11 ms·
The Books of College Libraries Are Turning into Wallpaper
- beamatronic 7y agoPeople used to access printed materials largely because, well, there was no other choice. Today digital is the native medium of authoring and creation. Sharing, copying, and indexing come “for free” where historically those were high-cost.
- mimixco 7y agoUnfortunately, there's still a lot of information that's locked up only in books. The more obscure or specialized your need, the less likely it is to be found on the web. Countless books will never be digitized because there's no profit motive to do so. And HathiTrust, while useful, keeps most of its PDFs behind a 'paywall' so that you can only download them if you are physically sitting at a partner University. I can't think of a dumber restriction on a digitized book than making you drive to a university campus to download it.
- asark 7y agoI've been repeatedly surprised and disturbed at how quickly one can hit "go get one of the five copies of this book if you want to know more" on any given topic, when researching online. You don't even have to go that deep. If you're lucky you can spend 30min digging around and find a scanned PDF on some foreign university library's site or something. If not.... [EDIT] and that's just when you can find out that there is something more to find. How many times does the Internet not even know—or if it does, not in any way you could reasonably find—what it doesn't know? I have a whole book that's just a list of works by and about T.E. Lawrence. Books, articles, introductions, collections, papers. It's the length of a normal book, and contains almost nothing but a list of works. It's a book-length bibliography. That's one guy. Granted, famous, but there are tons of people as or more famous/important as/than him. Plus all those topics that aren't single people. Buildings, movements, art works, events. The Web's smaller than one might hope.
- dredmorbius 7y agoFortunately, digitisation seems to be proceeding for reasons other than proft motive. https://b-ok.org https://b-ok.org https://libgen.io https://libgen.io https://archive.org https://archive.org
- 0815test 7y agoSharing, copying and indexing are things that you can't do if DRM gets in the way. If the alternative is a printed book vs. a fake digital book that you can't actually use effectively because of DRM, I'll take the printed book 100% of the time. Related: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html
- tokai 7y ago>Sharing, copying These two are not allowed with digital academic sources.
- teh_klev 7y agoI don't know how this works in the US, but I wonder if allowing/encouraging the general public (i.e. you're not an alumni, and perhaps you never went to college) to sign up and use university libraries would increase usage? Just had a scan of Glasgow and Edinburgh University's library membership pages. The general public can access the libraries but how and what you're permitted to access can vary between institutions.
- sgent 7y agoAll my local university libraries (including a few excellent ones) allow anyone to use the stacks for free. If you want to check something out or you want access to the computer databases you may have to pay to join the "Friends of the Library" or Alumni Association. Access to the databases is often restricted to students / staff though.
- ht_th 7y agoIf the state of public libraries is anything to go by, no. At least here in the Netherlands, most public libraries that are still open, have reduced their book shelf capacity in the past couple of years and added study spaces, conversation spaces, coffee corners, computer spaces, meeting spaces, and workshops to the menu. The experience of going to the library now compared to 30 years ago when I was a kid is totally different. Then it was a quiet place with books, catalogues, a reading table, and maybe a computer or two. Now it is a social meeting place. (What I do wonder is, what were the social meeting places of 30 years ago? Why is there a need for them now?) Anyway, in my experience with university libraries, unless you know what you're doing research-wise, these libraries are not the most accessible for the outsider. There is a lot of information to wade through, and if you're unlucky, you have to order books you want from the archive/warehouse anyway, which can take from a couple of hours to a couple of days. Unless you can go to the library every day, you will have to plan your visit, search and request the books and materials you think you want beforehand, and hope for the best. How I miss searching for hours or days in libraries and archives!
- mcphage 7y ago> What I do wonder is, what were the social meeting places of 30 years ago? Why is there a need for them now? Check out the book Bowling Alone by Robert Putnam
- Bostonian 7y agoFrom my experience as an undergrad and grad student in the 1990s, you can learn a lot about a subject by just going to the relevant section of the library and browsing.
