10 ms·
One of the theories behind the massive rise in student loans is "let the market decide!" But I think this shows why it's not a great theory. Markets work reall
by wpietri 7y ago
One of the theories behind the massive rise in student loans is "let the market decide!" But I think this shows why it's not a great theory.
Markets work really well when experienced purchasers make frequent purchases and can readily evaluate the quality and utility of the purchase. E.g., we're all pretty good at picking restaurants. But a degree is a very expensive product sold to people who, by definition, don't know much about the topic. It's no shock to me that a lot of them end up with buyer's remorse. And I'm not seeing how to fix this; schools are getting paid either way, so they're not motivated to solve the problem.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> a degree is a very expensive product sold to people who, by definition, don't know much about the topic We've also insulated everyone but the student from the consequences of the decision. Lenders, universities and counselors have zero exposure to students' lifetime earnings. Making student loans dischargeable (and modifiable) in bankruptcy and requiring colleges who maintain an endowment to guarantee first losses on their students' loans would be good first measures. (Uncomfortably, this will mean a liberal arts degree will become much more difficult to secure a loan for. It will mean fewer schools will be willing to print unlimited English degrees. This doesn't mean we don't need English majors. But if someone cares enough about the future of English majors, they should stand ready to hire them at a competitive wage.)
- jogjayr 7y ago> Uncomfortably, this will mean a liberal arts degree will become much more difficult to secure a loan for. Or colleges might charge differently per credit hour depending on course and major. It's always seemed a bit ridiculous to me that a credit hour of American poetry and a credit hour of propulsion systems costs the same amount, considering the wildly different overhead and input costs. That's how it worked when I was a student in India. Liberal arts, business, and law students are being ripped off right now - there's no way it actually costs that much to deliver most of those courses.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThey aren’t really, since costs in most courses are dominated by facilities (space) and administration. Unless there is a hands on lab for the propulsion systems class, it has an overall cost similar to the poetry one. Even the course instructors are likely to have comparable salaries, unless the poetry class is being taught by an adjunct.
- iguy 7y agoThe price you sell things for is more about what people can pay than what they cost to produce. If jet propulsion majors easily get huge loans, and English majors only get tiny ones, then the university will easily find a way to charge them different fees. Also, the poetry class is certainly taught by an adjunct.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoSupply and demand isn’t related to “cost”, only the price the market will bare.
- MaupitiBlue 7y ago“The portion of the marginal cost curve above its intersection with the average variable cost curve is the supply curve for a firm operating in a perfectly competitive market (the portion of the MC curve below its intersection with the AVC curve is not part of the supply curve because a firm would not operate at a price below the shutdown point).” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marginal_cost#Perfectly_competitive_supply_curve https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marginal_cost#Perfectly_comp...
- Tyrek 7y agoOnly in a perfectly competitive market, which, as you'll note, is the problem here - there's too much distortion around student fees (demand) to truly call the college market perfectly competitive.
- mont 7y agoMy university recently implemented a system where some majors (CS/Engineering/Buisness) students would have to pay ~20% more per semester.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> Making student loans dischargeable (and modifiable) in bankruptcy Technically, they are dischargeable. It's just really hard to do, much harder than other debts.
- __MatrixMan__ 7y ago> We've also insulated everyone but the student from the consequences of the decision I've never thought of it this way. I wonder if in a future with more flexible financial systems (smart contracts, etc.) maybe we could pay with college via a percentage of future earnings for a fixed time. So if you graduate with a doctorate then you owe 10% for 5 years, but a master's is 8% for 3. Or something.
- SmoothHacker 7y agoActually Purdue University is trying to implement a system like that. The University President went on Freakonomics Radio and he discussed a bit about how his school is implementing that very program.
- Forbo 7y agoNot sure why your comment was dead, so I vouched for it and decided to include a link to back up your statement. http://freakonomics.com/podcast/student-debt/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/student-debt/
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> I wonder if in a future with more flexible financial systems (smart contracts, etc.) maybe we could pay with college via a percentage of future earnings for a fixed time. I always find it curious how so many people are eager to advocate literally selling yourself into slavery for a college education, while being so outspoken against the word "slavery".
