5 ms·
This is wrong on so many levels. First off, everyone at Netflix knew that DRM wouldn't stop piracy. They knew what Bittorrent was after all. Google didn't se
by jedberg 7y ago
This is wrong on so many levels. First off, everyone at Netflix knew that DRM wouldn't stop piracy. They knew what Bittorrent was after all. Google didn't sell Netflix anything. Netflix does care about cross browser experience. But you know who doesn't?
The content owners. They wouldn't sign contracts without DRM, because for some reason they think DRM works. Or at least it stops the causal pirates. The ones who would just do a Save As...
And before anyone goes down the "well why isn't Netflix's originals DRM free?" road, for one, Netflix doesn't make those, other studios make them and then sell it to Netflix exclusively, so once again, it's up to the movie studios as to what goes into their contracts. And secondly, even for the stuff Netflix makes itself, the entire streaming infrastructure is set up for DRM. It would actually be really complicated to offer just a couple of items DRM free, with lots of if/then code branches.
Disclaimer: I worked at Netflix but this is all my own opinion, not the company's.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y ago> And before anyone goes down the "well why isn't Netflix's originals DRM free?" road This was the reason why I terminated my Netflix contract at the end of the free month. When I'm paying for something, I expect at least the quality that pirates get, but due to DRM requirements, I was stuck with 720p on my setup (and support wasn't particularly keen on acknowledging that DRM was the reason). I might have put up with it for third party content, but certainly not for the Originals.
- bscphil 7y ago>This was the reason why I terminated my Netflix contract at the end of the free month. When I'm paying for something, I expect at least the quality that pirates get, but due to DRM requirements, I was stuck with 720p on my setup (and support wasn't particularly keen on acknowledging that DRM was the reason). I don't know about the individual you spoke to (in general I'm skeptical that support agents are up to date on "technical" issues), but Netflix's own support docs explicitly say that Chrome and Firefox (at least) don't get more than 720p streams. https://help.netflix.com/en/node/23742 https://help.netflix.com/en/node/23742 The reason for this is DRM: in Edge and other software that gets 1080p and above, the decryption is done in hardware that is tougher for pirates to break. Widevine is a software DRM scheme that pirates are generally believed to have already broken. So Netflix limits Chrome and Firefox users to 720p.
- lone_haxx0r 7y agoDo they also require HDCP for it to work?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 7y agoThey did have support docs stating the limitations. The agent also seemed to be well aware of the reasons for the limitations, but it sounded very much like there was a policy preventing him from confirming that when I directly asked whether it's due to DRM requirements. It also seems that on Linux, you can't officially get more than 720p. Looks like Netflix still doesn't want my money. (I know that there are hacks and extensions that allow some additional resolutions on some setups, but given that it's a DRM thing and not a "we don't believe the browser can handle it", I expect those to break more often than I'm willing to tolerate for a service I'm paying for.)
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoRealistically there's no incentive for them to provide DRM-free content. All the arguments just boil down to "we can't profit off it so we'll just support the status quo". Pretty bullshit defense of netflix's values IMHO.
- nyuszika7h 7y ago> It would actually be really complicated to offer just a couple of items DRM free, with lots of if/then code branches. It's literally just an "isDrm": false in the manifest. They already do that for trailers and some extra content.
- jedberg 7y agoThat non-DRM content is delivered by a different infrastructure that is designed for speed, so that the user has a quick experience, but that system isn't designed for full length content.
- ndiscussion 7y agoHuh, how odd.
- joshuamorton 7y agoIt's not at all odd. It's very likely the same behavior as YouTube ads (which often load instantly) vs videos which need to buffer. They're both likely special cases for content < 1 minute long that you expect 20 or 30% of visitors to see.
