7 ms·
I kind of doubt this. Too much planning would be involved to: * pay people to add backdoors * tell DARPA * start a marketing arm to convince people to u
by jrockway 16y ago
I kind of doubt this. Too much planning would be involved to:
* pay people to add backdoors
* tell DARPA
* start a marketing arm to convince people to use it
Conspiracy stories very rarely turn out to be true; it's too hard to coordinate all of these efforts.
If it is true, though, it will be interesting to see how much code Cisco jacked from OpenBSD. (It's allowed by the license, but is probably a hard sell when you tell your Fortune 100 clients that they are just running OpenBSD but at 10000x the cost.)
Incidentally, I use OpenBSD for my VPN. But OpenVPN, not IPsec, as I could never figure it out :)
- binaryfinery 16y ago"Conspiracy stories very rarely turn out to be true;" That's because when they are found out to be true, nobody calls them "Conspiracy stories" any more. We call them "scandals". (ref: "Watergate Scandal"). Note that the perpetrators were indited for conspiracy. "it's too hard to coordinate all of these efforts." You're doing it wrong.
- ynniv 16y agoEvery week you should be allowed to upvote something twice. Conspiracy is pervasive in life. As far as I can tell (and I provide no evidence to back this up), "conspiracy theories" are often correct but lacking the direct evidence to do anything about. Those who discount something as a "conspiracy theory" are usually (a) naive, (b) like being "right", (c) personally benefiting from the situation, or (d) going to find a way to benefit from it. pay people to add backdoors This is hard if you have the money? Done. tell DARPA When the FBI spooks go to the military contrator parties, who else do you think is there? If you know that something is tainted, you tell people who might return the favor. start a marketing arm to convince people to use it Why? It's free crypto. Done. EDIT: A proper response to this kind of situation: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2006694 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2006694
- cafard 16y ago"Conspiracy is pervasive in life." I think a definition of terms would be useful. Cooperation is necessary for much of what one does. At what point does cooperation become conspiracy?
- binaryfinery 16y agoWhen its criminal.
- adambyrtek 16y agoSome conspiracy theories turn out to be true, but the problem is that people abuse this framework to support all kind of weird accusations. It's very convenient, because it frees them from the burden of supporting their claims with evidence. "It's a conspiracy, of course there is no evidence!"
- binaryfinery 16y agoI think its far more common to say "conspiracy theory" as a way to discredit an idea. Take 9/11 for example. Pah! Conspiracy theory. Yet the evidence is that the evidence presented by the government is total bullshit. Which is evidence of conspiracy. What, exactly, happened I expect we will never know. But the evidence is that something happened beyond planes flying into buildings.
- anonymous246 16y ago"it's too hard to coordinate all of these efforts." 3 MILLION people have access to the docs Bradley Manning leaked. ONE leaked it. I think you're overstating the difficulty of coordinating activities.
- lftl 16y agoThe documents Manning leaked weren't really conspiracies. Nothing that I've seen so far is illegal, and most of it isn't even interesting. 3 million people didn't leak it because there was no compelling reason to leak them.
- forwardslash 16y agoThere was the revelation that the US and China worked together, or one might say conspired, to derail the Copenhagen Climate talks: http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,733630,00.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,733630,00.h...
- lftl 16y agoI'll say that I dislike this, but I don't see anything illegal, or even unusual about this. This is absolutely politics as usual, and goes on every day in every country across the world. Every country lies to further their current interests.
- forwardslash 16y agoI was more pointing my comment towards the notion that there was no conspiracy revealed. I do agree that everything thus far revealed by the cables hasn't been illegal in-and-of-itself nor is it all that surprising to those who have a non-romantic view of international diplomacy. It is an unfortunate truth that lying is a natural state of politics.
- cscheid 16y agoNot every conspiracy is illegal or unusual. They're still _wrong_, especially when perpetrated by governments against their people's will.