6 ms·
> Outside the city, populations are decaying year after year, and the only chances of benefiting from global economic trends are in the city. We keep expecting
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
> Outside the city, populations are decaying year after year, and the only chances of benefiting from global economic trends are in the city.
We keep expecting the internet to change this, and it keeps not happening. Why doesn't it? Why haven't remote workers or remote teams spread into the smaller towns and countryside?
- tehbeard 7y agoIgnoring internet access issues in rural areas, What is there to do in your free time in smaller towns and the countryside? That's the reason.
- PerfectElement 7y agoIt depends on what you like to do. Countryside living is appealing to many people.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoTechnologists are probably not typically the ones that find it appealing.
- ghaff 7y agoWhat do you think is so special about technologists that they uniquely prefer urban (or suburban) living?
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIt really isn’t a mystery: they like tech obviously, they probably went to a big university with lots of diversity and eat out options, they feel a strong need to network. All hint toward city living rather than country side living. Also, many techies in the USA aren’t even Americans, they are even less likely to be craving for the countryside lifestyle.
- ghaff 7y agoI think you're projecting your preferences and those of your circle. The significant majority of the people I work with at a fairly large tech company live in exurbs/suburbs/country. Relatively few live in the nearby major city.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoNone of that is countryside or even small town America.
- ghaff 7y agoYou can define terms however you like but I do live in a town with a population of about 7,000 people and together with my two neighbors we're on about 100 acres adjacent to town forest. Sure, it's not some remote small town where you have to drive 3 hours to get to the nearest Walmart but it's not exactly urban--at least the way most people use the term--either. There's a pretty broad continuum between living/working in a city where you can walk to everything and living somewhere that's hours from "civilization."
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoYes, but you’ve just described about half of the Bay Area, or West Chester county, or even Queens (let alone Long Island).
- ghaff 7y agoIt describes a lot of places. If someone argues that tech people tend to prefer the greater metro areas (combined statistical areas) of large cities rather than truly rural areas (as defined by the census), I don't think there's much argument. Of course, by the numbers, so does a significant majority of the US population. But that's a lot different from people arguing that tech people like big cities specifically, as that tends to suggest that they can walk to coffee shops, take public transit to work, etc. which does not describe the bulk of the space in greater metro areas.
- nostalgk 7y agoOn the contrary, most of my peers are either living in the country on their own land or saving to do so. Especially if it's within driving distance of a city.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThat’s anecdotal, but I’m willing to bet the typical technologist is not like your peers.
- nostalgk 7y agoAs is your claim. What is the typical technologist? My peers, along with me, live outside of one of the biggest cities in the Midwest, and work remotely or commute to and from. I would consider us part of the prevailing technological culture.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoTrue. We need real data to say otherwise, but we already know most techies live in cities anyways, you can claim that is not within their desire and they would like your lifestyle better, but I would claim it is as they want.
- nostalgk 7y agoI would claim that the majority population of techies probably do desire to live in cities and hubs in which there are large communities of other techies, you're right. My point is just that there is also a sizable community of people who work in tech who also enjoy living outside the city, and can still enjoy a city lifestyle from time to time as well. I often notice that this sizable community is brushed to the wayside because they aren't the in-crowd of city-based IT enthusiasts, with their regions being considered "flyover" and their opinions devalued. Yet still, in small towns, we do have Slack and hackerspaces and lots of professional development, just like the cities.
- ghaff 7y ago
- sudosteph 7y agoPlenty of introverts who like building things (the stereotypical technologist) are into it. More income savings to spend on new gadgets, space to build things (plus No HOAs to say you can't run a business or put up a big antenna on your property), and relative peace and quiet in your environment are quite appealing. I know some brilliant technologists who work remote and wouldn't trade their life-style for any salary in a big city. I'm a city-lover myself, but easily understand the appeal of working in tech while living in the country.
