8 ms·
Some business schools are shutting down their on-campus MBA programs
- dahart 7y agoTl;dr on-campus programs are in decline while online programs are growing. Seems like the title is a tad misleading, the programs aren’t shutting down, they’re going online. But isn’t a lot of the value of an MBA in the face time and networking you get during the program? (Or is that a myth or only something that happens at Harvard?) Every once in a while I think about going back and getting an MBA, speculating it might help with my next startup, but I’ve always imagined going to campus. Are online tools and online degrees improving in the areas of having class discussions and making friends and asking questions and general people time?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIt’s not a myth, top MBA programs are top because they give you access to an exclusive network. Personally, I wouldn’t value an MBA much without that aspect.
- amb23 7y agoUS MBA programs need to start following the European model: Year-long to 16 month programs tailored to a slightly older demographic (late 20s to 30s) who actually need a degree to move a rung higher in their career. The shorter program length will decrease the costs for students (both in terms of tuition & opportunity costs) and--based on how much travel my friends currently pursing MBAs do during the academic year--is unlikely to hurt academic outcomes. There are a few MBA ROI calculators online, and for my career I wouldn't see an ROI until ~20-25 years down the line. (For context, I'd probably gain a ~30k salary increase if I were to pursue an MBA.) And that's with consistent salary growth with no sabbaticals or career changes (and any subsequent loss in earning potential) I might want to pursue. I would love to use a year long program to gain some needed financial modeling, HR, and operational skills while taking the time to pursue a business idea, but the traditional programs are not structured to accommodate that. And besides, you don't actually need an MBA if you work in the tech industry until you're in a senior position--VP or C-suite--so there's no direct need for the degree itself until ~10-15 years in the future.
- arcanus 7y ago> And besides, you don't actually need an MBA if you work in the tech industry until you're in a senior position--VP or C-suite You certainty do not need an MBA to reach executive level in American technology companies. Just a few CEO examples off the top of my head: Eric Schmidt (Google) has a PhD. Dara Khosrowshahi (Uber) has 'just' a BS. Ginni Rometty (IBM) also has no postgraduate education. I strongly suspect a minority of executives in tech have MBAs. I don't have anything against the MBA (my father and wife have them) but it's by no means necessary.
- jayalpha 7y ago"US MBA programs need to start following the European model" No they don't. I, as a dual citizen, think US programs are by far superior. "And besides, you don't actually need an MBA if you work in the tech industry" "How to value your start-up? Add 1 Million for every engineer, subtract 500k for every MBA" Guy Kawasaki
- rchaud 7y agoThe Guy Kawasaki quote is absurd when you consider that US startups bleed cash all the way up to and often well past their IPO. You best believe that the banks who are out there selling a fantastical vision of a startup's future profitability have MBAs in their team. They're the ones making the engineers' equity worth something.
- gguijf 7y agoThe idea that investment bankers are the ones that make equity worth something, and not the founders and employees, is so wrong as to be a joke.
- ska 7y agoIt's not so absurd - it doesn't imply you shouldn't have any MBA's, just that the ratio to engineers should be very small at this stage. Which isn't wrong in a tech startup. Also, the banks don't really create value here, they preserve it if they can and in the best case help people not piss it away. All for a handsome percentage, but c'est la vie.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoThe two existing comments are from people who are considering an MBA at some point, so perhaps these thoughts are helpful: - Doing a full time MBA at a top school (or any school) is a large commitment of time and money. If your aim is to start a business, then it's worth considering what you could achieve with the same amount of time+money invested in getting that business started. If your aim is to get a promotion then, again, it's worth considering the opportunity cost. - Some of the things you'll learn during the MBA can easily be learned on your own. But 90% of us usually only study the stuff we find most interesting or most immediately relevant. An MBA is a good mechanism to force some breadth. - The people who get most out of an MBA (from what I've saw at my school, and other people I know) are those who have a clear goal, and have done some research beforehand about how an MBA from their chosen school will help them to get there. Those people also spent a significant portion of their time researching jobs, and trying to meet people to get leads. They didn't just focus on the classes until near graduation, and then apply via standard processes. They were focused on their goal (e.g. 'M&A Associate position at a top-tier investment bank') from the first day, until they got their job offer. - There are plenty of people who pursue a full-time MBA as a 'break' from work, or because they want to learn a set of skills they can apply in their existing or future business, or because their employer (e.g. investment bank, or top-tier consulting firm) expects it and pays for it, or even just for fun. These are all acceptable reasons. But pursuing an MBA because you think it's a magic solution to $current_career_problem probably won't end well[0]. [0] This last part might be incorrect if you end up at a top school. Like, maybe if you do an MBA at Harvard you won't even need to apply for jobs, and people will come knocking on your door. I don't know. But I suspect the intersection of people who (i) get into HBS, and (ii) have unrealistic expectations of what a piece of paper can do for their career, is pretty small.