- 8bitsrule 7y agoIn the past, college libraries with open stacks of printed books were often the only way to learn of the existence of an obscure book that might be of use to you ... even change your life or at least enhance your research. They were in close proximity to other books that you knew to be useful. Example: I might be looking at someone's obscure technical book from the 1870s at the college they worked for ... and nearby might be the world's only remaining copy of a bio written by a friend or colleague that mentions facts found nowhere else. I won't know ... because neither is shelved any more. The 1870s book is found at archive.org. But not the bio. And the computer doesn't duplicate the proximity once found in the physical card catalog. The rewards of the physical browsing experience are lost in the digital age. No way to assess the damage that's been done by hiding college stacks underground in containers. To assess the effect of moving uncommon books to special collections with infrequent hours and stringent requirements. I have to wonder about the professionalism of the people who too carelessly make the decision to overturn systems evolved by centuries of scholarship.
- codingdave 7y agoThank you for pointing this out. When I would do research in the library, I quickly learned that looking up one book was really just a path to finding the correct shelf in the library, where I could browse an entire shelf of books on the same subject. While I certainly appreciate the digital modernization of academic work (and in many ways even I am amazed that we wrote papers by hand, on paper, from paper books)... There really is something about just browsing shelves that exposes you to more options that I miss when researching online.
- marmot777 7y agoYes, and that was kind of fun to stumble on that treasure trove.
- CydeWeys 7y agoWhen I was in elementary/middle school I would become familiar with entire racks of books in the library, starting with the Tom Swift and Hardy Boy sections and then moving onto the adult scifi section. Surprisingly, you can duplicate a lot of the "see similar stuff" functionality through Amazon's recommendation engine (for new books anyway). The other things people have viewed/purchased for any given item are usually quite useful, and aren't limited by physical proximity, e.g. the Band of Brothers DVD listing on Amazon includes in its related items many nonfiction books, which you would never get from the strict categorization scheme in the library. I wish online library catalogs would do a better job of replicating this recommendation/similarity engine, because on Amazon things tend to be limited just to things that are still in print and for sale.
- rjsw 7y agoI was at university in the 80s, I was often the first person to borrow CS books that I read.
- cheez 7y agoIn my university there were so many books that part of the comp sci section was in basically crawl space (I was too tall to enter and had to crawl.) It was such a vivid experience, I can't imagine not browsing books as a student.
- rxm 7y agoThere are many aspects of a library of technical books that I miss online: the curation process, the higher bit rate once you are holding the book, and the lack of distractions in the library. What I fear may go away is the long form books offer. When exploring a new topic, articles are often too dense. In books, authors can establish the background, help create a shared vocabulary, and motivate what is often so condensed in a research article.
- nabla9 7y agoThere was just recently discussion about books on HN. It was based on some blog post where the author complained about the book format and how hard it is to remember what you just read. The discussion revealed that people don't learn in shool how to read and study with books anymore. Of course you don't remember much if you read the book from start to end. E-readers may share the blame. It's very hard and slow to study with e-book. If you spend hours studyin, you really need a book written into a paper.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoIt's funny, as someone who grew up with books and the burgeoning world wide web, I hadn't thought of this. When I'm learning a topic I tend to buy or print books so I can soak it in. When I to learn a quick task I go online. Books tend to be great for the why's of something but not the how's. Online is great for the how's but not the why's. I think a blended approach has ended up being the best way for me to learn. I do have a genuine love of books though.
- asark 7y agoBooks are damn good interfaces for reading long-form text. Footnotes, end notes, indices (sure search is handy—indices are better for some things, though, by excluding invalid partial matches and other irrelevancies) glossaries, integrated author bios and expert introductions, and so on. Multi-page marking with near-instant switching. Two pages visible at a time. Cover, title, and author visible when sitting on the table not actively in use, to help passively absorb and retain that info—ever forget who wrote an ebook while reading it? Spatial recall. Margins to mark on or write notes in. They're excellent. E-book readers are a replacement only for disposable cotton-candy fiction—which has its place, and that part's nice. Maybe one day computers and digital readers will actually be good enough to replace books. They're not even close today. The tech's just great.
