3 ms·
>Reuters could not verify the authenticity of the records. Shown the images of the tracking records, FedEx declined to make any comment, saying company policy p
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
>Reuters could not verify the authenticity of the records. Shown the images of the tracking records, FedEx declined to make any comment, saying company policy prevented it from disclosing customer information. //
So they're confirming that the images are customer data, which makes them authentic. If they weren't authentic then they wouldn't be customer information, no?
>FedEx spokeswoman Maury Donahue told Reuters the packages were “misrouted in error” and that FedEx was not requested to divert them by any other party. //
Which doesn't tell us anything as NSA letters, for example, can IIUC require a company to lie to cover up executive activity.
>The U.S. Department of Commerce did not reply to a request for comment on whether the incident might be related to its move on May 16 to add Huawei to the so-called “Entity List,” //
Which is basically "hey are you being a shithead?", "oh, no comment!". Not even bothering to deny it??
>FedEx declined to give details on what the exception was in this case. //
I mean, it sounds a lot like the response of someone caught with their pants down (ie in the act of committing a nefarious offense).
What is clear is that this is more shots fired -- and TBH the message of "you can't trust USA not to be using security letters to pry in to foreign businesses confidential affairs" isn't anything like unbelievable.
- vinay427 7y ago> So they're confirming that the images are customer data, which makes them authentic. If they weren't authentic then they wouldn't be customer information, no? I don't think that assumption works. Reuters asked for specific customer information: in particular, whether the records were valid. Answering in the affirmative or negative is divulging customer data, and FedEx would be wise to avoid doing so whether or not it's valid.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoYou're right, I skipped over the "decline to make any comment" part. But still, "this is not a valid receipt" doesn't reveal data about a customer transaction.
- elliekelly 7y agoBut then when the reporter comes back a few days later with a different receipt that _is_ valid and FedEx tries to give the canned response about not revealing customer transaction data... they inadvertently have. Because if it wasn’t customer transaction data then they would have simply said as much, as they did the last time. Companies always respond with “no comment” for a good reason: to prevent people from drawing incorrect conclusions by reading between the lines as you are doing now.