10 ms·
I find it fascinating that at the time, a holistic diet-based solution was considered flakey and rooted in ignorant traditions. And yet here we are almost 200
by steve_adams_86 7y ago
I find it fascinating that at the time, a holistic diet-based solution was considered flakey and rooted in ignorant traditions.
And yet here we are almost 200 years later and many common illnesses are still closely related to diet, and many still feel as though treatment through diet is flakey or inferior to modern drugs or surgery.
It turns out one of the best things we can do for ourselves is eat well and strive to prevent disease before it occurs. If I recall correctly, this is a core tenant of many traditional medicines including traditional Chinese medicine.
I'm not saying we should all start practicing traditional medicine. I just find it fascinating that we have and still often discount traditional knowledge, even after it's been virtually proven for milennia. It's like we throw out the baby with the bathwater.
I hope modern science can find more concrete conclusions around health and diet such that more people might have faith in food as a preventative medicine. To many of us it seems obvious, but to much of the world I suspect it isn't... Just like it wasn't in the Japanese Navy.
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y ago> many still feel as though treatment through diet is flakey or inferior to modern drugs or surgery. This advice literally (using the word in the correct sense) kills people. > I just find it fascinating that we have and still often discount traditional knowledge, even after it's been virtually proven for milennia Check out the infant mortality rates for milennia. I agree prevention is better than cure. That is why I and my family are up to date on all our vaccines. Meanwhile a holistic diet will do nothing to prevent most infectious diseases. The reason we have the luxury to entertain wellness bloggers, traditional medicine and faith healers is that we discovered antibiotics and vaccines. Traditional medicines that work get incorporated into modern medicine. For example if you have a dietary deficiency you will be given supplements and told to eat better. If you have a headache you may take a compound first derived from Willow bark. Modern medicine has even resulted in flour being fortified with vitamin B1 preventing the disease the article refers too! Even modern understanding of healthy eating is derived from modern medicine not traditional 'healing'...
- kranner 7y agoAntibiotics, vaccines and a well-balanced diet are not mutually exclusive, nor did GP imply so.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ericd 7y agoHaving a good diet isn't in any way competitive with being up to date on your vaccines. And a good diet absolutely will do something to prevent most infectious diseases - if your immune system is stressed/compromised due to a shit diet, you're much more likely to be infected when you're exposed. You're exposed to infectious disease constantly, and the reason you don't get sick the vast majority of the time is because you're successfully fighting those off.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nextlevelwizard 7y agoI don't think he is arguing against vaccination or using modern medicine just that people see things like obesity and type-2 diabetes as issues that need to and maybe even should be cured with medicine or surgery while the actual answer is radical change in diet. While I remain skeptical about long term effects of the new fad carnivore diet there is no doubt it has helped a lot of people with inflammation to regain control of their lives. You can look up Mikhaila Peterson's blog or interviews about the subject.
- JamesBarney 7y agoWhy is this the actual answer? Most RCTs show the best obesity cure we currently have is surgery, and it wildly outperforms diet on an intention to treat basis. Diets do terribly in long term RCTs.
- bad_user 7y agoI would add more ... when it comes to chronic diseases, modern medicine is about treatment after the fact, after the damage has occurred and not about prevention. And while it’s incredibly efficient at treating acute conditions, it fails miserably at chronic ones because it’s treating symptoms instead of underlying causes. And sometimes those symptoms might actually be part of the body’s defenses against inflammation, which doctors suppress with pills. The perfect example is elevated LDL cholesterol. This is a marker for heart disease, however it can be high due to hypothyroidism or due to inflammation. LDL cells are actually part of the body’s immune system and by suppressing their synthesis or by accelerating their clearance, the body could be less effective at fighting infections or at repairing arterial walls that have been damaged. Plus pills are a blunt tool with many unintended side effects. It is no wonder then that people taking statins don’t have a reduction in all cause mortality and personally I’d rather die of a heart attack than die of cancer or dementia. Also the DASH diet, the one that is supposed to prevent CVD, is effectively poison as it’s encouraging people to eat ultra-processed food and oils high in omega-6, due to encouraging a big chunk of energy to come from “whole grains” (i.e. products which are often a lesson in chemistry and that might not even contain whole grains due to weak regulation), plus the phobia for saturated fat.
- PhantomGremlin 7y agoit fails miserably at chronic ones because it’s treating symptoms instead of underlying causes I'm not sure if "fails miserably" is the proper characterization. It's just simple capitalism. Just look at statins. They're something that they want to sell you for the rest of your life. Because statins treat symptoms, they're not a cure. But antibiotics? Just 10 days and you're done. Hmmm. Which is more profitable? It it any wonder that the US government is looking into how to fund development of new antibiotics? Same with vaccines. The government has had to step in to fund them.
- refurb 7y agoYet one of the most profitable drug launches ever was a cure for hepatitis C.