- dvtrn 7y agoBut pursuing an MBA because you think it's a magic solution to $current_career_problem probably won't end well[0]. I've watched a few people enter STEM for the same reason and very quickly burn out. Arguably holding an MBA and making good use of it, or starting a career in STEM and finding a niche (dev, design, ux, what-have-you) certainly has the upshot of potentially larger incomes, but just in passive observation I've watched friends go to bootcamps or take an online class, slap it on a resume and just expect the jobs to start showing up-grow frustrated when they don't, or they get rejected from interviews and return to their former careers tail between their legs. It's not fun to behold. There's probably an economic/era of data/wage-stagnation argument to be made here-that has people racing madly to these career fields, I'm just not qualified on the topic to figure out how to make it.
- vikramkr 7y agoMost of the value in an MBA is from the face to face interaction and networking - the classes in business school are helpful sure but nothing you can't learn yourself in a book. If these schools weren't able to offer much in the way of networking and development of soft skills in the first place, then frankly going online makes sense because you don't lose anything, but i think that's a factor specific to these business schools, not the very top bschools that have no shortage of funding/extensive networks etc.
- analog31 7y agoI think there are a couple other values as well. Maybe this is similar to "networking," but there is a certain standardization that makes it easier to hire an MBA and plug them into a business that has already adopted the MBA business culture and methods. It also brings everybody up to a decent level in a variety of areas. Some folks may need to brush up on their quantitative skills, others on literacy, negotiation, etc. Empirical example from talking to a number of MBA's: They all have the same beliefs about things like the purpose of the corporation, how to motivate people, and so forth.
- povertyworld 7y agoIs it possible some corporations just have MBA requirements for advancement? Then it doesn't matter where you got the degree from just that you have it. I know this is the case in education, and has lead to the proliferation of online education grad degrees. Since you just need the piece of paper, most careerists optimize for the easiest online "mail order" type degree possible. They don't, however, optimize for cheapest, since tax payers bankroll most of these cheesy degrees through tuition reimbursement.
- delfinom 7y agoMBA used to be an requirement for an engineer to jump into manager roles. But nowadays it depends on the company.
- mcmoose75 7y agoI went to one of the top-tier (top 3) MBA programs in the US. The way I've described that value of the top MBA programs is in 3 (roughly equally-weighted) categories: 1) The Education: Getting to discuss business concepts with a group of smart, successful folks for 6-9 hours a day is very helpful. Most of the content, I could get from books/ online articles at a fraction of the price, but spending the time in a focused way is actually helpful. 2) The Network: In terms of network, this isn't some vague amorphous thing at Stanford GSB, HBS, or Penn- it's knowing several hundred other folks who are going to be very successful in their careers. This can be useful in sales, fundraising, finding a next job, etc. and DOES have a tangible dollar value. 3) The Rubber Stamp: Having your resume say "Stanford GSB" or "Harvard Business School" does have value to future employers or customers- it de-risks you as you've been validated by a famous institution, and helps THEM to associate with these famous brands. For the top 3 programs, even though they're VERY expensive (approx $250k in tuition + living expenses, plus at least another $250k in foregone income for most incoming students, for $500k in actual cost+opportunity cost), they're almost certainly worth it. For middle-/ lower-tier MBA programs, 2) and 3) above aren't NEARLY as valuable, or perhaps don't even exist- is your "network" from Podunk State School MBA actually valuable? For these, the only real value is the actual education, and most students would be better served with an online program or just actually picking up some books/ case studies/ reading online articles.
- purplezooey 7y agoPodunk State School, eh?
- mcmoose75 7y agoThat's probably overly dismissive. Obviously state schools are super valuable for undergrad- I went to one. I just wouldn't pay a ton of money for an MBA from one of them.
