8 ms·
Going from a model where social media is a new instance of the public square I guess I would agree there is no expectation of privacy in the public square, but
by bryanrasmussen 7y ago
Going from a model where social media is a new instance of the public square I guess I would agree there is no expectation of privacy in the public square, but where the public square metaphor breaks down is that this square is actually owned by a corporation that is taking pictures and wiretapping all the individual conversations taking place in their square and selling the contents thereof to other corporations.
So as always metaphors are a lousy way to reason, and quickly break down because once you are arguing that X is like Y you will end up hitting the limit of X being unlike Y anytime you try to deal with something complicated in regards to X.
Hence regulation of a medium where everything lasts forever and can be looked up instantaneously from almost anywhere, and copied and repeated all over the world by anyone wanting to do so, should not follow the model of regulation for a medium where everything is ephemeral and while theoretically open to anyone in practice not so open because availability of space is a limiting factor on proximity and proximity is needed to take part.
- rightbyte 7y agoThe methaphor is good. It clearly shows why wiretaping the public on the square is unreasonable.
- michaelchisari 7y agoAlso, given that metaphor, if I'm whispering to a friend in a public square, I do have an expectation of privacy in the sense that there should not be boom mics placed everywhere to pick up the smallest of conversations.
- cm2187 7y agoOr talking to a friend on your mobile phone. Your phone company is not allowed to wire tap the conversation.
- maehwasu 7y agoYeah, this is the most apt comparison, and is barely even a metaphor. Shocking that it's not applied to FB.
- testvox 7y agoYour phone company can actually record your conversations so long as they ensure all parties to the conversation are aware they are doing so.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 7y agoOnly if the parties agree and continued use of the service argument isn’t fair.
- Frost1x 7y agoI believe these protections are related to voice specifically, from what I recall. The law on record has to do specifically with voice data and excludes textual forms of data. If you were voice chatting over Facebook they would probably have to make you aware if they were listening/processing the data for words. By make you aware, it probably means bury it in the ToS on page 784 in a generic and ambiguous way and that is sufficient for court should someone litigate. Now when you start looking at voice assistants like Alexa, GA, etc. the waters could get muddier.
- PeterStuer 7y agoOr when you send your friend a letter, the post office isn't expected to open the envelope to read your communication.
- cm2187 7y agoNot even isn't expected. Isn't legally allowed.
- ToFundorNot 7y agoUnless you're the NSA / CSIS / Etc.
- derefr 7y agoThe “expectation of privacy” isn’t about what you would expect regular people to do. It’s about what you would expect malicious actors like spies (or just private detectives hired to tail you) to do. You wouldn’t expect to be safe from a detective with a boom mic in the public square—therefore, the square is not a place where you should be having private conversations (even whispered) if you have anything to hide.
- comboy 7y agoI would argue that's exactly what the expectation of privacy is. Malicious actors on the other hand are the reality of privacy.
- jasonlotito 7y agoA better metaphor I've found is a telegram. You dictate your message and someone else inputs the message and someone on the other end transcribes the message and delivers it to the recipient. Is there an expectation that only you and the recipient will know what the message is? No. There are at least two other individuals involved there. I've honest never understood how the expectation of privacy arose from using Facebook. You are literally sending your information to Facebook. If anyone is at fault here, it's browser makers who enable sending your data to Facebook. Facebook isn't reaching into your computer "stealing" your data. It's recording what is being sent. Obviously talking about the web site here.
- msiyer 7y agoAt times, a public square is the best place to have a private/secret talk.
- bduerst 7y agoExcept their point is that the public square is not. "Most convenient" is not the same as best wrt private conversations.
- Dylan16807 7y agoI wouldn't expect to be safe from that detective in my own house, in a sealed room! But I certainly have an expectation of privacy there.
- em500 7y agoYou can use Whatsapp to whisper to your friend. It's end-to-end encrypted.
- toastal 7y agoAnd get ads in your conversation like real life. This private dialog is brought you by Squarespace.
- msiyer 7y agoEncrypted by whom? Who has the keys? WhatsApp is not good for anything private.
- rakoo 7y agoAs always, it depends on who your enemy is. For the ultra vast majority of people, and in the continuity of the "public place" metaphor, it's more than enough.
- nothrabannosir 7y agoAre you implying that Facebook can snoop on the contents of whatsapp messages? That'd be a pretty significant scandal. No matter how disillusioned you are with Facebook, directly and overtly lying to customers about encryption would be next level. Definitely beyond their current tactics of circumspect honesty, e.g. TFA. Until proven otherwise, I think it is absolutely fair to say WhatsApp messages are, indeed, encrypted end-to-end with no possibility for FB to read the contents. So, to answer your question: encrypted by users, and the users have the keys. FB doesn't. WhatsApp is definitely good for most things private. Moreso than e.g. Facebook wall or messenger itself, as per TFA. Sneaky fine print is one thing. Plain lying is another.
- StreamBright 7y agoI am not sure if understand how encryption works in the context of messaging applications. Unless the two parties communicating generate a set of keys for that particular session there is a high chance that a 3rd party who is operating the service can read their messages. This is the theory. Now, in practice you can see exactly the same. https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/2606495/facebook-can-read-your-private-whatsapp-conversations-and-snooping-governments-might-be-copping-a-look-too/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/2606495/facebook-can-read-your...
