11 ms·
First, using an arbitrary number of stars is part of the problem. Too much opportunity for legitimate differences of rating to come into play. Just make the q
by rootusrootus 7y ago
First, using an arbitrary number of stars is part of the problem. Too much opportunity for legitimate differences of rating to come into play. Just make the question "would you do business with this driver/rider again?" and leave it at that. At the very least the rating should be market-specific, since there is so much cultural influence over such ratings.
Second, Uber should not be making the choice based on some arbitrarily chosen numerical value. Present the rating to the drivers, maybe with some comments, let them choose who they want to take. After all, if Uber isn't employing the drivers and is just the middleman, wouldn't they want to avoid being seen as a crucial decision maker?
- mirceal 7y agothis is already happening. the driver does see the rating and does decide if they want to pick you up or not. effectively, if you have a low rating you will have troubles getting a ride today without uber banning you.
- Hydraulix989 7y agoI think in Uber Pool, the driver is automatically assigned the rides with no confirmation step?
- Jommi 7y agoNot always true. Not picking up is highly disincentivized.
- woliveirajr 7y agoI heard from a Uber driver that she was told to avoid passengers that are below 4.7. Only time she didn't follow the rule, the passenger changed a lot of details during the trip (I don't have money, can we stop a while at some bank while you wait in the car?, Could you take me some blocks ahead?, and some other weird things). And even with she complying with those requests, she got one star in the end. So, yes, passengers are also rated and some drivers take actions based on that.
- petre 7y agoI'd probably flat out rate these annoying passengers with one star or maybe even tell them to get a hike.
- bena 7y agoThat happens because of rating inflation. If everyone just used the system where 3 was the average rating instead of 5, then he'd be in a much lower range. But since everyone got in their heads that anything lower than a 5 is somehow an assault on the other party, 5s are the "average" rating and there is no way to distinguish between average and good. You only know that he was bad enough to get dinged .3 stars over the course of his history with the app.
- m11a 7y agoThe issue with this rating inflation is that it's a recursive effect. If the majority end up treating 5 as average, then you also have to do the same and go with how the majority ends up using the rating system, which in turn forces even more people to use that definition of ratings, and so the cycle continues. If you hold 3/5 as your average when 5/5 is held as the average for most people, you're just hitting the driver with a "this was awful" effectively. This rating scale allows for some form of categorisation of the levels of 'badness' of the drive (e.g. differentiating between dangerous driving and jerky driving, between rudeness and general discomfort), but doesn't allow 'above satisfactory' to be separated from good or excellent. But perhaps that's what Uber is going for with the rating system; maybe their intent is that 5 is meant to be 'above satisfactory' and anything better than that should be a 5 + a tip? If that's not their intent then I have no clue why they haven't redone the rating system already.
- bena 7y agoWho tells everyone to use that scale though? You're presented with a row of stars. Expecting people to read winds up being a big ask. Also, those categories are subjective as well. What's the difference between "bad" and "really bad"? Mutual graded rating systems suck. That's all there is to it. Because no matter what, it turns into currency. "Yes/No" and then base a rating on that. Rotten Tomatoes had it right from the start.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoI saw my girlfriend rate our driver 3/5 stars for a ride that was perfect. When I asked her what problem she had with the driver to rate him so low, she said "huh? it was just an average ride, nothing special." I think of this whenever people suggest that a star rating system is ideal.
- Nition 7y agoThat's how you'd rate a film. 3 stars for something that's fine, five for something that blows you away. Plenty of people see 3 stars = Average, 5 = Amazing, but companies have decided that 3 = Bad, 5 = Acceptable.
- tlogan 7y agoPlenty of people see 1 star = not free, 5 = free
- incompatible 7y ago> companies have decided that 3 = Bad, 5 = Acceptable. Does Uber actually give instructions on how to rate? Does it say a normal, acceptable trip should be 3 or 5? What would a really great trip be anyway, perhaps if the driver says "hey, I just won a lottery and I'm celebrating with my passengers, take $10k", or perhaps something sex related? Once Uber kicks out all the below-average passengers / drivers, will they take into account that the average will be pushed up for those remaining, so they will need to do further rounds of kicking?
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Uber should not be making the choice based on some arbitrarily chosen numerical value It’s tough to judge the measure without understanding the distribution. Uber has to compete for drivers. They aren’t incentivised to throw them away without good reason. Most people I know default to 5 stars. Anything below means something went wrong. (I do 4 for nuisances, like odour; 3 for discomfort, like jerky driving; 2 for minor safety issues, like being on the phone; and 1 for major safety issues, like threatening my fellow Pool passenger or nearly hitting a pedestrian lawfully using the crosswalk. Maybe once every few weeks I’ll rate a ride less than 5.)
- wallflower 7y agoFWIW I’ve heard that a rating of 3 or less for the driver ensures that you are never matched with them ever again.
- wallflower 7y ago> Just make the question "would you do business with this driver/rider again?" FWIW I’ve heard that a rating of 3 or less for the driver ensures that you are never matched with them ever again.
- ahallock 7y ago100% agree. Uber drivers should be able to tag a passenger as "do not accept requests from". Maybe they can; I'm not sure if the driver app has that functionality. But if they truly are contractors, they should be able to pick & choose their clients, so to speak.
- ibejoeb 7y agoI think I like the binary choice. I also think it'd be better to flip it around. These services could ask if anything went wrong, e.g., "Did the driver do anything dangerous?" or "Was the driver discourteous?" Likewise for the rider. Since we're saying anything less than 5 stars is a problem, might as well ask explicitly problems, and if it's not big enough to be worth reporting, we just assume it was good enough.
- berbec 7y agoFor a good while, and possibly still, Domino's Pizza stores were graded on a yes/no "would recommend" (iirc).
- capedape 7y agoI agree, there are cultural and market issues at play. It should as simple as would you drive this person y/n, or anything less arbitrary than the current. I spent some time in foreign markets where Uber no longer exists and my rating took a hit for not knowing the language or being a foreigner, or something. There should be a way to at least correct that. Add to that, in the states now some drivers will rate lower if you don’t tip. I mostly tip and the one and only time I’ve rated a driver low was when he was blasting music, twitching and doing some disco move right turns that were frightening to everyone in the car.