- neom 7y agoExcept then your best friend moves to San Fransisco and now you have no friends, so you move to San Fransisco and then you live in San Fransisco (I'm not bitter or anything....) :(
- tdb7893 7y agoRide horses, hang out with friends, play video games, go hiking, pay music with friends, cook food, shoot guns, watch Netflix, play poker with friends. My wife grew up in a small town and she always found stuff to do, it's really not that hard depending on what you like. Edit: to add some more specific flavor my wife liked to ride horses, play her guitar, swim, and watch TV. Her parents were pretty busy but they would hang out with friends and liked to cook and play in what was essentially an Irish folk band in the area.
- nostalgk 7y agoExactly, all of these things. The notion that city living is the only way to live and that smaller towns are simply flyover communities is pretty ignorant. I love visiting the city as well, there are excellent opportunities like restaurants and events, but the culture is different and I am always happy to return to my small town hobbies.
- arethuza 7y agoGarden, walk, cycle, fish, run, hunt, sail, ride horses, keep bees, kayak, swim, view historical stuff.... [I'm just naming things that people do within a couple of km from where I live]. NB Personally I garden, walk and look at mysterious old stuff. But plenty of people doing the others. Edit: Until 2 years ago I lived in the very centre of Edinburgh - which is quite a nice place to live. So far I've never regretted moving out of town to the country.
- switchbak 7y agoI've got gigabit fibre running to my house, and some of the best natural beauty and outdoor activities available anywhere just minutes away. Mountain biking, climbing, white water paddling, kite surfing, trail running, sailing, hiking, etc. Let me assure you, there is plenty to do if you're into this lifestyle. Don't knock it just cause it's not something you're into. I think as more people get good remote jobs that many of them will realize that living in nice small towns is really desirable.
- rootusrootus 7y agoThat sounds wonderful. Can I be your neighbor? Edit: Ah, I'd have to move to Canada. Not a deal killer :)
- 0xffff2 7y agoLucky you. I have a house just outside a small town of 700, about 30 miles outside a town of 30,000. I can't even get DSL; I'm stuck with terrible satellite internet when I'm out there. I really can't wait for Starlink. If it works as promised, I'll finally be able to ditch my Silicon Valley apartment and go full remote.
- rb808 7y ago> there is plenty to do if you're into this lifestyle I wonder if there are fewer people that like the outdoors lifestyle now. New generation prefers xbox and eating at restaurants and doesn't like yard work or hiking. I'd love to move somewhere quieter but my wife would kill me.
- fzeroracer 7y agoThere are plenty of cities where this is also the case however. You're also not locked into the local area only (where the nearest airport might be hours away) and your options for everything else other than leisure aren't limited Living in small towns is incredibly stifling for people that prefer to use their feet to get around, at least in America. It always seemed fittingly ironic that people move to small towns so they can drive out to their outdoorsy hobbies.
- landryraccoon 7y agoI don't think the problem is not having stuff to do, the problem is finding people to do it with. Small towns and nature have no end of things to do. But it has way fewer people. I think modern society has a bigger problem with loneliness than with not having enough entertaining activities.
- circlefavshape 7y agoThis. I live in the countryside, 5km from the nearest village (<1000 people). It's a very pleasant village, and I know plenty of people in it, but the population is too small and sparse for me to find a group of people like me. To hang out with my real friends I need to go into the city
- thrower123 7y agoA whole lot more than you can do if you are stuck in an urban area or worse, a suburban hellscape. At least if you like doing things outside, or want to do more worthwhile things than mindless consumer hedonism. Go fishing, go hunting, go hiking, do some trailriding on an ATV or a snowmobile or a horse. Plant a garden or an orchard and tend to that. Have a barbecue with the neighbors. Get involved with the community. Work up your firewood. You can read books, or watch TV or engage with the internet just as easily as anywhere else, and you can get anything in the world delivered to you with two-day delivery from Amazon. You can look up at night and see the stars, rather than just washed out orange halogen haze.
- madengr 7y agoGuns Archery Model rocketry Ham radio Fireworks
- kawfey 7y ago+1 for ham radio, HF is much better in rural areas since it's farther from manmade electrical noise, however VHF+ is boring due to lack of people (and typically line of sight range) unless you're into satellites, sporadic-E, and tropospheric ducting.