- wukerplank 7y agoOne anecdote (not diet related): Last winter I developed knee pain, which turned out to be an inflamation. The typical doctor's response: rest, inject cortisone and apply warming creams. After three months the pain was still there. I went to a kinesiologist. She acupunctured the leg (with added electricity) and cupped the knee. After one treatment (~30 min) the pain was gone for good. I'm sure modern science can find ways, but those must be taught to doctors too. The doctors I've met in my life only treat symptoms (with chemistry) and rarely have a holistic look at what's going on in your body. The ones digging into a problem are rare breed.
- dc_gregory 7y agoIts not surprising that the doctor suggested those things, as its not really the domain they focus on. If you have bio-mechanical pain, its often better to see a physiotherapist, who can better diagnose the underlying reason and help you resolve it properly.
- wukerplank 7y ago> Its not surprising that the doctor suggested those things I saw an orthopedist who claimed to specialize in sport injuries. He immediately understood which part of the knee was affected. Also I'd expect a doctor who's out of his depth to suggest a specialist, not a "meh, try this".
- smacktoward 7y agoAs with engineers, the three least commonly uttered words among doctors are “I don’t know.”
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoApparently, I'm not an engineer.
- LunaSea 7y agoBecause holistic looks have systematically been proven as being non medically effective ...
- powerapple 7y agoThe traditional medicine has worked in the past probably won't work in the future. The reason is that human has been travel a lot, and our fixed diet has changed. Traditional medicine relies heavily on the local environment, local produce and work on local people. These assumption is not true any more. Not only I see the kind of produce grow locally has changed, also the people are different. To my understanding of Chinese medicine, the treatment is personalized. It is not the medicine treating people, it is the doctor. He has a brain full of local knowledge, what water you drink, what season is now, what's going on in your village. These thing does not exist in current culture. Personalized medicine will take its place however. We can then treat people with minimal side-effect.
- onetimemanytime 7y agoIf you get stomach cancer, a holistic diet is not gonna help. And, I don't think there's a doctor that doesn't suggest we exercise, eat the right things etc etc. So the science is there, but people...are people, until it hits them.
- glastra 7y agoAll doctors recommend eating well. But none of them actually knows what eating well means. Or, rather, they might think they know, and still you get ten conflicting answers.
- Mirioron 7y agoDiet and health is incredibly complex. Not only is it about which nutrients we get for our body, but also which bacteria live in our gut and which nutrients they need and in what concentration, so that the balance stays the same. A healthy diet is basically about trying to feed an ecosystem.
- glastra 7y agoDefinitely. However, this has been used to market a myriad of so-called health products that are far from ideal. I follow a carnivore diet and have always been a bit scared of messing up my microbiome, while finding it quite strange that I defecate non-negligible amounts of waste, once a day on average. Only recently has my knowledge gap been filled when I found out that our microbiome can survive solely on amino acids. In fact, all this "gut-brain axis" stuff regarding the production and/or catabolism of neurotransmitters by gut bacteria only makes sense if bacteria can ferment amino acids. Thinking that some bacteria strain can produce neurotransmitters from fibre is an insult to intelligence: where does the nitrogen come from?
- onetimemanytime 7y agoin most cases it's nitpicking. While an apple might be 6.48% better than a pear for a certain person at a certain time, eating an apple is still way better than an order of french fries. We're talking about basics, getting all the vitamins and nutrients needed for a healthy body. Exercise, eat about 5 servings of fruit and veggies a day etc ....
- arvinsim 7y ago> And yet here we are almost 200 years later and many common illnesses are still closely related to diet, and many still feel as though treatment through diet is flakey or inferior to modern drugs or surgery. It certainly doesn't help that the science on diets nowadays contain so many contradicting studies. Moreso that some of them are pushed by powerful corporations for their own vested interests. No one wonder people don't trust them.
- adrianN 7y agoNutrition is just a really difficult field for robust studies. There is an enormous amount of variables you have to control for and the effects you're looking for are likely small or only appear after decades. Strict adherence to the experimental protocol usually can't be supervised, leaving you with observational studies or self-reported data. Blinding is pretty much impossible. Funding is very limited, especially if you don't want to take money from "powerful corporations".
- leksak 7y agoAs a side-project me and a friend have been trying to formalize a set of different rules and models from which to establish a diet. But, as the consumption of certain micronutrients drive the need for others up it's pretty hard to beat just eating a varied diet of mostly clean food. Some people on here mention organ meats, but that does not mean that it's safe to eat liver everyday either.
- nradov 7y ago"Clean food" is such a vague term as to be nearly meaningless.
- steve_adams_86 7y agoTo make matters worse, varying gut biomes and environments tend to yield different nutritional requirements. Amongst other things. I'm not sure we'll ever nail that down. Again though, traditional medicines were aware of this and it was typically recognized that diet was specific to an individual and their environment. There were (and still are) complex systems outlining how foods may affect different people and what it could mean. Still, I'm not claiming anything here other than that it's interesting and worth considering. I take advil when my head hurts and I go to the hospital when I'm sick, and I'm not going to start treating cancer with fungus from my back yard. I just suspect there's a lot of useful knowledge in this tradition.