4 ms·
What other options would you have in such an extreme situation? It seems to make sense to me.
by chrisseaton 7y ago
What other options would you have in such an extreme situation? It seems to make sense to me.
- Hydraulix989 7y agoRight, you have no control over the lift surfaces in this scenario. This would be the equivalent of your steering wheel suddenly not turning the wheels.
- dylan604 7y agoExcept, even if my steering does go out, I can typically hit the brakes and come to a stop. Airplanes do not have that as on option.
- serf 7y agothe SR-71 , at that point in failure, would still have the opportunity to 'hit the brakes' like you would in your car. Both vehicles can still veer wildly out of control even under deceleration, sometimes being exaggerated by the event -- so the plane manual recommends ejection rather than other remediating maneuvers because it's understood that further maneuvers may put the plane into such an attitude that ejection is impossible or futile. So, that said, the SR-71 can still hit the brakes at the point by which their primary control surfaces fail; it's probably just a mighty bad idea to try to do so. There's a few instances in a car that might be a bad idea, too. Imagine the steering wheel falls off in heavy moderate speed traffic -- in many cases it'd be safer to let the car drift across the road crowning and slow itself on roadside barriers than it would be to slam the brakes and take the full force of the traffic behind you colliding with your vehicle. Screw it. Where's my automotive ejection seat?
- FabHK 7y agoYes, airplane check lists do tend to make sense. Still, there is some humour in the laconic terseness and finality of that checklist, which is probably why it was brought up.
- chrisseaton 7y agoIt's an emergency checklist - of course it's terse. I don't know what people expect.
- patrickmcnamara 7y agoIt's funny. That's it. People just find it funny.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI guess I don't really get that then - it's funny that someone designed it sensibly? Not sure where the joke is.
- vokep 7y agoYes! The standard is so senseless that something sensible is hilarious. In a mad world, a sane man is considered mad.
- gouggoug 7y agoI originally downvoted both your comments, but after a few seconds of reflection realized that it's not deserved, and undowned both. I think you _truly_ are missing the point of why it's funny, and that's fine. Humour is a pretty subjective thing in the end.
- Archsys 7y agoLaughter is provoked by a discontinuation of what your brain expects. If you saw a dog walking a man on all fours, you would most likely laugh, because of the unexpectedness. In this case, the unexpected terseness causes laughter. You don't expect what follows to just be "Eject". In a technical context like a manual, you expect what follows to be a detailed list of steps and instructions. When this expectation is shattered, you laugh. Thanks for reading. Have a good day.
- 7y ago