- groby_b 7y agoOr we could turn education into a common good, instead of a for-profit system.
- peteey 7y agoI did not know electrical engineers did mostly design work until my junior year. A professor was flabbergasted when I asked about learning more about soldering techniques, as if I would end up working on an assembly line. My major was a lucky whim.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoEngineering culture fetishizes engineering and tends to look down on implementation details. Why would you care about spec'ing a standard thread, that's the toolmaker's problem. Why would you care about leaving enough space around components to assemble the device, just outsource assembly to some 3rd world sweatshop full of kids with tiny fingers. And then everyone wonders why new engineers spend their first few jobs trying to design crap that's hyper optimized for what it does but can't actually be built within any reasonable set of constraints. CS isn't quite so bad but you definitely get some profs with that same optimization worshiping attitude.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoInternalizing profits and externalizing losses... Use a crappy JS system that kills mobile devices but lets you deliver the widget in 3 days... and just ask users to upgrade often.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoBut to be a good EE designer designer you would need to know the mechanics of soldering and production engineering and presumably all the stats behind it as well. You cant always rely on the technician remembering how ohms law works for you
- robomartin 7y agoMaybe this is the case today. When I went to school EE’s built things, they didn’t just design them. In fact, you would be looked down upon if you could not assemble your own design properly. Note I said “assemble” not “solder”. At the time (‘80’s) wire-wrapping was a viable prototyping option. Once digital circuit speeds and complexity increased the option evaporated. I must have wire-wrapped thousands of feet of circuits, including a 6502-based multiprocessor robot controller.
- p_roz 7y agoThe government has distorted the market by subsidizing college with guaranteed student loans unable to be discharged in bankruptcy. I’m confident that a fully private market would limit student loans to those with a positive ROI. Of course, that’s politically unpalatable in the US.
- joejerryronnie 7y agoYep, it’s essentially the same mentality that lead to the 08 housing crisis. People’s hearts are in the right place, i.e. we should make it easier for disadvantaged people to get an education/purchase a home. But when you only walk through the use case half way (as politicians always do) and don’t really follow the policies through to their natural conclusions (as politicians never do), you get all kinds of unintended consequences and ultimately end up hurting the people you’re trying to help. This is my biggest fear with the current rise of progressive/socialist interest among young people. All they can see is the free stuff being promised, not the inevitable fallout down the road (the wealthy will be fine, they always are - it’s the young, poor, and disadvantaged who will be stuck with the bill).
- moorhosj 7y agoMeanwhile, other rich countries offer college that is significantly more subsidized, sometimes even free. How do Norway, Sweden, Germany, France and Slovenia offer almost free university tuition without the same problems [1]? Certainly those countries have politicians. EDIT TO ADD: Argentina, Brazil, Poland, Spain, Turkey, Panama, Kenya, Egypt and more [2] [1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/080616/6-countries-virtually-free-college-tuition.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/08061... [2] https://www.edvisors.com/plan-for-college/money-saving-tips/colleges-with-free-tuition/countries-with-free-tuition/ https://www.edvisors.com/plan-for-college/money-saving-tips/...
- joejerryronnie 7y agoI’m pretty sure the way these countries provide much cheaper education is not through unfettered access to loans.
- JCStr 7y agoYou are mistaken, the market is not at all in control and has not been for a very long time now. It's quite baffling even that anyone would say something like that considering the government not only guarantees most student loans and has flooded the market with every lower qualified loans and pushed every more people into ever lower quality schools while simultaneously also importing foreign national "immigrants" that drive down salaries as well as wages. If the market actually worked, you would not be able to get a student loan for a nonsense degree at a nonsense school that dumped you out into a job market in which you could not recuperate the loan within the term. It's quite literally and PRECISELY because the market is NOT allowed to function that the whole system is so perverted and distorted to insane and illogical and irrational levels, which is rather ironic considering Universities are where the smartest people are supposed to be. But I guess when your salary depends on not knowing something...
