9 ms·
On the one hand, yes companies should be held accountable to governments everywhere they operate, of course. On the other hand, a multinational company can't
by crazygringo 7y ago
On the one hand, yes companies should be held accountable to
governments everywhere they operate, of course.
On the other hand, a multinational company can't be expected to fly its CEO to a legislative hearing in every country where it operates... you could spend an entire year doing that instead of actually running your company. It's just straight-up logistically impossible, a legitimately unreasonable burden. And if a government legitimately just needs information as opposed to just optics, they don't need the CEO anyways.
Where do you draw the line? It seems pretty reasonable for the CEO to show up to hearings for the country where your company is headquartered... but to send lieutenants everywhere else, no?
- Tyrek 7y agoIt seems equally reasonable to withdraw from doing business in countries where you can't bother to show up for a hearing. Where do you draw the line?
- crazygringo 7y ago> Facebook said is it sending Kevin Chan, its head of public policy for Facebook Canada, and Neil Potts, its director of public policy, to the meeting instead. They're sending multiple people, just not the CEO. It's logistically impossible for a CEO to be in every country at every government's whim, and also run their company. Shouldn't a company be allowed to choose who represents it legally?
- CosmicShadow 7y agoIf you had to make a list of things that you'd think a CEO would be responsible for, this sure seems like one of them. If they've got enough people to send in their place, then they also have enough people to run the company while they do the things like this. It's not like it's just any country's whim, it's a group of G7 countries conveniently meeting next door. If every single little country was calling on them all the time, then yeah maybe, but this seems like one of those "pick and choose" situation where you should send the CEO and Founder.
- sjburt 7y agoIs there any chance that Zuckerberg (or his subordinate) will say anything that everyone doesn't already know? What is the point of him appearing exactly?
- meddlepal 7y agoPoliticians are looking for a soundbite and to humiliate him.
- sleepybrett 7y agoHe should already be humiliated, the fact that he isn't is very disturbing.
- daniel-cussen 7y agoYeah like when Zuckerberg told senator Leahy, he'd get back to him about the issue he was being asked about. It'd be the perfect chance to finally answer that question.
- cookiecaper 7y ago> What is the point of him appearing exactly? Zuckerberg makes great fodder for Bad Lip Reading. :) [0] [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zCDvOsdL9Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zCDvOsdL9Q
- labster 7y agoThe potential, albeit unlikely, that questioning Zuck causes him to feel the smallest iota of shame for his actions in destabilizing democracy.
- bin0 7y ago> If every single little country was calling on them all the time, then yeah maybe, but this seems like one of those "pick and choose" situation where you should send the CEO and Founder. So legal authority is determined by the size of the nation? Or the number? They either can or cannot compel him to do so, regardless of size or number.
- jammygit 7y agoFacebook famously answers in scenarios like this “I’m not sure” in order to avoid answering questions. It is not sufficient for a lackey to go considering this.
- atonse 7y agoA CEO who flies a private jet with great connectivity can't take a day to make a 4 hour flight (where he can continue to work and take calls) to show up? What are you worried about? He's going to be stuck in lines all day and won't be able to work on the plane because he didn't want to buy airplane wifi? If there's anyone who will simply not be disrupted AT ALL by this kind of visit, it's the CEO of a $500bn company who has the resources of a small nation at his disposal. Hell, it's even practically the same time zone.
- nearbuy 7y agoI tend to agree, but in this case it's a meeting of 10 countries representing 450 million people.
- tjpnz 7y agoAnd they had no issue fronting in the US. Clearly the opinions from representatives to those countries are worth less in their eyes.
- pfarnsworth 7y agoDid they send the leaders of those 10 countries, or just the representatives?
- spinach 7y agoAre you seriously trying to equate the CEO of Facebook to 10 heads of state? Just how high of a pedestal do you put FB on?
- barry-cotter 7y agoI’m sure if Heads of State were in attendance Zuckerberg would be delighted to attend. As it is he has nothing to gain from attending a civil servants ego stroking summit. It’s not about what other people think of Zuckerberg, it’s what he thinks because he can do it. The Canadian government is not going to try and prosecute him or shut down Facebook.
- rudiv 7y agoDo civil servants frequently serve in parliament where you're from? In my country, you're proscribed from running in any significant elections (state legislature/national legislature) if you're a serving civil servant. I may be wrong, but I presumed that was the case more places than not. I know that it is the case in Britain, which may be relevant to Canada. (An office of profit under the crown disqualifies one from parliament).
- 7y ago
- bassman9000 7y agoWhere do you draw the line? At the point in which you have 1B+ users, access to mind-boggling quantities of information about them, and unprecedented power over elections.
- TallGuyShort 7y agoIf we think Facebook has "power" over elections, let's just give up on democracy, honestly. That's abdicating any responsibility voters have for their own votes.
