4 ms·
> we as a society need to ... give them a path forward in life that's what degrees like science/engineering is. It's a path forward. The trades are also one,
by chii 7y ago
> we as a society need to ... give them a path forward in life
that's what degrees like science/engineering is. It's a path forward. The trades are also one, but less "comfortable". What else could've society done?
- cryoshon 7y agoi would say that 90% of people do not have the talent for science/engineering that is necessary to succeed. and even if they did, that would just dilute the wages of those fields and make jobs harder to come by because there would be too many jobseekers and not enough jobs.
- kemiller2002 7y agoPersonally, I think we need to make sure that college does not force you into debt for decades. The rise in tuition over the last 30 years is completely nuts. I think we also need to reevaluate what we really need from people graduating. I think there needs to be a serious discussion around how badly you need a STEM degree for some jobs. Do you need a CS degrees to test an application, probably not. This leads me to another problem, because everyone wants to get a degree in a STEM field for a better job, the pool is diluted. I've met several people with degrees in CS where I seriously question if they actually ever attended class. (Actually from what I've seen the profitable jobs are really just in TE, science and math in undergrad seems to be little better than an English degree as far as decent job prospects.)
- shakyshakyshaky 7y agoProvided a safety net? Collectively decided that education shouldn't be a gamble, and that the way we classify degrees as more or less useful is flawed? Funded more rigorous public education? Reduce the portion of labor value shaved off by executives and shareholders so that workers can live comfortably off of their labor without government assistance? As of now, society is doing practically nothing. Don't act like there's nothing more we can do.
- _hardwaregeek 7y agoThere's something seriously concerning about having the only path forward be science/engineering and trades. That's essentially limiting the liberal arts to only the rich and the delusional. If fields such as architecture, literature, photography, film, journalism are populated by people who grew up with wealth, their privilege be reflected in their work. Would a journalist who grew up in a gated community be the best choice to cover and discuss income inequality and gentrification? Would an architect who has only lived in million dollar houses necessarily understand how to design public housing? The liberal arts fundamentally shape how we view, live and act in the world. If this perspective is purely driven by the rich and the privileged, we risk losing an understanding of how the other half lives.
- nixarian 7y ago>That's essentially limiting the liberal arts to only the rich and the delusional. Not strictly true. If you notice, and you probably have, women are able to get useless degrees and marry a man with a useful one. The reverse is rarely true.
- asark 7y ago> That's essentially limiting the liberal arts to only the rich and the delusional. Fulfilling careers that pay even a semi-decent wage for folks in those majors already kinda are limited to the (relatively, at least) rich. See Graeber's speculation in Bullshit Jobs re: the elevation of the military in certain circles as a reaction to all the doing-good-in-the-world or expressing-oneself while also making-ends-meet jobs being monopolized by those with family connections and/or existing money.
- malvosenior 7y agoOf the fields you list, architecture stands out as different in that it seems hard to self study. The rest have already been totally subsumed by amateurs (photography) or are on their deathbeds (journalism). Youtubers are as well known if not more so than professional actors. Most journalists are already filtered down to the upper classes (the ones with jobs anyway). Being productive in liberal arts, and more broadly, creative endeavors is absolutely attainable without a university degree. The internet has made self study, guidance and distribution open to anyone. It's also decimated many of these fields from a professional perspective.