4 ms·
Doesn’t seem fair, the way you’re describing companies that operate like Uber/Lyft/etc... Drivers opt-in on their own accord and it requires zero skill whatsoe
by whalesalad 7y ago
Doesn’t seem fair, the way you’re describing companies that operate like Uber/Lyft/etc...
Drivers opt-in on their own accord and it requires zero skill whatsoever. You can work whenever you want for as long or as little as you’d like.
How is this somehow unethical or immoral? You used the word wrong.
These people are not employees, they’re temporary/ephemeral contractors. If you work for an hour a month - you’re not my employee - and I’m not going to give you health insurance.
- ilaksh 7y agoThe percentage of Uber drivers that work for an hour a month is close to zero. Obviously those people should not get health insurance.
- social_quotient 7y agoOkay so where is the line? Not zero and not 40 hrs.
- whalesalad 7y agoSo where do you draw the line?? The reason Uber and the like operate the way they do is they don’t need to worry about that overhead. It’s simple and easy, unlike having people on your permanent staff. So you say: well, we don’t like that, we will stop it. If a person works more than X hours a week for you, you owe them benefits. “Okay no problem,” Uber says, “drivers can no longer drive more than X hours per week in this municipality” and then boom supply goes down and pricing (revenue) goes up and then people start getting fake accounts etc... or just get fucked like this article eludes. So in the end the business will always succeed and protect itself, the “employee” or “contractor” gets the short end of the stick. Sucks that this happens.
- manfredo 7y agoSure, but what about people that work 2-4 hours a day, to supplement their main job? Or once a day on the weekends? Or a mom whose daily routine is to drop the kids off school, and drive Uber until the kids are done with school? This is the problem with extending employee benefits to gig workers. Employee benefits are an overhead cost, so now it becomes unprofitable for Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, etc. to have workers working sporadic hours. If their workers get classified as employees, then they'll have to start setting hours for employees. This put a lot of people who need flexible hours out of work.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoSure, but what about people that work 2-4 hours a day, to supplement their main job? Or once a day on the weekends? Or a mom whose daily routine is to drop the kids off school, and drive Uber until the kids are done with school? By and large they don't exist.
- manigandham 7y agoThey are the vast majority of Uber drivers.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoThose who stick around are driving more than occasionally. The "vast majority" of those buying into this "gig economy" bullshit only last a few months at most. https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2018/06/uber-fails-to-disrupt-the-concept-of-full-time-work/562427/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2018/06/uber-fails-to... Low wages correspond to a high turnover rate. While more than 800,000 people drive for Uber in a year, the average driver lasts around three months and drives less than half time, or only 17 hours per week.
- manigandham 7y agoOk, but that doesn't refute anything I said. The whole point is that it's not a FT job. Most drivers are work for a few hours a week in addition to their other job/school/etc. It's perfectly valid for people to drive when they need extra income and stop as their situation changes. That's what the flexibility is for.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoThe whole point is that it's not a FT job. It is a full-time job in that the so-called "core" drivers drive for Uber full-time. There are a lot of part-time employees too, and they're just as deserving of minimum wage, social security contributions, workers comp insurance, unemployment insurance, health insurance, and the whole host of other benefits that come with being classed as not-a-contractor. It's perfectly valid for people to drive when they need extra income There've been part-time jobs with flexible schedules since before Boober was even a glimmer in Kalanick's horny eyes. The difference is that when you work as a part-timer for a real company you are subject to things like minimum wage. Driving for Uber is nowhere near as profitable as their marketing is claiming. For instance: https://www.extremetech.com/mobile/243102-uber-fined-20-million-lying-driver-earnings-predatory-financing https://www.extremetech.com/mobile/243102-uber-fined-20-mill... Across all of those cities less than 30% of the drivers are making what Uber claims they can make. That's before the usury that Uber engages in (20% APR on a new car lone? for fucks sake).