3 ms·
Let’s not forget kids starving to death in some parts of Africa while we are at it. And cancer, it kills a lot of kids every year also. So what does that have
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
Let’s not forget kids starving to death in some parts of Africa while we are at it. And cancer, it kills a lot of kids every year also. So what does that have to do with school shootings? Isn’t this just a huge red herring?
School shootings are not a leading cause of death for kids in the USA. Instead, they cause terror: freaking active shooter drills, metal detectors and security theater, armed campus officers, all the crap that I really don’t want my kids to go through.
- jMyles 7y ago> School shootings are not a leading cause of death for kids in the USA. Instead, they cause terror: freaking active shooter drills, metal detectors and security theater, armed campus officers, all the crap that I really don’t want my kids to go through. Shooting incidents don't cause those things. Administrators and school boards who are unwilling to engage in thought leadership do.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThe public demanded it! You can’t just be an administrator and say, “well, school shootings are bad, but statistically they aren’t a problem, so we don’t need to do anything.” Well, you can try to make this argument, but you’ll be out of your job quickly. Kids die in auto accidents at the rate of auto accidents, a tragedy, a common tragedy, so no one pays much attention to it. But school shootings, they aren’t common at all, they are horrific, and no one wants to be caught doing nothing about it, and since we can’t get rid of the guns in the USA, active shooter drills it is.
- untog 7y agoTo follow on from "the public demanded it" and bring it back to the original article... why is the media publishing these photos? Because the public want them to. The vast majority of newspapers are profit making enterprises, and they're giving customers what they want. Blaming the media here feels like missing the forest for the trees.
- jMyles 7y ago> You can’t just be an administrator and say, “well, school shootings are bad, but statistically they aren’t a problem, so we don’t need to do anything.” FWIW, you are talking to the son of a school administrator who did just that. (or, more specifically, who facilitated the introduction of text alert systems, security systems, etc, but who successfully resisted metal detectors and active shooter drills)
- ipython 7y agoWhat’s your solution? Not being snippy just honestly interested.
- opportune 7y agoThe solution is to not do anything about it. An absurd amount of money is wasted on ineffective mitigation strategies to protect against something less common than getting struck by lightning
- umvi 7y ago> The solution is to not do anything about it. I agree in many cases, but it's a circular problem: 1. Shooting event happens 2. Media whips up national frenzy, people start calling for politicians to do something 3. Politician's Syllogism happens due to pressure from #2 4. Repeat 1-3 The only way to break the cycle is to remove step 2.
- mises 7y agoI sort of wonder: if we didn't publicize these the way we do, would it occur at the same rate? Terrorism happens so people can inflict terror. Less the terror, maybe it would reduce.
- ipython 7y agoI wonder about this as well... but I am afraid the real answer lies with an underlying lack of meaning, lessened emphasis on community and lack of empathy. We like to treat the symptoms but the root cause is so removed we can’t even begin to identify it let alone address it.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoEvery single other developed country has successfully dealt with this problem in another way besides censorship.
- ipython 7y ago
- dahart 7y agoI’m not sure I understand your question. If you think that school schooling terror is disproportionate to risk (which it sounds like you do), then aren’t the leading causes of actual death extremely relevant? Kids are much more likely to die in a car than at school, so your strawman about Africa might not be super relevant, but auto accidents in the US and auto safety certainly are something we ought to be paying roughly 100x more attention to in the media than school shootings, right?
- ozim 7y agoBig part of it is ... intention. If you have human who is willing to kill other people it is at least order of magnitude worse than car accidents or starving to death. If you would have some person starving kids to death intentionally that would be really bad and people would do something about it. But just not getting enough food when a lot of people are already donating loads of money for starving people. It is just, I am sorry, but cannot do anything about it more. Even if I donate all my earnings to starving children, there still will be some children dying from hunger, I cannot do anything about it. Shootings in schools are possible to prevent in multiple ways. I live in Europe and school shootings are not something that happens once a year or twice a year in here like in US. It something that happens once in IDK 10 years or something?