7 ms·
That's like saying McDonald's has a monopoly on what food appears on their menu. It's non-sensical as a complaint.
by CharlesW 7y ago
That's like saying McDonald's has a monopoly on what food appears on their menu. It's non-sensical as a complaint.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoIn United States v. Microsoft Corp.[0] it was determined that Microsoft abused monopoly it's power by simply preventing OEMs from removing internet explorer. Apple demands that all web browsing is done via Safari on IOS as I understand it. [0]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_C....
- npunt 7y agoMicrosoft had a 90%+ market share in computer operating systems, aka a monopoly. So there's that.
- Veen 7y agoBut Microsoft did have a monopoly in the browser market at that time. Apple doesn’t have a monopoly in the browser market or the phone market or the app market. You can’t abuse a monopoly you don’t have.
- mbreese 7y agoThe monopoly was in the OS market. Microsoft got in trouble for trying to use that monopoly to create a new one in the nascent browser market.
- toasterlovin 7y agoAnd Apple has no monopoly. Having a monopoly is a pre-requisite for being found guilty of using a monopoly to leverage your way into an adjacent market. End of story.
- tooltalk 7y agoQCOM doesn't have a monopoly in the baseband market either, yet Koh's court found QCOM's monopoly there. The FTC simply redefined a market where QCOM had a dominant marketshare -- the "premium" modem market (LTE) -- for Koh to come to that ruling. So I guess if someone can prove AAPL's dominance in "premium" PC, education, or some niche subgroup in PC market, it too can be in trouble.
- halter73 7y ago> So I guess if someone can prove AAPL's dominance in "premium" PC, education, or some niche subgroup in PC market, it too can be in trouble. If Apple used its dominance in some niche subgroup PC market to force buyers to pay a percentage of the total cost of all USB-C devices they buy, including non-Apple devices, to Apple to pay for Apple's patents related to USB-C. And if those buyers were companies like Best Buy that needed to be able to buy Apple devices or else lose access to over half their market. And if Apple refused to sell buyers any devices unless they agreed to those terms. And if Apple promised during standardization of USB-C to offer licenses to said patents on FRAND (fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory) terms. Then that analogy might hold a little water.
- awad 7y agoYou can use Chrome on iOS.
- tracker1 7y agoChrome on iOS still uses Safari's renderer and JS engine.
- dwaite 7y agoMy understanding is that Google is allowed to use their own renderer and their own Javascript engine - as long as it doesn't do JIT compilation. The ability to mark pages or files as executable is a platform security model thing. Chrome uses WebKit because Google would rather use a WebKit/JSC engine than a slow Blink/V8 engine - especially since Blink is a WebKit fork.
- tracker1 7y agoIf the alternative is something so slow that nobody would actually use it, does the why really matter that much in practice?
- eadmund 7y agoNo, the case of Apple is more like McDonald's being able to prevent its customers from ever eating food not signed-off on by McDonald's.
- 100100010001 7y agoHow so? Apple can’t stop you from using a different phone.
- closetohome 7y agoI think people are confusing mild inconvenience with monopolistic oppression.
- joezydeco 7y agoThey can do that, if you are sitting in a McDonald’s dining room. They can’t stop you from walking over to Burger King.
- unixbeard1337 7y agoIt's analogous to McDonald's selling you a dining room and then regulating what food you can eat in it.
- toasterlovin 7y agoExcept you're perfectly aware of that fact when you buy the dining room.
- binarybits 7y agoThe question is how you want to characterize an iPhone. If the phone is Apple's property that they're letting you use, then Apple's app store restrictions are analogous to McDonalds deciding what going on their menu. If the iPhone is a product that you bought from Apple, then Apple's app store policies are equivalent to GE selling me an oven that will only cook food purchased from GE's grocery store. Luckily, oven technology doesn't really make that business model feasible so GE doesn't try to do it. But I think there are reasons for antitrust authorities to take a careful look at the behavior of companies that do have this kind of power over their customers.
- mason55 7y agoBut none of those things are a monopoly. A GE oven that only cooks GE food isn’t a monopoly, it’s just a shitty oven. Plus, monopolies aren’t illegal, using them anti-competitively is. So the analogy would be GE buying or putting out of business all the other oven makers, then saying you can only cook GE food in a GE oven.
- jdmichal 7y agoIt's maybe not a monopoly, but it's definitely tying, which is still covered under anti-trust law.
- p1necone 7y agoWhat? That's not the same thing at all. McDonald's doesn't let third party companies sell food on their menu. McDonalds is a place, not a platform. Your analogy falls short in so many ways I have to assume you're being disingenuous.