- brlewis 7y agoI do think big media have a lot of power to influence elections, but I'm not ready to give up on democracy yet. Also, it's only possible for me to abdicate the responsibility of one voter, not all of us.
- pferde 7y agoBig media has always had a lot of power to influence election. This is mostly about FB being the new kid on this block, and traditional big media not liking it, and firing at FB from all barrels. I do not like Facebook at all, but I can recognize a sustained media smear campaign when it's smacking me in the eyeballs every day.
- cameronbrown 7y agoExactly. It feels like Facebook's other issues like Cambridge Analytica would've been basically ignored by the general public if the media wasn't angry with FB for dominating the attention of its audience.
- ben_w 7y agoAll voters can only make decisions based on the information they can find. If the information comes overwhelmingly from one source (and in this case “Facebook” counts as such for the average voter), then it is imperative that said source represents reality, not propaganda. It is impossible for even the smartest voter to do better by the power of reason alone. Reason isn’t magic.
- mikeash 7y agoI don’t see what's unreasonable about a legislature compelling the appearance of a CEO that operates in their country. If it’s logistically impossible for a large multinational operating in many countries to comply, then maybe its unreasonable for a single company to operate in so many countries. There’s such a weird sense of entitlement here, that companies should be able to do what they want and countries need to accommodate them. There’s nothing that says it must be easy or even possible to operate a company in every country in the world simultaneously. I see no need to draw any lines. If you don’t want to be subject to a particular country’s rules, there is a really easy solution: don’t operate there.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoIMO, it depends whether the law is just and reasonable. I do not think any just or reasonable purpose is served better by having Zuckerberg or Sandberg attend this meeting, as opposed to their lieutenants. No questions will be asked that the lieutenants would not be equally or better equipped to answer. If such questions need to be asked, a letter and response would be fine. If the purpose of the meeting were more than a show trial, I might feel different. But, that is universally not the case. FWIW I would not be offended if Zuckerberg declined invitations from the US congress either, although it's difficult for him to do so considering they could actually arrest him.
- edoceo 7y ago> I do not think But, the Canadian government thinks it. They don't just call up folks on whim. Cost of doing business for FB. CEO gotta do CEO things, which includes the occasional inconvenience of answering a few questions from the Government.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y ago> But, the Canadian government thinks it. ... CEO gotta do CEO things ... Apparently he doesn't, though. What the Canadian government thinks matters only to the degree that they have the power to compel their desired behavior, and the will to use that power. Also, I contend the Canadian government doesn't think there's a just purpose in him showing up. Whether any of the politicians will admit it, I'm sure they are aware that no productive purpose will be served by Zuckerberg's attendance, besides their own political self-aggrandizement. They do not need his input on any proposed policy. They don't need information from him that cannot equally well be acquired from a lieutenant or through a letter. To be clear, I'm not saying these politicians are corrupt or anything. They are doing what is rational from their perspectives. Scoring points against Zuckerberg is a win, since a few constituents would really like it and anyone else won't care either way. But rational, goal-seeking behavior and just behavior are often different things. On the other hand, Zuckerberg is also doing what is rational from his perspective. To give in to this request would probably cost him dearly in time going forward as every politician in the world looking for a distraction would be knocking at his door. Like us all, he has a limited amount of time on this Earth. I doubt he has much desire to spend it as a whipping boy for foreign governments, and so he cannot accede to the request unless Canada ups the ante.
- HenryBemis 7y agoThis is not some small business making minim salaries for the owners. Not your typical corner store who's owners cannot afford the tickets. How fun it would be if all 10 countries block Facebook for a couple of years, now THAT would be fun!! That would teach these thugs a lesson or two about 'corporate responsibility'.
- bin0 7y agoNot sure that this would be legal in many countries. Not showing up is not a crime. Besides, were I Facebook, I would put my best men to work on anti-censorship technology posthaste. Airlift in slips of paper with tor bridges written on them; I don't care. They would figure something out.
- HenryBemis 7y agoNo it is not. So the law-makers should pass a law that says: " when you do business in this country, we pay for your ticket and your time and you bring your a$$ over when we ring the bell, or else you a) better be in a hospital sick as hell so we justify the absence, or b) we shut your business down until you show your face". These thugs should be held accountable. Giving BS excuses about "oh we dropped the ball on the last 10 elections" doesn't cut it. Maybe some citizens are to meek or irresponsible or ignorant; this doesn't mean that these thugs should get a pass.
- vkou 7y ago> On the other hand, a multinational company can't be expected to fly its CEO to a legislative hearing in every country where it operates... you could spend an entire year doing that instead of actually running your company. You don't get called out for a legislative hearing for running a company. You get called out for a legislative hearing when you are running your company poorly, and in opposition to public welfare. If he doesn't want to meet the legal obligations for operating in Canada, Mark is more then welcome to close up shop.