- Illniyar 7y ago> And it runs contrary to the experience of public libraries and bookstores, where print continues to thrive. Ha? What about all the stories of public libraries and bookstores closing down? These seems like a long article that avoids the obvious - people don't use books because eBooks and computers are simply more convenient.
- gnicholas 7y agoEbooks aren't doing so hot these days: sales were down about 5% this year. https://goodereader.com/blog/e-book-news/ebook-sales-decline-by-4-9-in-january-2019 https://goodereader.com/blog/e-book-news/ebook-sales-decline...
- marmot777 7y agoAnd I have some good times with my girlfriend in the more obscure parts of the stacks. That's another reason to presume these stacks for posterity.
- microcolonel 7y agoWe absolutely must match the archival properties of books. Send your cold hard cash and public support to archive.org so that not everything is forgotten. I can't tell you how many of what would eventually be cultural and historic artifacts I've seen just disappear on a failed disk somewhere.
- Jill_the_Pill 7y agoMaybe I read too many horror stories when I was younger, but the concept of a "digital dark age" has stayed with me. I never fully trust online resources to be there after a wildfire, flood, or multiple changes of storage format.
- lqet 7y agoThis is also a major concern of mine, to the point that I actually considered to start printing the English Wikipedia at home, on very thin paper. Sure, it will take a few years (and probably a few printers) and will occupy most of my basement, but at least I will have access to this knowledge in case another dark age emerges. I am extremely worried that libraries are now replacing physical books by digital representations. If this is going to continue, there will be a point where the slightest global catastrophe will wipe out most of the knowledge of the past 2000 years.
- gdubs 7y agoThe signal-to-noise ratio there will be huge. Wouldn’t a normal multi-volume printed encyclopedia be way cheaper and less time and resource consuming?
- ThrowawayR2 7y agoWhere would you get a printed encyclopedia that's current? The only encyclopedia that I've heard of that's still actively being published is World Book Encyclopedia and that's meant for grade school children. Even the Encyclopedia Britannica released its final edition in 2010.
- dredmorbius 7y agoMost information usuful in a postindustrial society is over 100 years old.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoI'm sure there's ways to automate what should and shouldn't be printed, or prioritize and group it somehow. If you'd make a printed version of wikipedia you'd also need a transformation to turn links into references to other pages.
- RandallBrown 7y agoWhen I was in college, books played a bigger role than just wallpaper, although they still weren't used for reading and nobody was browsing through the stacks. They were great at sound dampening. Studying in the library was great because if there was a row of books between you and the people working on a group project. The books muffled the sound enough to concentrate. I don't mind losing physical books in the library, as long as we can keep the same ambiance.
- asark 7y agoDoes it follow that dramatically reducing the volumes available in university libraries is the right way to respond to this? Seems to me that might lead to a death spiral for the library by killing its remaining utility to students and researchers.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThe article makes it clear that the library still has enormous utility for students and researchers in the form of providing a focused space for study and collaboration. Those needs aren't going away anytime soon, and no other place fulfills them nearly as well as a library.
- whenchamenia 7y agoStarbucks without coffee sounds like a death spiral to me.
- thekyle 7y agoPerhaps this isn't true for every university, but mine has multiple cafes in our library.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThere's a big difference between a public space like a library, which has no admission price, and a private cafe like a Starbucks, that exists to make money from you. There's a huge demand for both types of spaces, and said demand is not interchangeable. And anyway, cafes are way too loud.
- cglace 7y agoWhen I would study in the library I would sometimes grab random books to read when I got bored or needed a break.
- gerion 7y agoAre they selling the books in second hand libraries? Does anybody where I can buy them in bulk?
- Data_Junkie 7y agoPeople think of this as the information age, but we are just approaching it. Libraries as we know them, public and academic, are about to be completely different. Even already the old way is obviously just the same because society doesn't have leadership to advance in blatantly obvious ways because we can't disrupt the cash flow.
