4 ms·
To be fair a million people is 0.07% of China's population. 0.7% of the US is in prison, so that would be about 1/10th of the prison population. I'm not sayin
by IshKebab 7y ago
To be fair a million people is 0.07% of China's population.
0.7% of the US is in prison, so that would be about 1/10th of the prison population.
I'm not saying US prisons are the same - you get a vaguely proper legal process, and conditions are probably better. You're not likely to have your organs havested. But "a million people" isn't the problem.
- humanrebar 7y agoA million people is enough to be concerned about. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- ppod 7y agoIt's not "whataboutism" to point out that this level of incarceration is not unusual. It is being portrayed as unusual in the article, when, in global-historical terms it is statistically perfectly normal. The small number of western democracies that do not practice violent state suppression of dissent and exploitation of the poor are the anomalies. The comparisons to Nazi Germany are also misleading. Nazi Germany was unusual in the degree to which it industrialized and systematized its racial slaughter, but the propaganda, state suppression, and state police brutality doesn't seem to me like an outlier among 20th century governments.
- humanrebar 7y agoIt's exactly whataboutism to say "What about U.S. incarceration?" when defending China. It's 100% analogous to what would come up in discussions of the USSR. "The USSR is bad for its people." "What about Jim Crow?" It's also worth noting that there is a bipartisan criminal justice reform movement in the U.S. that is critical of the U.S. government at various levels, so, no, it's not apples to apples.
- wizzairflyer 7y agoI think the parent meant that looking at raw numbers isn't enough to get a good idea of if a situation is bad or not. Since China is so big anything they'll do will affect a huge number of people, even if it's not excessive.
- NicoJuicy 7y agoI would suppose there are more then 0,07% in China's prison or have dissapeared or are punished. This resemblance doesn't make a lot of sense.
- some_random 7y agoDid you just claim that more than one million people being forced into reeducation camps isn't a problem? What constitutes a problem to you?
- FabHK 7y agoThe claim is a) that things have be put in relation to the size of the country, and b) that having less than 0.1% of the population in prison for relatively minor offences can't be that huge of a problem if that is the case in many countries, including the USA.
- some_random 7y agoReeducation camps are not the same as prisons. Imprisoning someone for drug charges after due process is not the same as imprisoning someone for being the wrong ethnicity. The moral weight of a life does not change based on the population of a country. I feel like these statements are pretty close to being axiomatic.
- Krasnol 7y agoWhat percentage of the Uigur population is it?