6 ms·
I wondered about this at one point. I'd been under full propofol sleep a couple of times due to knee operations, and the experience was quite interesting. You
by lordnacho 7y ago
I wondered about this at one point. I'd been under full propofol sleep a couple of times due to knee operations, and the experience was quite interesting.
You fall out of consciousness insanely fast. One moment you're talking to the anaesthetist about your name, what you're there for. You feel a cool sensation where the needle is. Before it's grown to your whole arm, you've vanished. I mean you're not dreaming, you're gone.
The only way you know you were gone is that there's no sensation of time. When you sleep, you feel like there's time. Under propofol I felt like my arm was cold, then I was groggy and waking up. In one action.
Maybe it's like dying, I don't know. But there's definitely this "system was rebooted" sensation as you come back to consciousness.
- GordonS 7y agoIt felt exactly the same way to me. > Before it's grown to your whole arm, you've vanished I wonder about this bit though - I wasn't sure if I really had gone out that quickly, or if I talked for more time but just don't remember it. After my operation I apparently woke in the recovery room and said some things (I heard the nurses talking about it afterwards) - but I have no recollection of it at all. Also, you're spot on about the passage of time - when I finally woke and was actually lucid (well, fairly!), it really felt like no time had passed.
- lordnacho 7y ago> I wonder about this bit though - I wasn't sure if I really had gone out that quickly, or if I talked for more time but just don't remember it. Something about the sensation of returning felt like it was on the waking side of the experience, rather than the falling asleep side. And because I did it twice I did see that the doctor had practiced it, it wasn't just smalltalk. He got me to do a biographical spiel because you tend to have one (grew up there, moved for uni, blah blah) ready. So when it came time to give it, I sort of vanished while talking about myself. No slurred speech like I was drunk, just sort of "oh shit I'm falling asleep" after maybe a couple of sentences, and then gone. I can see why Michael Jackson might have liked it. It really does KO you super fast.
- jazzyjackson 7y agoSince you brought it up I'm really curious why you suppose MJ would prefer to be KO'd so often.
- DanBC 7y agoYou can get addicted to propofol, and some people who self harm frequently and severely report the propofol as one factor for their continued self harm. (although it's often only one of many factors).
- lordnacho 7y agoI guess he was a troubled character? Couldn't sleep normally, perhaps due to some trauma?
- beenBoutIT 7y agoArguably the most talented and most troubled child prodigy/musical genius of all time. Obvious trauma right off the top would be a childhood of physical/sexual abuse combined with an unprecedented level of early fame and success.
- aperrien 7y agoReportedly, he had some botched plastic surgeries which made it hard to breathe normally, and in particular, made sleep painful.
- mgkimsal 7y agoprobably lots of reasons, but I can certainly see someone who's used to having anything they want at any time also wanting to be put to sleep (pardon the term) whenever they want as well. if all of your life is 'on demand', why wouldn't sleep be as well?
- gonzus 7y agoI understand he suffered from chronic pain, so sleep must not have been easy for him. I can totally see the lure of propofol in such a case.
- fnordsensei 7y agoI've only been under once, and it was the strangest thing: I had an out-of-body experience. When I woke up, it was like I had two sets of "memories" (for lack of a better word): one was nothing (like you describe), and the other was the OBE. I presume that I wouldn't have been able to notice the span "nothing" (because it didn't contain any time or space references as I can tell) at all if there wasn't a sort of parallel overlay of the OBE. By the way, this hasn't led to me drawing any particular conclusions about the nature of reality or consciousness. I didn't find it useful to hold a particular set of beliefs about these things before the event, and that didn't change afterwards. If anything, it just presents more questions.
- rhizome 7y agoI'm no neurologist, but I can picture a brain retconning the OBE as a reaction to the knowledge that time had passed when you didn't perceive that it did. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retroactive_continuity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retroactive_continuity
- buckminster 7y agoReading your comment it occurs to me that all remembering is retconning. But I'm not a neurologist either!
- fnordsensei 7y agoYep, very plausible. Also, some parts of the brain would still be active, I wasn't brain-dead after all. The OBE itself had some dream-like qualities, though one thing I did notice was that the "resolution" was superb, unlike my normal dreams. We're talking next-gen graphics. The closest thing I can compare it to is as if the entire field of vision was center of focus.
- lostmyoldone 7y agoSometimes I dream like that. It's the oddest bthing to dream something with the fidelity of, or even above, ones default conscious experience. Clear enough to afterwards, even years later, be able to recall the exact color and texture of the floor tile glazing, just how a doorway arched, and precisely how a distinctly non human entity looked and acted. Curiously, at least to me, it's primarily a profoundly visual experience. Sound, touch, and smell is rarely, if ever, prominent in those dreams. Maybe the clarity of vision somehow drowns them out, or maybe I simply don't dream much in sound, but it only becomes apparent when the visual experience is almost jarringly clear.
- distantaidenn 7y agoNot propofol specific, as I'm not sure what I was administered, but "rebooted" is the best way I've found to explain it. I've only been put under once, and similarly for knee surgery. After everything was prepped, my surgeon and I were chatting about something and the last thing I recall was the anesthesiologist putting the mask on me and saying "nemasu" (Japanese for "sleep"). There was no countdown, no drowsiness, no sleepiness -- I was just gone and then waking up post surgery. It felt as though no time had passed, but it had been hours. Completely and utterly trippy.
- KevanM 7y agoI've fainted a few times and that reboot experience was the same. It felt like the RoboCop boot sequence, you get sound and then vision that slowly returns.