- nobrains 7y agoAlso, a degree is purchased mostly "once" a lifetime. And you cannot sell your degree, like you can sell a house.
- rayiner 7y agoBlaming the “market” for this is bizarre. You have guidance counselors at government-run high schools goosing demand by telling kids that college is the only way to happy life. Then, the federal government gives them student loans with no credit check or analysis of ability to repay. (More than 90% of student loan debt is owed to the federal government.) Students hand that money over to colleges, which are either directly government run, or heavily subsidized by the government. So where exactly is the “market?”
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThe "market" invented the student loan business - as a vector for short-term profit created by moving wealth from one segment of the population to another while adding nothing of real value. What are the odds the "loan market" will blow up and need a public bail-out, which will be turn out to be vastly more expensive for tax payers than the free fee and maintenance grants provided by other countries?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vonmoltke 7y ago> What are the odds the "loan market" will blow up and need a public bail-out, which will be turn out to be vastly more expensive for tax payers than the free fee and maintenance grants provided by other countries? Virtually zero, because almost all student loan debt is already held by the Department of Education. There is no "loan market" to speak of.
- repolfx 7y agoYou can also see that as meaning the odds are 100% that it'll need a public bail-out - it'll just be a budget transfer to or writeoff for the DoE instead of a bail-out of private sector lenders. Depends how you define 'bail out' :) That said I'm not sure how a loan writeoff is more expensive than just paying the fees outright. Presumably public subsidy is always going to be more expensive than a student loan system.
- dev_tty01 7y agoIf you want to have the market decide, the market has to be in play for the entire process. For example, the loan terms could vary based on the demand for the chosen degree. Or, the loan terms could vary based on the (salary?) success statistics for grads from that school in that degree program. As it is now, there is no up front penalty for choosing a major at a school that is so expensive the student may be in financial bondage for a significant portion of their career.
- wpietri 7y agoStandard market theory is that rational actors will make optimal decisions. In theory, that the effects happen in the future shouldn't matter. Indeed, almost all market choices are prospective. Cars are a good example of something where there's generally no up-front penalty for a bad decision, but people buy cars just fine, and it would be weird to say the market isn't in play there. The problem is that actual humans are pretty different from homo economicus. Iterating on experience is most of how we learn. But people don't really iterate with education; as structured, it's way too big. I think the way to solve it isn't some sort of system of up-front penalties. Personally, I think the problem is that education is treated as a one-and-done thing that happens at the beginning of our lives. But that's when we know the least about the world and ourselves. I think education should be an ongoing process mixed in with work.
- TheBeardKing 7y agoFreakonomics did a recent podcast [1] which examined different methods of student loans and payback programs. One idea was letting businesses "invest" in students directly by paying for tuition, with the student agreeing to payback terms upfront, thereby shifting the risk from the student to investor. [1]http://freakonomics.com/podcast/student-debt/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/student-debt/
- Marxian_Hunter 7y agoWell, it's not really "let the market decide" if loans are virtually guaranteed to any high-school student regardless of the ROI of their chosen degree. When you make debt easily accessible, you make it easier for people to not need to be responsible with their decision making. What the market decides is what wages ought to be. English degrees result in, on average, lower wages than...say...an Engineering degree precisely because the market has not found as much value in yet another English degree. The burden of the debt is not a result of market forces. It's a result of cheap government debt being freely available.
- manfredo 7y agoI don't think the issue is with the market. The issue is that there's strong social signalling to have a college degree (or more cynically, social stigma that comes with not having a college degree. How many times have you head "uneducated" used as a negative descriptor?). The fact that the value of this social signalling is diminishing is, in my opinion, a long term positive change. It does mean that some people who got degrees just for the sake of getting degrees are left out. But they aren't getting shafted by the market, they were put in this situation by skewed social norms around college education.