgage with 5-20% downpayment, and so that ongoing payment already dwarfs the one-time purchase cost. Alternatively, you're talking about rent. Also, large wealth doesn't generally just run out, if properly managed. It can grow very easily with decently smart investments. Also, how do you know society mis-valued John's grandfathers contributions? If John's grandfather invented the axe, thereby incrementally improving millions of lives, and generating vast wealth for himself, such that his contribution is still "being paid back" in some sense by society by allowing John to coast, this seems neutral to me. Remember, this is true for only a very small % of society. Instead of trying to implement a rule-based system to correct it and thereby creating other problems (such as creating a steep inheritance tax), good old-fashioned social pressure can go a long way. Celebrate the rich who use their wealth for beneficial purposes, and shame those who do not. Public appearance is important for business, but make it even more-so. Instead of celebrating flaunting of wealth, celebrate giving to charity. I see the rise of the tech elite already moving us in this direction.
- coliveira 7y agoMoney is green everywhere, so people can never be sure if your father worked a lot for that money or if won the lottery or stole it. As a result, we should not make these decisions based on money alone.
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoWe could just make value judgments on people based on how much money they have. /snark. Really to be serious I would say that your concern is valid, but we shouldn’t be comparing this idea to perfection, because today we certainly don’t have perfection. Yes you are right that determining who gets housing is nontrivial. But who said collaborating across society was simple? Abstracting it all away to markets is far from ideal, don’t dismiss other proposals simply because they may not be easy.
- Aeolun 7y agoI don’t dismiss other proposals. I dismiss this one in specific. Our current housing market isn’t perfect, but like democracy it’s the best we’ve been able to come up with so far.