3 ms·
> As far as I'm concerned, it's a huge failure that, over thirty years after computer programs were explicitly added to copyright law, it isn't clear to what ex
by tzs 7y ago
> As far as I'm concerned, it's a huge failure that, over thirty years after computer programs were explicitly added to copyright law, it isn't clear to what extent APIs are copyrightable, and we have to watch lawyers argue over strained analogies to chapter titles in Harry Potter books.
It was pretty clear, until this case. What's different here is that Oracle initially had both patent and copyright claims, and appeals to cases involving patents go to the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) instead of to the appeals court that normally serves the district court that came from (9th Circuit, in this case).
When an appeal goes to CAFC because of patent claims, CAFC handles the entire appeal. Result: instead of this being decided be an appellate court that has extensive experience in copyright (9th Circuit) in this case, and even with similar issues within copyright, it ends up at CAFC which is not nearly as experienced in the relevant areas of law.
CAFC is supposed to follow the precedent from the circuit the appeal came from in matters like this that hitched a ride with a patent issue, which is why there was so much surprise and consternation at their ruling. As far as I can see, most lawyers and legal scholars though 9th Circuit precedent would result in a win for Google.
Personally, I dislike the way other things piggyback their way to CAFC. Besides the problem mentioned above of it putting issues before CAFC that they are not experienced with, it also makes for weird precedent.
Whenever CAFC goes in a different direction from one of the regular appeals courts, you then have a situation where you effectively have two different rules in that area in that circuit, one for when the case also has a patent issue and one for when it does not.
- kevin_b_er 7y agoCAFC has continually shown itself as a renegade court which might be corrupted or captured by the "intellectual property" industry. We can presume they will consider everything copyrightable and everything patentable. They've continually tried to circumvent supreme court rulings to make things more patentable. The same can be applied to copyright.