4 ms·
> Non-Chinese business must operate with a Chinese partner to do business in the mainland. That isn’t true universally. Certain industries require (required?)
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
> Non-Chinese business must operate with a Chinese partner to do business in the mainland.
That isn’t true universally. Certain industries require (required?) JVs, most notably the car industry but also energy resources.
Most industries are free and clear and don’t require JVs. Microsoft, for example, has always operated independently in China, nor does Apple. Starbucks started out as a JV but has been getting its own store, especially in 2nd tiers.
- JonathanMerklin 7y agoJV == Joint Venture (I had to look this up so I figured I'd comment to note it for anyone else who might, since the term isn't used in full anywhere in the article or parent comment chain - barring future edits.)
- comex 7y agoHowever, Microsoft and Apple’s cloud services (Azure and iCloud respectively) are operated as joint ventures.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThose aren’t JVs, which has a formal meaning anyways. They call it a partnership, or an operator agreement. Maybe the distinction is moot here, but they aren’t really working together, just they provide the machines and Microsoft provides everything else.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoAs of last year, automobile manufacturers don't require joint ventures any more. As time goes on, the number of industries that require joint ventures is decreasing. The joint-venture requirement for automobile parts was removed in 1993, for example. The thinking of the Chinese government was that as an undeveloped country, Chinese companies had no hope of directly competing against companies from the developed world. Chinese car manufacturers in 1990 would have simply been wiped out by Toyota, Ford, BMV et al. The Chinese government wanted foreign investment, so they created a middle ground, where foreign companies could exploit cheap Chinese labor and gain access to the growing Chinese market, but in which they would have to work with Chinese companies. This sort of policy makes sense for a developing country, which aspires to be more than a platform for cheap labor, but also to develop its own domestic capabilities. It actually follows in the tradition of a theory advanced by Alexander Hamilton, the "infant industry argument." As know-how at Chinese companies has increased, however, these restrictions have started to make less sense. There are Chinese electric car companies (such as BYD) that can legitimately compete with foreign manufacturers now. As a consequence, JV requirements are also being scaled back.
- CathayRe 7y agoIt is basically the standard with all developing countries joining the WTO where by they are allowed and even encourage to do this as an under developed country. The problem is China is no longer one, or at leats most countries doesn't think it is anymore. And has failed to abide by what they promised when they joined WTO. Or you can blame it on US for letting them joining without clear cut rules and terms in the first place.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoChina has plenty of developing and even in developed countries inside its borders, along with its mostly developed areas. It is kind of difficult to classify a country that is so huge and heterogeneous with respect to development levels.
- CathayRe 7y agoYes, and surprisingly enough, even in US and many part of Western Europe. The problem is China has been playing their developing country card for far too long, and if we have to argue a Country with GDP that is either 1st or 2nd by different way of measurement as developing country I think we can agree to disagree.
- CathayRe 7y agoIt depends on its strategic interest. ARM, AMD all have JV. >Most industries are free and clear and don’t require JVs. That is true only on paper. In reality they would still want a JV or some form of partnership. From Food Production, Restaurant Chains, to other part of the industries. If China wasn't desperate for Pork, ( Due to all sort of Pork disease ) they would not have allowed Danish Crown to operate independently after both have negotiate for years. You can try to register, but without some form of JV and somehow doing the "relationship" work for you. Nothing will get done.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIt has changed over time. China went from having a positive list to a negative list, and ya, local implementation often lags behind central government initiatives by a few years.