3 ms·
Companies had come to the conclusion that they could just save lots of money by using contractors or freelancers as cheap long term employees since they didn't
by ilaksh 7y ago
Companies had come to the conclusion that they could just save lots of money by using contractors or freelancers as cheap long term employees since they didn't have to pay benefits. It was obviously wrong, but everyone was doing it, and no one was stopping them, so it became normalized as a business practice.
There are some companies like Uber that have their entire business model based on misclassification.
The issue of people blacklisting California freelancers though now becomes a real problem for some people.
Maybe other states will make similar laws.
- jameslk 7y ago> It was obviously wrong It sounds obviously wrong by the way you phrase it, but it's not so black and white. As a freelancer myself of the past 5 years, I prefer the independent life, being able to negotiate things as I'd like, having more varied work and having more freedom to work when and where I like. Perhaps I could make more and have better benefits as a regular employee, but that's not what I want. Maybe you don't understand and so this is "obviously wrong" to you, but not everything can be bucketed into "wrong" and "right" for everyone. This may help some but it will definitely screw over others.
- jacobolus 7y agoThe concept of freelancers isn’t the problem. It is entirely legitimate to be a freelancer and entirely legitimate to hire a freelancer. The problem is de-facto employees who are classed as freelancers as a way of avoiding taxes and worker-protection laws.
- jameslk 7y agoYes, I would be classified as an employee according to this CA precedent for some of the clients I've worked for. I don't want this. > But it’s part B that presents a problem for freelance journalists: someone is an independent contractor only if they perform work “outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business.” In the archetypal example, a plumber fixing a restaurant toilet clearly qualifies. A freelancer journalist writing a column for a magazine? Not so much. In my case, I've been a contract developer working for agencies before. Sometimes I want work like this.
- chrstphrhrt 7y agoMy understanding (and experience as a contractor) is that for the service provider the benefit is being able to control the what and how of the work. This is better for the client as well especially if there is asymmetric knowledge as is often the case in tech. However, if your are working full time and end up being made to follow the client's schedule, don't get to address technical debt, have useless meetings etc. then you might be considered an employee anyway. Which I can't understand why you _wouldn't_ want that, because it could mean overtime pay for all those crunch times that result from bad management. So independent contractor is probably best for a tech worker if you're able to set boundaries and have autonomy, but not at all if having to work overtime and not take vacations.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> then you might be considered an employee anyway. Which I can't understand why you _wouldn't_ want that Because it comes with a significant reduction in flexibility. If the employer has to provide health insurance then they'll pay you proportionally less, even if you already have health insurance through your spouse. If they have to pay you overtime then they may cut your hours instead, or lower your base pay to compensate, which may be worse for you than being able to continue working at the original wage. Meanwhile if you did prefer some aspect of the arrangement the law would require then there is nothing stopping you from negotiating that to begin with in exchange for the correspondingly smaller amount of cash money. Few employers have any objection to providing you with health insurance in lieu of the same amount in cash that they would otherwise still have to pay you in order to get you to work for them. But some employees would prefer the cash -- and the employers take some of the loss when not being able to do what both parties prefer makes the employee walk away, so they don't like it either.
- ilaksh 7y agoI understand better than you. I've been a freelancer, temp, or contractor for most of my working life. This spans about 20 years. For the past 10 years it's been almost all remote freelancing. I also prefer freedoms to the degree that I can get them. I've also lived in California for most of my life. In about 75% of the projects I have been brought into, projects were not short term, and the non-employee status was maintained long term as a way to avoid paying for benefits. In some cases I was also building a startup, i.e., I was effectively serving the role of technical cofounder over a period of many months or a few years, but the freelancer status was leveraged as a way to ensure I did not try to gain any business interest or profit. I'm sure people will say that it's my fault for allowing people to take advantage of me. However I do the best I can and since I do not have a large social network or savings, it has almost never made sense to quit a project and therefore drop my only source of income, on the basis of not receiving benefits or equity or whatever.
- whalesalad 7y ago> I'm sure people will say that it's my fault for allowing people to take advantage of me. Yes. It’s not binary, as you describe.
- whalesalad 7y agoDoesn’t seem fair, the way you’re describing companies that operate like Uber/Lyft/etc... Drivers opt-in on their own accord and it requires zero skill whatsoever. You can work whenever you want for as long or as little as you’d like. How is this somehow unethical or immoral? You used the word wrong. These people are not employees, they’re temporary/ephemeral contractors. If you work for an hour a month - you’re not my employee - and I’m not going to give you health insurance.
- ilaksh 7y agoThe percentage of Uber drivers that work for an hour a month is close to zero. Obviously those people should not get health insurance.
- social_quotient 7y agoOkay so where is the line? Not zero and not 40 hrs.
- whalesalad 7y agoSo where do you draw the line?? The reason Uber and the like operate the way they do is they don’t need to worry about that overhead. It’s simple and easy, unlike having people on your permanent staff. So you say: well, we don’t like that, we will stop it. If a person works more than X hours a week for you, you owe them benefits. “Okay no problem,” Uber says, “drivers can no longer drive more than X hours per week in this municipality” and then boom supply goes down and pricing (revenue) goes up and then people start getting fake accounts etc... or just get fucked like this article eludes. So in the end the business will always succeed and protect itself, the “employee” or “contractor” gets the short end of the stick. Sucks that this happens.
- manfredo 7y agoSure, but what about people that work 2-4 hours a day, to supplement their main job? Or once a day on the weekends? Or a mom whose daily routine is to drop the kids off school, and drive Uber until the kids are done with school? This is the problem with extending employee benefits to gig workers. Employee benefits are an overhead cost, so now it becomes unprofitable for Uber, Lyft, DoorDash, etc. to have workers working sporadic hours. If their workers get classified as employees, then they'll have to start setting hours for employees. This put a lot of people who need flexible hours out of work.
- manigandham 7y agoDo you realize that anyone can be a full-time driver? The job has been available for a century now, and has plenty of demand still. The people driving for Uber do not want a full time job, that's the point. They want the flexibility of working whenever and wherever they can, usually because they have a day job, are retired, in school, or some other situation. Ask your next Uber driver if they want an 8 hour shift where they have to show up on time at a location that Uber chooses. See how that goes. The low rates are due to an over-supply of drivers, something that happens because it is low-skill flexible work. All that Uber needs to do is limit the drivers on the platform, but that has its own challenges which is why it hasn't been done.
- ilaksh 7y agoAsk the tens of thousands or perhaps million of full time taxi drivers that had to quit their jobs and start 'freelancing' for Uber because there was no more business.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe people complaining about Uber destroying taxis were the taxi companies who owned the medallions. The drivers themselves were paid crap before and they still are. They actually get a higher percentage of the fare now than they did as a taxi driver. But now the fares are lower because the medallion owners aren't artificially constraining supply, which means more people can be drivers. In principle this should result in higher compensation for drivers, because without a huge margin wastefully going to the rent seeking medallion holders there is more demand for car service, which means more demand for labor, which means higher prices for labor. But Uber drivers may not be a large enough percentage of the overall unskilled labor pool to move the needle much on their own, so the low wages are still low.
- manigandham 7y agoBeing a taxi driver was never a good job but taxis still exist, along with limos, shuttles, buses, trucks, ambulances, construction vehicles, and many other transportation positions. Jobs change over time. Driving for a living is slowly declining in demand and you can't legislate your way out of it. How to give people new job opportunities is real valid concern but completely separate from the fact that the vast majority of Uber drivers are not looking for a fulltime driving job.