4 ms·
If adults don't understand the technology and kids don't consent, isn't that exactly a scenario where we should at least protect the children, given that its wi
by Barrin92 7y ago
If adults don't understand the technology and kids don't consent, isn't that exactly a scenario where we should at least protect the children, given that its widely accepted in most countries that children can't actually enter commercial relationships on their own?
- ve55 7y agoWhile protecting the kids would be nice, it results in a large inconsistency to apply it here, given the level of control we allow parents to have over their kids in many areas. For example, parents have near-complete jurisdiction over the diet of their children and can therefore cause significant health issues at their own discretion (or just due to lack of nutritional knowledge). This is (at least at the current moment) a significantly larger issue for kids than if Amazon has personal data on them or not. Accordingly, it seems strange for us to want the government to intervene with respect to data on children, but not with respect to a child's diet.
- hrktb 7y agoGovernment can and mostly do intervene in respect to child diet as well.
- ve55 7y agoI said 'near-complete' in attempt to include edge cases. Most parents definitely make their own decisions as to what to feed their kids rather than letting the government make them, just as they decide what to teach their kids.
- hrktb 7y agoIt wildly depends on where you live I guess, but I expect a large portion of kids to eat lunch at school, and school meals are regulated.
- dvdbloc 7y agoWhataboutism
- windexh8er 7y ago> If adults don't understand the technology and kids don't consent, isn't that exactly a scenario where we should at least protect the children, given that its widely accepted in most countries that children can't actually enter commercial relationships on their own? Or more accurately kids can't consent. This is the argument I've used for my kids against family members who had a hard time understanding not plastering them on social media. Basically we told everyone in the family that our kids images, names, DoB, whereabouts and anything else about them should not be posted in any form or fashion. I'd then go on to position it from my kids point of view: what if they don't consent later in life and those posts somehow impact them negatively at that time? Do you [family member] want to take on that you were the only one to choose for them? I am their custodian and doing my due diligence to keep their digital footprint to a minimum until they have the capacity to make those choices on their own behalf. I feel like there are lawsuits all around this that will be cropping up in the next decade which may shy people away from the unfiltered social media perspective many run with today.
- xwdv 7y agoOTOH, if you are plastering yourself all over social media and other kids parents are doing the same with their children, not including your child in your posts can feel extremely alienating to them, and make them feel like you do not care about them or want to be seen with them. And when they grow up, they may resent you for not even putting up even one picture of them with you. The moral of that story is to beware: kids may not always share your values and by doing what you think is best you may be doing harm. They may not understand consent, but they will understand what it looks like when a parent doesn’t give a shit about them.
- windexh8er 7y agoIf you talk to your kids they are surprisingly intelligent and can comprehend this. I do my best to bridge the line of alienation and acceptable use of technology which leverages other forms of inclusion and sharing that doesn't require Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, etc. And to your point, kids don't always share values of the parent which is why they don't have final say. Your implication that a parent that does more to protect their child "doesn't give a shit about them" clearly showcases your agenda and/or unfounded assertion.
- marcosdumay 7y agoId adults don't understand the tech, they can't consent either. It's a scenario where we should be protecting everybody. Pushing for children protection first would not be wrong, but would be counter productive.