- madengr 7y agoEven then, getting a decent satellite station the the suburbs is problematic. I’d like nice rotor setup with dual band, dual polarized yagi. I have a active loop for HF RX, which does a good job of rejecting local noise, but would still be better in rural area.
- hutgu 7y agoFor anyone who isn't into highly social hobbies the countryside is usually at least equally good. Apart from restaurants and larger selection of food in stores, city life has not changed my free time much at all.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoAmenities and education for your kids, mostly. Big cities have more than just jobs. I think resort communities might do better, like Bali, Jackson Hole, Bend, Gulf Shores, but not Hawaii, COL is just too high. Also, decent schooling for kids is still a problem in those areas.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWhen you said "education", I first thought that you meant college. That's not so much a problem - kids go away to college all the time, and there's online if they don't want that. But primary/secondary schooling... yeah, that could be a concern. On the other hand, that's a concern in the city, too, unless you can afford the suburbs. Even there... we lived in the suburbs, and the elementary school in our area was ranked in the bottom third in our state. My wife called the vice-principal there, and asked why we should put our daughter in their school. He said, "Well, going here can toughen kids up." Becoming tough was not our priority for our daughter, and we didn't put her there. (We homeschooled, but I recognize that most people won't want to go that route.)
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoYou have options in the city. Make a lot of money? Private school is an option. I live in the Seattle area, according to Zillow Seattle schools are ok, nothing special but definitely better than Spokane or Walla Walla schools. And then there is Bellevue, mercer islands, north lake WA, and so on that are all 10s. Works well enough. I can see it as a huge problem if one lives in Chicago, I guess. The Midwest isn’t a great place for that kind of thing.
- debaserab2 7y agoActually I think it's exact opposite - the midwest is great for k-12 education. Illinois is ranked #7 overall in k-12 education (washington sits at #19 for comparison). Most other midwest states are somewhere in the top 20 [1]. [1] https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings/education/prek-12 https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings/education/p...
- e40 7y agoWhy haven't remote workers or remote teams spread into the smaller towns and countryside? Because when you live in an area you become entrenched. I would love to move out of the Bay Area for cheaper everything, but all my friends and family are here. This is the element that people forget about in these discussions.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> but all my friends and family are here. Ah. That explains quite a bit, actually. But it doesn't explain everything. It explains why people who are there stay there. It doesn't explain why people have to move there to make decent money.
- cameldrv 7y agoBecause there are only a small portion of jobs that can effectively be done remotely. A few long-term trends I see driving the move to big cities are: 1. Jobs are becoming more specialized, and so it's more difficult to find every specialty you need for many businesses in a smaller town. 2. There are many more two earner households. In the past, many people would conduct a job search over a wide area and move the family for the man's new job. If the woman already has a job she likes, especially one that would be hard to replace in another town, the couple is much less likely to move for a job opportunity. 3. Businesses know this and have noticed that it has become harder to recruit people to move to a smaller "company town" for an opportunity. They therefore have tended to locate new operations in bigger cities.
- paganel 7y agoCase number 2 applies to my situation, as I’ve been able to work remote for almost half a year now but my gf has to be in the office.
- jandrewrogers 7y agoThese locales are severely lacking in amenities that cater to people with incomes significantly above the national median. In most rural and semi-rural areas in the US and elsewhere, the household income is well below the national level, so the goods and services available in those communities reflect that. This puts a very low ceiling on the lifestyle that is achievable living in these locales even if you could afford it as a remote tech worker. Most people who earn $100+k aspire to more than a lower-middle class lifestyle, which makes most rural towns unattractive. Small semi-rural towns composed primarily of high-income people exist but they are the exception rather than the rule, and the lifestyle in these places often suffers from a high percentage of part-time residents.
- chrisco255 7y agoWhat goods and services, exactly? Other than a vast array of restaurants and night life to choose from, struggling to see what you mean here. It doesn't have to be a "rural" city in the traditional sense. Plenty of 100-250K population cities out there.