- baby 7y agoIt is not a metaphor, it is an analogy.
- LoSboccacc 7y agoand while it might work for Twitter (with the exception of private messages) I'd also argue that the metaphor falls apart for Facebook since you can have private profiles and groups where there's an expectation of privacy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sgt101 7y agoFacebooks posting sections explicitly provide segregation and message direction - "Only Friends" They directly create an expectation of privacy with their controls. The argument that they are making is outrageous.
- bduerst 7y agoIsn't the best analogy for the public square the entire internet, not just Facebook? If you stand in the section of the public square next to Facebook and they listen in, then it's no different than standing by any other website. It's true FB is popular and present in a large portion of the square, but they're not entirely unavoidable in the public square. It's also true that others can talk about you and share your information in the public square and Facebook will pick it up, but now we're dealing with control over your own information in the public square, which is a different topic altogether.
- llukas 7y agoIf somebody follows you even in public space all the time then in most countries it is considered stalking and penalized.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAs it should be with on-line tracking too. This intuition, that on-line tracking is akin to meatspace stalking, is behind some of the arguments against that tracking.
- bduerst 7y agoExcept tracking pixels aren't following you, they already exist on the properties you choose to visit. It's more analogous to mass surveillance of the public square with security cameras. Most stalking laws apply to a single person who is targeting an individual, in the effort to harass, incite fear, or some other malevolent intent.
- tomglynch 7y agoThis is a great metaphor. Social Media should be more like a public square - maybe we need to get cities or countries to create a public online space, rather than corporations with monetary focus.
- baby 7y ago> So as always metaphors are a lousy way to reason It is not a metaphor. It is an analogy. It was used as comparison to the living room. Knowing that, it is hard to follow your point.
- coldtea 7y agoAnalogies are an equally lousy way to reason, one should study the thing itself and its unique characteristics to determine how to deal with it, not some proxy by analogy.
- baby 7y agoAn analogy is never a way to reason, it's a way to explain and teach. It's been used forever and nobody thinks it's lousy unless they want to complain about something :)
- freeflight 7y agoBut standing in a public square doesn't tell anybody your name or anything else personal about you except for how you look because people usually don't walk around in public with name-tags, thus even in a public square, you will be reasonably anonymous. At least that's the German interpretation, afaik in the US, it's interpreted a bit differently where everything "in the public" has no reasonable expectation of being "private"?
- Barrin92 7y agoyes, and unless you're living in a country that has plastered every centimeter with cameras (which is of course objectionable on the same grounds), observations in the public square are ephemeral, nobody's logging your behaviour. It really is a horrible and intentionally misleading analogy.
- dalbasal 7y agoas always metaphors are a lousy way to reason We'll put. Unfortunately in this case, iur legal and often social reasoning works exactly this way. I think you've put your finger on the metaphor at the heart of this problem: the public square. I've had this thought several times when hearing/reading Jack Dorsey's response to all sorts of issues. We can't have a private owner and rulemaker for our public squares, without losing some of that metaphor's more meaningful implications. I think there are two big issues at play. One is that public square issue. If that is appropriate to think of FB that way, I think the implication is exactly opposite of what FB execs want: you can't exclusively exploit it for private gain. A (metaphorical) public square is a political (literal) forum. The types of problems that come with a private public forum are exactly those demonstrated by the Cambridge Analytica scandal. The public forum gets auctioned off secretly to political bidders. The second issue is another (possibly) metaphor broken by a shift in the underlying reality. "Expectation of privacy" means something totally different online. There's no expectation of privacy when you get in your car and drive to the store. But, if a new technology happens to give a company the ability to log your car's whereabouts at all times.
- stcredzero 7y agoGoing from a model where social media is a new instance of the public square I guess I would agree there is no expectation of privacy in the public square, but where the public square metaphor breaks down is that this square is actually owned by a corporation that is taking pictures and wiretapping all the individual conversations taking place in their square and selling the contents thereof to other corporations. Not just that. Also selling the ability to remote control boom mics and remote control telephoto cameras, so they can send you an advertisement based on what you were looking at.
- falcolas 7y agoIf they want Facebook to be a public square, then they have to take the bad with the good - they should respect free speech, as defined by the constitution of the country they are incorporated in. They should lose the ability to censor anybody, or to kick anybody out of the square (sans illegal activities), or prevent entry to anybody who wants to come in.
- scotty79 7y ago> this square is actually owned by a corporation that is taking pictures and wiretapping all the individual conversations taking place in their square and selling the contents thereof to other corporations. You mean like a mall? There's no expectation of privacy at the mall.
- sorokod 7y agoMetaphors are an excellent way to reason about complex fenomena as they provide a simplified model. Naturally the entity that chooses the metahor dictates the tone, the direction and the likley outcome of the discussion as is the case here. Here is another one: social media is like a livley party where people can mingle in large and not do large rooms with different degrees of interaction with the totality of the guests. One can see that this is not a metaphor that FB would choose to discuss.