- anonymous5133 7y agoPeople often underrate the state schools. I went to one as well for accounting. When I graduated I got a job at a big 4 accounting firm and was working with people who went to USC for their undergrad. We were making the same amount of money. Only difference was I graduated debt free (worked through school) and they had massive loans. IMO, only go to the prestigious schools if you are studying a profession that has earning potential. Don't bother with any liberal arts type major.
- rchaud 7y agoYou can see from the list of names in the article why those schools are dropping on-campus programs. Some of them are prestigious institutions, but not for business: - University of Iowa - Wake Forest University - Thunderbird School of Global Management - Virginia Tech - Simmons College There aren't many people out there thinking, sure, I'll go into six-figure debt so my LinkedIn can say I have a Simmons College MBA. Simply put, if your on-campus MBA program isn't likely to result in a six-figure job right out of the gate, it's not worth the cost. And those six-figure jobs only come about if big, rich companies (banks, big 4 consulting/audit, big tech) come on campus to hire MBAs. If yours is not a Top 15 MBA program, you may be better off career-wise by staying at your current job and pursuing professional certifications related to your field.
- askafriend 7y agoI’d take it even further. If it’s not a top 5 program then you’d really really have to think about if it’s worth doing at all.
- joker3 7y agoTop five is a little too strict, but top twenty, yeah, maybe.
- bigtunacan 7y agoIt's not that simple. Take the University of Iowa as an example. The full time MBA program has seen declining enrollment and has been steadily losing money. Conversely the PMBA program has seen increased enrollment and profits and it can be difficult to get into classes wanted/needed to complete the degree. If you are planning to stay in Iowa the network effects of the Iowa PMBA program are pretty strong. Many of your classmates will be in leadership roles within local area businesses that you may be considering moving to at some point. Often times the students are looking to take another step up, but are lacking skills that can be provided by the degree. In many of these situations the businesses agree with this as the businesses are frequently footing the bill for tuition either in part or in full. Students within the full-time traditional MBA programs are typically younger with less or even no professional experience. PMBA students are generally experienced professionals that have already proven a certain level of success to an organization that are then learning skills that will help them bridge a gap.
- SQL2219 7y agoThere are 16 references in the comments about "top" programs. I am curious as to what top actually means, can I sort by the top column in a spreadsheet? Is it a code word for cost?
- petronio 7y agoThere are a few companies that rank educational institutions and their programs by various metrics. "Top" programs are just the ones that tend to be at the top of those rankings. For MBAs, Harvard, Stanford, and UPenn's Wharton usually take the top three globally.
- filmgirlcw 7y agoIt means Harvard, MIT, Stanford, University of Chicago, Penn — most generally. But there are different MBA programs. There’s the traditional MBA, the part-time MBA (which is a great choice for people who already work), and the executive MBA.
- bitL 7y agoLook up M7, T15 and T25 B-schools, that's how they are usually called by B-folks.
- baron816 7y agoIs there a lot of value in getting a non-specialized MBA if you're working in tech (or want to work in tech)?
- miohtama 7y agoOnline MBA would be only for career signalling? Is the other side of the coin, networking, present in any form? Has anyone taken online MBA and can comment the benefits?
- Ibethewalrus 7y agoInterested as well about the benefits/downsides of an online MBA by a prestigious vs regular school
- _sword 7y agoInterestingly, institutions such as Simmons (highlighted in this article) are partnering with online education platform vendors such as 2u to bring their campus online. Using 2u as an example, the schools offload all of the marketing for candidates, managing the online platform, and more to 2u in exchange for a revenue share for tuition for online students. Schools are in turn responsible for the course content including the professors, and for their admissions department to accept or deny applications provided by 2u. The net impact for the school can be incremental revenues by addressing students that weren't accessible previously, and that these incremental revenues come with a high margin for the school, which can help fund other areas of the school. Fascinating business model in my view.
- RickJWagner 7y agoAnything that adds prestige and profitibility to online education is ok with me. Traditional college education is a racket. I'm hoping online is the way of the (near) future.
- bitL 7y agoIMO online MBA from a respected school is a perfect thing for entrepreneurs that need flexibility and can't just take 2-3 years off. It's also awesome for digital nomads that can literally earn degree while lying on a Hawaiian beach or traveling around the world. And if the class is massive like at UIUC (2000 people?), networking effect gets a huge multiplier, globally, comparing to much smaller classes at M7 (and FAANG is quite strongly represented there, like with Georgia Tech's OMS CS). The only problem I see is prestige, so I'll keep an eye on iMBA to see how they wrestle with rankings.