- Macha 7y agoIn the past, students read the books in the college library, as it was the best way to find information about the topics they studied. Having their own copy was prohibitively expensive for anything more than the textbooks and maybe one or two books of required reading (this may be an experience in countries with free education, when you're borrowing several thousand a semester, another thousand for textbooks is probably less significant, but it was true in Ireland), and the only other source of information was the college's journal archive which was definitely not aimed at beginners. Nowadays, most students have a library of pirated PDFs, meaning they have the information on hand where they need it and with no need to return it or find it already borrowed in the college library. Most colleges will give you access to online databases of journals, so they aren't a draw either. The other problem encountered was that of QC. At least in my institution more substantial books were always in short supply, as they'd never have more than 5-6 copies of a single book, so you'd arrive at the computing section and find... "Java 2 for Dummies". Or "Teach yourself C++ in 24 hours". Books that might have been fine to self-learners (when they were not significantly outdated), but nothing that wouldn't be covered in a textbook and nothing more substantial. Probably this is a disconnect between the people running the library and the lecturers, but the attitude of the library was "Yes, we have software development books. What do you mean 15 years is out of date? The psychology books have been there since the 70s. And our figures show that more students have taken out 'Java 2 for Dummies' than 'Design Patterns' or 'The Pragmatic Programmer', so we don't need more copies." But those two factors, the greater accessibility of pirated PDFs and blogs (and for some of the slightly more recent students, Stack Overflow), and the lacking quality of what was probably available on the shelves at any given point you chose to look meant that the library was definitely way more useful as a study space than for the contents of the shelves for the other students and myself during my degree.
- tntn 7y agoI have strong feelings about this. When I was in university, I would quite frequently just going wander through the stacks in random sections, look at the titles, and pick up some that seemed interesting. I'd also go to some sections I liked (physics, math) and browse for hours. Frequently I'd end up spending a while looking though several hundred year old books written by the people that invented what the book was about. There weren't many people that did this, so in my senior year the library decided that the books were a poor use of space, and started tagging books that hadn't been checked out for N years for removal (just with a sticker, I had to ask to find out what the tags were for). Then they started to remove the books, so the 10 aisle section (each aisle with 20 or so full size bookshelves) on physics got reduced down to ~3 shelves. I asked the librarians where they had gone, and they assured me that I shouldn't be concerned because they had just gone to storage, so they could still be requested if needed. But this change meant that instead of just quickly checking several relativity books (indices are great) when I needed further explanation, I would have to search in the catalog and individually request them, which took several orders of magnitude longer. I have never seen a catalog with an interface that allows replicating the experience of walking through the stacks. Most interfaces allow you to find 1) popular books in some field which are almost always from the last decade or so and reflect what is currently hype, or 2) books with a particular title or author that you are already looking for. I'm reminded of a study on the dynamics and distribution of academic citations over the past century. I can't seem to find it at the moment (maybe it was referenced in one of Carr's works), but I think the gist is that the breadth of citations has reduced substantially in the last decades. Rather than citing many different papers from many different times, papers have begun to cite that same most-cited papers over and over again (that show up first in the search results), if I recall correctly. Reading a single pdf excerpted from a journal is a very different experience from reading the same article in the physical journal, because in the second you end up flipping past all the other articles which may catch your eye. In the same vein, reading a single ebook (or even requested book from storage) is a very different experience that finding it on the shelf and maybe running across several other awesome books on the way. It makes me very sad that centuries of knowledge from the best minds of humanity are getting shoved in storage, accessible only via search terms and the like, and replaced by couches where students can sit and browse Facebook/reddit/etc and occasionally work on schoolwork.
- kazinator 7y ago> Before you tsk-tsk today’s kids for their lack of bookishness, note that the trend lines are sliding southward for graduate students and faculty members, too Graduate students, and some faculty members, are also "today's kids", depending on your vantage point.
- physicsguy 7y agoI've found as a graduate student that lots of things I've wanted access to are out of print, and there's been no digitisation other than bad scans that you can only access through LibGen and which I end up printing out anyway. Journal access is also a pain - digital subscriptions are amazing, but my University is not subscribed to some journals I need access to, or they only have a subscription for papers after a certain date, which is when they stopped buying the print copy.