- xxs 7y ago>Mark is more then welcome to close up shop. Still, he might need to pay fines.
- bin0 7y agoLet's say he takes you up on that: * closes all canadian offices * shuts down all canadian datacenters * moves everything back to America What will canadians do? Easy, keep using Facebook with slightly higher latency. He'll put up a bunch of servers right across the border; done. Unless canada wants to pull a China and start censoring the traffic of her citizens, she'd be out of options.
- vkou 7y agoHe will do all that and give up billions in sunk costs and revenue because he can't be bothered to show up to a parliamentary hearing? His board will destroy him. Letting 'jobmakers' hold jobs hostage over their incompliance with the law is like negotiating with a terrorist. It opens the door for others to extort you, and the only correct move is to not do it.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agohow many days of this last year has Zuckerberg been appearing at hearings, I'm sure it sounds like a lot but I bet if we count up the amount it wouldn't seem like near an unreasonable burden yet. Aside from that if any company should be able to have it's CEO work remotely Facebook should, so year he will spend some hours in a hearing, and then answer his email.
- paulcole 7y agoIf every country you operate in is subpoenaing you, then maybe it’s time to reevaluate how you run your company?
- monkeydreams 7y agoOne of the roles of the CEO is to be the "public face" of the company. This is literally "the public" requiring Facebook to explain themselves. Demanding that a CEO face up to public scrutiny of a company's operations is well on this side of the line. If companies want to be treated as citizens they must, periodically, offer up a pair of wrists to be cuffed.
- ta34729384 7y ago> Lawmakers from at least ten countries, including the United Kingdom and Australia, are expected to attend the meeting, which is the second of its kind. Yep, totally unreasonable to make Americans leave America.
- drivebycomment 7y agoFrom the article: > Both executives received formal requests from the Canadian Parliament earlier this month tied to a gathering of an international committee examining Silicon Valley's impact on privacy and democracy....Lawmakers from at least ten countries, including the United Kingdom and Australia, are expected to attend the meeting, which is the second of its kind. The meeting of an international committee of lawmakers, without any specific tie to an international body, has to be an informational one, and such a meeting does not need a CEO. In fact, you actually don't want the CEO but the actual experts. So by calling out Zuckerberg, those lawmakers are implicitly declaring that they want this meeting to be a dog-and-pony show of political theater, not an actually useful meeting. This sounds like some Canadian politician is huffing and puffing about Zuck not helping them look good when they are hosting some event. I'm not at all surprised Facebook doesn't want any of it, and I wouldn't be surprised that the threat of contempt vote is a complete bluff and won't go anywhere.
- M2Ys4U 7y agoAlso from the article: >Their presence is important, he said, because, "Knowing the structure of Facebook and how it is micro-managed right from the top, any change on the platform is done through Mr. Zuckerberg or through Ms. Sandberg."
- bin0 7y agoYou hit the nail on the head here. The canadians are doing the same thing the American Congress did recently: pulling in the big bad zuck for a stern talking-to. Notice that they passed no laws. It's televised political theater of the kind we have seen ever since C-Span showed up.
- jaredklewis 7y agoAll good points. Probably just the bitter American in me speaking, but if Canada is anything like the US, the hearing will be 100% optics, 0% substance. All the politicians will want to be seen asking tough questions and then–once the public flogging is over–will return to their regularly scheduled program of doing fuck all. As cathartic as it would be to see another grilling of Zuckerberg, it's hard to get too worked up that he's sending his understudy. Same song and dance either way.
- lazugod 7y ago> Where do you draw the line? It seems pretty reasonable for the CEO to show up to hearings for the country where your company is headquartered... but to send lieutenants everywhere else, no? What is the precedent in this case? I assume Facebook is not the only multinational corporation to ever exist or be called to testify to foreign congresses. What have other corporations done?
- pulse7 7y agoIf Facebook operates in Canada it must: 1) either have there a subsidiary and a CEO of that subsidiary would represent a company in this case or 2) the CEO of a multinational company needs to go there and represent a company.
- tus87 7y agoDo they operate in Canada though?
- tpm 7y agoDo they accept money from Canadian customers and show ads to Canadian users?
- M2Ys4U 7y ago>On the other hand, a multinational company can't be expected to fly its CEO to a legislative hearing in every country where it operates... Yes, yes it should be expected to do that.
- StreamBright 7y agoI think Zuckerberg has both the financial means and the time to fly to every country where he operates. Not all the countries requested hearings so the number of countries he needs to show up is probably less than the number of countries he visits on pleasure trips.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 7y agoThen Facebook shouldn’t do business in that country. It’s really simple. Corporations and their executives should not be exempt from governments, especially democratically elected ones.
- OrgNet 7y ago> It's just straight-up logistically impossible yes, Facebook should probably get sued daily seeing the way it is acting so that they can suffer the consequences of its actions... If that isn't possible, maybe jail is the only option.