- dillonmckay 7y agoYou named 2, also a selection of retail stores, besides Walmart, is also nice.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThere are a lot of things that you get anywhere that FedEx delivers. Of course, the delivery charges may eat into the rural cost-of-living advantage...
- dillonmckay 7y agoSometimes it is nice to try on clothing or shoes before you buy them, or not have to wait at least 2 days to receive something you may wind up returning.
- ta1234567890 7y ago> We keep expecting the internet to change this, and it keeps not happening. Because the Internet has enabled clusters like Silicon Valley or Hollywood to be even more prominent. Before the Internet, if you wanted to do something in tech, you probably would have only looked for local opportunities, but now because of the Internet, you have the impression that SV is almost the only place where you can do something notable in tech. Big names have gotten bigger and global, a lot of them becoming de facto monopolies. The Internet makes access to information easier, but at the same time it narrows information sources enormously because it puts all of them on the same playing field, leaving only very few winners. For example, pre-internet you might have read your local paper to be up to date with the news, now instead you probably read the news at the website of a global news company. It's almost impossible for the local paper to compete with the global company. Basically the Internet has created a global winner-takes-all market where everyone is competing for attention, and mostly only the big players win, or at least that's what the Internet makes us believe.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 7y ago>Basically the Internet has created a global winner-takes-all market where everyone is competing for attention, and mostly only the big players win, or at least that's what the Internet makes us believe. Numbers such as market cap, net income per employee, and median average salary clearly indicate this is true.
- SantalBlush 7y agoWith regard to places like Hollywood and SV, they almost certainly benefit from large economies of agglomeration, particularly from having a large and very specialized local labor pool. The network effects via the internet must not be comparable (yet).
- njepa 7y ago> Because the Internet has enabled clusters like Silicon Valley or Hollywood to be even more prominent. And bigger cities in general. But I also think people tend to underestimate changes. Small and medium sized cities have been hit hard by the recession and rising housing markets. There are increasingly no good deals to be had anymore. Unless you go to Chiang Mai or something.
- remote-hellzone 7y agoPeople toss around "remote work" like it's nothing at all. Like it's easier than face to face work. It's not easier. It's not easy. Social interaction via remote is hard. Very hard. I can't emphasize the difference in the level of skill, and change in personal style demanded to make it work. True. There are some negatives that go away. Physical harassment all but disappears. But not the psychological barbs. Those still cut. Is there an "efficiency" bonus? Yes. No commute. Lower carbon footprint. Less space wasted on offices, supplies, personnel specific to offices. Sure. All at the cost of sanity. There are so many more interpersonal blind spots. The more remote you are, the more expendable you feel. Suddenly, it's all the more volatile that your paycheck and lifeline seems, because even without sentimentality, face to face, you sense a firmer bond. Even if you don't like your colleagues, there used to be a gut sense of mood and morale. Now? Total mystery. Less predictability than a five day weather forecast. Most people aren't solvent enough, financially, to feel okay about braving the high seas like that. Sorry. Remote work isn't the panacea some claim it to be. I think there's a lot of big talk coming from people who have never done it, and wouldn't even think to try it themselves. And if they did it experimentally, they'd likely forget to model authentic risks will real and punishing consequences for failure to perform. Try it that way, and you'll sing a different tune. It's not at all fun.
- manfredo 7y ago> We keep expecting the internet to change this, and it keeps not happening. Why doesn't it? Why haven't remote workers or remote teams spread into the smaller towns and countryside? Because there are benefits to living in the city even if your job can be done in arbitrary locations. It's easier to deliver goods and services (on a per capita basis) in dense population centers. It also means that people have much more options for entertainment, dining, socialization, dating, and plenty of other advantages. Really, the only disadvantage is space but that's mitigated by skyscrapers (effectively multiplying the surface area of a city). Urbanization is directly correlated to educational attainment, income, and other quality of life metrics. Urbanization is also nothing new. Humanity as a whole has been on an continuous overall trend towards urbanization since the industrial revolution. Really, the only reason why we weren't urbanized until now is because postindustrial societies couldn't function without >70% of their population working in agriculture.