- ineedasername 7y agoThis is the experience I have on something called seroquel, in my case taken for sleep issues. It comes on more gently than propofol, but once I'm out then I'm out, and waking up in the morning is, about 90% of the time, like a time warp. Sadly, remembered dreams are exceptionally rare now.
- tellak 7y agoPropofol is an anesthetic, seroquel is not... it’s an antipsychotic. The thing with antipsychotics is they’re shit or “dirty” drugs... seroquel is not even indicated for insomnia (and depending on who you ask is a terrible choice.. a lot of family med/internists use it, psychiatrists often cringe). It works because it has a strong antihistamine side effect, so it’s basically a very potent Benadryl. The point being, you’re still arousable. A vigorous rub of the sternum will likely wake you up. Not so much on propofol.
- ineedasername 7y agoI'm not sure what your point here is. I made no claim of 1-to-1 parity with propofol, the various uses of seroquel, it's efficacy for a given purpose, etc. Seroquel is however in the class of drugs "major tranquilizers" and my claim was simply that it can have a similar "time warp" effect. It's a claim based on my experience with it, and it is not an uncommon one. (And I do have experience with propofol through a single surgery to compare) I will address some of the other details of your comment though. First, the statement that someone on seroquel is "arousable": Compared to propofol, sure. But a vigorous rub of the sternum will absolutely not do it for many people, myself included. My wife can attest to the difficulty. And if aroused before time, the state can be likened to severe drunkenness in terms of ability to function. Also, your are right, there are arguably better sleep aid options. But it's arguable because individuals react so differently to different medications. Seroquel was not a first choice for the task, or the third. A doctor likely would be negligent in prescribing it for that sole purpose on a first consultation without exploration of other options. As for it being a shit or "dirty" drug, there aren't particularly good options within this class of drugs. We can argue about whether these are over-prescribed, but for people who truly do need them, it is something of a devil's bargain where the benefits can be suspect relative to the costs. For the fortunate that response to them, newer medicines like latuda offer a much lower side-effect profile for similar benefits. Absent very good insurance though, that is financial hit of roughly $15,000 per year that few can afford out of pocket. This leaves the "dirty" drugs. I won't put words into your mouth with this next part, but there are some that would then argue that these sorts of drugs are universally unsuited for any use, and that people suffering from their targeted disorders might better control their symptoms with diet, exercise, and supplements. Having seen many people attempt such and fail, I regard this point of view as a sort of survivors bias. The people that argue this point of view tend to be the very rare people for whom it works, but just as with any particular medication, the efficacy of any treatment regime varies greatly with the individual.
- tellak 7y agoWere you under with propofol the whole time though? Usually the propofol is just to put you down (it is very short acting) you’re intubated, and then anesthesia is maintained with a volatile fluorane such as sevo.
- HillRat 7y agoPropofol-only deep sedation is commonly used for minor outpatient procedures. If you’re going to have a patient down for less than an hour for a colonoscopy or endoscopy, it’s a very popular alternative to combination sedation as patient recovery is faster and a lot more pleasant.
- tellak 7y agoThe original commenter mentioned a “knee operation”
- wincy 7y agoI REALLY dislike that feeling of not existing or blinking out that people describe, it causes me some substantial existential dread afterward. So I resolved to have a colonoscopy without any anesthesia or painkillers. It wasn’t a big deal for me, it felt like having bad gas when the tube would go around a corner in the intestines, but the nurses acted like I was insane. The doctor had to come out and tell them it was fine. He said doctors have to experience a colonoscopy awake at least once so they know what it feels like, which I found interesting. Seeing what was in there was pretty interesting too. The American medical system acts like the smallest bit of discomfort warrants being knocked out. The anesthesiologist seemed a little put out about it too, as I refused to even let them give me an IV. Maybe he didn’t get paid if I wasn’t out. It was funny afterward because someone had the job of escorting me to my ride, so we walked together to my car. Made the whole thing far less unpleasant in my estimation.
- tellak 7y ago> The American medical system acts like the smallest bit of discomfort warrants being knocked out. There is a tremendous variation in both pain tolerance and anxiety. You sound like you’re in the minority. The anesthetist still gets paid. His concern is if you freak out (this happens more often then you may think), he may at minimum have paperwork to do and worse you may sue him for malpractice (“well he didn’t clearly explain it would be that bad during the consent process).. again this problem happens more than you may think. Ie the negative ev for them if you do not do the typical protocol is considerable.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"When you sleep, you feel like there's time." The only way I have a sense of time from sleeping is if I can recall a dream when I wake up. Otherwise the experience is identical: I remember going to sleep, and I remember waking up, but the space in between is empty -- no sense of time or anything. It's identical to being put under general anesthesia via propofol or other amnesia-inducing substances.
- StavrosK 7y agoI don't know what the GP's experience is like, but when you wake up you roughly know what time it is, no? Even if you're in a dark room.
- pmoriarty 7y agoDarkness/light are not the only clues you might have to how much time has passed. Other clues may be sounds you hear around you -- like other people going about their business (making breakfast, talking, etc), or cars driving past. These clues might be registered by your subconscious, even when you're not consciously aware of them. Another clue is how rested you feel. If you wake up feeling incredibly tired, you probably haven't gotten much sleep. Yet another clue is temperature, as it tends to get colder at night and warmer during the day. The smell of breakfast or coffee could give you a clue. How hungry or full you feel could be a clue, as could needing to go to the bathroom. There are probably plenty of other clues as well. In the absence of such clues, I'm not sure how well one would be able to guesstimate time after being asleep.