- sonnyblarney 7y ago"They wouldn't sign contracts without DRM, because for some reason they think DRM works" DRM absolutely works, just like the 'war on drugs' actually works. If Netflix allowed mp4's of content to be downloaded, and there were 'no DRM' in the world, there'd be an explosion of 'piracy' (or pick a nicer word). 'Not paying for anything' would be absolutely normative. Netflix would not have a business model, neither would the creators who make stuff for Netflix. Just as if opioids were freely available, your mother who just had jaw surgery and took '3 pills' might want a few more, and a few more, and a few more ... and most of your little cousins at Uni would experiment, and probably one of them would become addicted to the 'Heroin Cola' or 'Heroin Cigarettes' or 'Heroin Vape' or 'Heroin Cookies' that are available every corner store and advertised heavily. Everyone, at some time in their lives would be victim to opioids, it'd cause problems. So they are illegal, and controlled, and you need a prescription in some cases, and the availability is very narrow for most people, they don't have ready access, the legal consequences are rough, and so 'most people' never bother. The game of 'DRM' (and hard drugs) is not to 'stop all' so-called piracy, it's to keep a limit on it. This is a game of Supply and Demand, not a game of absolutes. As it stands, in 2019 - if you want to watch films, you pretty much have to pay HBO, Netflix, Cable, iTunes for most high quality stuff. 'Bit Torrent' for example, is a fairly ugly experiential barrier for consumers, and it helps prove that DRM works - not the other way around. 'Bit Torrent' is way beyond most people's material capability, moreover, you kind of have to really look for stuff, know where to find it, possibly wait forever for stuff to download, you expose yourself to all sorts of creepy stuff and spyware - it's a 'bad experience'. The state of DRM today is that it's not exactly easy or convenient for regular people to get a copy of the latest Avengers in decent quality - the evidence for this is easy: because they are paying for it (otherwise they would not). Of course, the economic realities of that system can't be ignored either: if there is no money, there is very little content. Podcasts and a lot of decent music would survive, but anything that required production wouldn't. As for Google, Netflix et. al. - they are 'all in on it'. We can't point the finger at one point in the value chain. Google does things because entities like Netflix will need it. Netflix does it because content producers need it. Content creators need it because they have to pay writers, directors, actors, set designers, and of course take a big risk every time as most content that's made flubs. I understand ideals such as 'freedom of information' etc., this is fine, we should always be talking about DRM, but the level of cognitive dissonance on this issue is painful. It's very expensive, and very risky to make such content, and frankly, there are very few making huge money from it. If we want that stuff, we have to pay for it. There's no way around that. Edit: I worked with the music industry in developing a content delivery system (it didn't work out). Yes, it was shocking the level naivte and lack of understanding going on there, which is partly why we dropped the project. There were (and continue to be) some really difficult things about that industry that made it ready for destruction (among other things). Specifically how the unions have worked out their 'rev-share' agreements with respect to minimum revenue per song, etc.. Instead of % rev-share, they have hard minimums like 15-25 cents for certain entities (i.e. writers/composers - this was 10 years ago I fail to remember the group). This poses some ugly realities on price points, but also 'bundling' of music. I suggest that the 'real market value' of most songs, even in a 'fully DRM'd world' is much less than $1. Because of those 'ancient' pacts written by the Moses's of Music Industry, which nobody seems to have enough leverage to influence - it's nary impossible to sell or distribute music cheaply back in the day. If the labels, writers, composers, performers had of 'adapted their model' it's possible they may not have been wiped out, granted, as I noted below, music is different than video. We have to look at Google's decision in the context of the entire value chain: points of consumption, distributors, producers, and the various creators etc..
- sonnyblarney 7y ago"First off, everyone at Netflix knew that DRM wouldn't stop piracy. They knew what Bittorrent was after all." The objective of DRM is not to stop piracy, it's to put the thresholds of difficulty or labour beyond the reach of most people. Which it does, as evidenced by the robust revenues of things like films in iTunes, otherwise, that business could not exist.
- jedberg 7y agoBut yet none of the music in iTunes has DRM and yet it also makes robust revenues. DRM doesn't really stop anyone -- it's convenience that people care about. Otherwise no one would pay for music.
- sonnyblarney 7y ago"But yet none of the music in iTunes has DRM and yet it also makes robust revenues." This is totally misleading. The music industry was wiped out and digital revenues are net, a fraction of what they would be. The 'new equilibrium' on the Supply and Demand curve is now 'iTunes' and a few other things. So yes, in this new crappy market, some people can make money, but it's bad. " DRM doesn't really stop anyone -- it's convenience that people care about" You've contradicted yourself in the same statement. We know 'DRM' won't stop 'everyone', but it's totally misleading to say 'DRM won't stop anyone'. Everytime someone buys a piece of media DRM 'has stopped someone' Every Netflix subscriber is an example of 'DRM stopping someone' Every iTunes film purchase is an example of 'DRM stopping someone' ... because, as you point out 'nobody would pay for music' - or any other form of content, if they didn't have to. So, DRM puts the 'Supply and Demand' equilibrium up pretty high for most video. Studios can still make money 'the old way' using our current DRM systems. In music, for reasons of how it's consumed etc., the 'old ways' are destroyed, so they've had to adjust to a new equilibrium. It's a really difficult argument to have with HNers, I'm more interested in what kind of logic is going on in their minds. If movie studios and netflixed released their mp4s, with no DRM or copyright protections, then everyone, including my non-tech savvy mother would just go to the widely available resources found on Google, and just 'watch it for free'. Obviously this would wipe out film production. If we want films, which are expensive to make, we have to pay for them, one way or another. There is no way around it.