5 ms·
Is there anything we can do as developers? Obviously I don't want to DDOS/DOX the supreme court, but can we write letters or do anything else to show _how massi
by exabrial 7y ago
Is there anything we can do as developers? Obviously I don't want to DDOS/DOX the supreme court, but can we write letters or do anything else to show _how massively important_ this is?
EDIT:
For those unable to read between the lines, HN is a large forum read by thousands of people of different backgrounds. Often when someone suggests something, small actions can add up to create a large problem. DDOSing/Doxing is never acceptable for any situation. I want to "do something" but without accidentally creating a problem.
- panpanna 7y agoA lot of people/companies contacted the judges last time but some were actually companies backing Oracle (eg microsoft?) What you can do as a developer is to ensure your company is not using any of oracles cash cows.
- mlinksva 7y agoEFF has collected all of the briefs submitted throughout the dispute at https://www.eff.org/cases/oracle-v-google https://www.eff.org/cases/oracle-v-google I don't recall any computer/software companies actually backing Oracle, other than Oracle itself.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThe article says the BSA (Business Software Alliance) has filed a brief in Oracle's favor. This is their membership: https://www.bsa.org/membership https://www.bsa.org/membership (Obviously this is not a unanimous support list, as I believe Microsoft has filed in Google's favor.)
- Justin_K 7y agoWhy would the thought of DDOSing the supreme court even cross your mind?
- ummonk 7y agoIf every developer wrote a letter to the SC, that might (depending on how they handle such letters) function as an inadvertent DDoS - similar to the HN hug of death.
- JudgeWapner 7y agoHow does it impact us as developers either way? Both are titans that have contributed vital pieces of tech infrastructure as well as committed evil acts in their space. Oracle is arguably more evil here, but is it that big of a tragedy if Google loses? They have obscene amounts of cash; what difference does it make if a pile of cash goes from one evil pocket to another? Please if you downvote give an explanation. I honestly want to know what's at stake here for us.
- lloydde 7y ago> How does it impact us as developers either way? “Treating APIs as copyrightable has a profound negative impact on interoperability and innovation. And it goes against decades of tradition and common practice in the software world.” https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/05/eff-asks-federal-circuit-fix-its-terrible-api-copyright-decision https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2017/05/eff-asks-federal-circu...
- treis 7y agoThis is only true if you exclude the middle ground of APIs being copyrightable with fair use exceptions. In other words, you can't kick start your program by copying the structure of another, but you can create a compatibility layer to your novel program.
- jandrese 7y agoI don't see how creating a compatibility layer makes it fair use. Unless you're only using 5% of the original API or have a strictly educational use you're going to be in violation. Even then you'll need to fight it out in court if the original party is litigious like Oracle and there's absolutely no guarantee that you'll get a jury that understands and is friendly to the concept for Fair Use. Media companies have been basically claiming that Fair Use is a myth for many years now, often successfully.
- treis 7y agoBecause it's transformative: >The Transformative Factor: The Purpose and Character of Your Use >In a 1994 case, the Supreme Court emphasized this first factor as being an important indicator of fair use. At issue is whether the material has been used to help create something new or merely copied verbatim into another work. https://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/fair-use/four-factors/ https://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/fair-use/four-factors/ IMHO simply re-implementing an API is not creating something new. It's just redoing something that has already been done. A translation layer from one API to another is a new thing separate from the original API.
- ergothus 7y agoDonate to the EFF - they write amicus briefs and generally empower the legal profession to have that understanding. That said, courts generally don't focus on "how important" something is - that's supposed to be Congress' job. The exceptions are where the importance triggers some other area of law.
- caymanjim 7y agoYou say this as though you'd normally DOS or dox someone you disagree with, or that it's a normal course of action for a developer, or something that a reasonable person would consider.
- jcranmer 7y agoThere is already a long list of amici curiae filings at SCOTUS asking them to look into this case and helping inform them: https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/google-llc-v-oracle-america-inc/ https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/google-llc-v-ora... This is still in certiorari phase (i.e., SCOTUS hasn't decided whether or not to hear it), but there's already 15 separate briefs filed all urging SCOTUS to hear the case, and only Oracle is opposing it. There's nothing you can do at this point to urge SCOTUS as to whether or not to hear it. Assuming that SCOTUS will hear the case (which is probably pretty likely--this is a Big, Important IP question which means the only reason not to hear it is if there's a better case coming along soon to hear it), the best chance at influence is an amicus curiae at that point. Talking to your company's legal representation is probably the best bet to get on one of the amicus curiae, but if you don't have any legal experience, you're probably not going to be capable of writing an effective amicus.
- jandrese 7y agoThere is also the not-unlikely possibility that the court takes the case but then rules in an extremely narrow way that leaves open the larger question about the copyrightability of APIs.
- jcranmer 7y agoThe petition for certiorari has to explicitly lay out the questions that are to be answered by SCOTUS. In this case, the questions are: (1) Whether copyright protection extends to a software interface; and (2) whether, as the jury found, the petitioner’s use of a software interface in the context of creating a new computer program constitutes fair use. Considering that SCOTUS is being very directly asked to rule on the copyrightability of APIs (and fair use, if they are copyrightable), not reaching the question is pretty much only possible if they dismiss the case as improvidently granted.
- Sacho 7y agoIt appears they denied the previous petition from Google in 2015. Why is this one different?
- kevin_b_er 7y agoI'm not sure what can be done. The entire software industry is threatened by Orcale's greed at this point.