8 ms·
Bonini's Paradox
- hprotagonist 7y ago“a model that completely describes the system is about as useful as a map at 1:1 scale” — a quote from my advisor in grad school.
- ysleepy 7y agoI would also say, that a "complete model" is not a model anymore, but a copy of the thing itself. A model is always an incomplete simulation of something, keeping some relevant aspect but discarding less relevant ones while remaining useful.
- AstralStorm 7y agoBut that's completely untrue when the implementation does not match. Suppose one day we manage to create brain uploads. They're not brains but would have additional or different capabilities despite being 1:1 maps - being possible to restore the original from them. This is because they could be ran on different hardware. Likewise, consider lossless compression. It is an accurate model of the data in shorter form.
- ithkuil 7y agoThis is a good example where overloading the meaning of a word decreases its usefulness. There might be a better word for "an effective copy of the same underlying thing but with a different substrate/implementation"; perhaps "homomorphisms", perhaps make up a new word.
- AstralStorm 7y agoWe have the word already in art, it's a sketch or diorama - something known to not be an accurate representation. Or just call it a simplification instead of a model. It's a subset of all models. Alternatively, an explanation of it captures all the detail. Model is combined with another interesting word, essence as in essential, which is what it's supposed to capture, for given purpose. If the purpose of the model is explanatory power and accuracy, these two do not necessarily form a one dimensional trade-off.
- ithkuil 7y agoI think it would be easier to just accept that "model" already means "simplified description" (source https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/model https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/model) and use another word to refer to the superset you're mentioning. That's because language is mostly useful for communication between people, here and now. Treating a natural language as a construct to refine until it reaches a mathematical beauty where nice and short words mean what they "should mean" often causes so much grief and wasted energy.
- ysleepy 7y agoImplementation is an aspect though, possibly the non-relevant one for your usecase. A braindump would keep some aspects, like the neuron configuration etc, but discard others, like vascular properties, exact positional information of neurons etc. You could even go as deep as exact positioning of all contained atoms in the original brain.
- na85 7y agoOne of my profs was fond of the saying "with enough money, anyone can design a bridge that will stand up. Only an engineer can design a bridge that will just stay up". I think the same is true of simulation and modeling: it requires a domain expert to include the useful stuff in your model while skirting or abstracting away the extraneous bits.
- salty_biscuits 7y agoTo quote Ulam Knowing what is big and what is small is more important than being able to solve partial differential equations.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toomanybeersies 7y agoThe second year civil engineers at my university had a project where they had to design a bridge that could support 2 people, but would break under the weight of 3, to teach that exact lesson.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoPeople vary in weight by more than 50%. I don't see that the spec is possible.
- lugg 7y agoWoosh.. That's the point!
- flashingleds 7y agoThe three people are known to you in advance (it’s your group). It was common to game this a little by saving the biggest person as the third one that had to break the bridge.
- jobigoud 7y agoWell a 1:1 map is super useful. This is another use-case of VR. You can visit appartments or wander the World in Google Earth. I also used this recently for renovation work, my wife created the model of how the studio would look in the future, I imported it in Unity and we visited it in VR before starting the groundwork. The trick is that the map itself is 1:1 but your moving around in the map is not constrained by the same limitations as in the real world.
- simonh 7y agoArguably the trick is it's not a physical map, which isn't a detail that would have needed to be specified when the saying first came into use.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoPhysical 1:1 maps are still useful. They have numerous military applications, and in general allow you to become familiar with an area without having to physically be in that area, if being there or getting there is difficult for any reason.
- pelario 7y agoDo you have any example of a Physical 1:1 map ? I truly believed that such a thing is (physically) impossible.
- lordnacho 7y agoI would imagine soldiers train for urban combat in actual houses or whatever landscape they need.
- grkvlt 7y agoMaybe Exercise Tiger[0] w which was a rehearsal for the D-Day Normandy landings, where they created a replica of the beach landscape that would be encountered. Or there's Sindh Kalay[1] which is an Afghan village created in Norfolk, UK. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exercise_Tiger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exercise_Tiger 1. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain/welcome-to-afghanistan-no-norfolk-1919462.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain/welcome-t...
- neokantian 7y agoAbstraction, i.e. modelling, means leaving out details. Understanding then becomes knowing what details you can leave out for the given purpose. In this context, it is essential to remark that scientific abstractions, i.e. physical-world, empirical theories, need to be tested experimentally. Otherwise, they will simply lack legitimacy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mannykannot 7y ago> This paradox may be used by researchers to explain why complete models of the human brain and thinking processes have not been created and will undoubtedly remain difficult for years to come. This assertion would only be justified if we knew enough to create complex models that we do not understand. The reality is that we don't know enough yet to create any sort of working model of the whole human brain and its thinking processes.
- hprotagonist 7y agoEssential nonlinearities are rife in the little of neurophysiology that we've encountered. I am more or less sold on (possibly deterministic) chaotic models for things like tinnitus. That's close enough to "a complex model we cannot understand" for me.
- mannykannot 7y agoMy point is not that Bonini's paradox is false; it is that it is being used incorrectly, in the quoted passage, to 'explain' something that has a different explanation. The paradox itself seems to me to be almost certainly true, but rather trivially so, without adding much at all to our understanding of complex systems. There are a lot of incomplete models that are useful and add to our understanding of the thing being modeled.
- hhs 7y agoInteresting view. You write: “The reality is that we don't know enough yet to create any sort of working model of the whole human brain and its thinking processes.” To me, this sentence seems to mean that it may be possible some time down the road to “know enough” and create a complex model of the human brain that’s understandable. There are also some in philosophy who argue that humans may be cognitively closed off to understanding things like the human brain [0]. They note that humans have biological limits to understanding certain things just like an animal might. For instance, an ant, may have biological limits to its understanding of how certain things work. What do you think of philosophers who argue of cognitive closure? [0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_closure_(philosophy) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_closure_(philosoph....
- OrgNet 7y agodang, thanks for stating the obvious professor Charles Bonini.
- louis8799 7y agoA realistic model is hard for human to understand, but it didn't account for the case that human can leverage computing power to simulate and machine learn whatever is "realistic".
- falcor84 7y agoThis is an interesting point - if I create a fully accurate model that allows me to quickly simulate the outcome of any input, then that becomes an oracle that I can query to better understand the problem. But this then leads me to think that my understanding would then be a simpler mental model of what the simulation does, which brings me back to the original paradox.
- d--b 7y agoThe Paul Valéry statement’s translation is fairly poor. It sounds more like: “What is simple is always wrong. What is not is unusable”
- AstralStorm 7y agoAnd the most important bit is left out - you have to know when and how the model is inaccurate or even the simple one is useless. Explanatory power is limited by explanation of errors.
- falcor84 7y agoExactly - this seems to be the issue with many models in the social sciences, they often seem to do equally well at explaining opposite outcomes
- notafraudster 7y agoI think the George Box aphorism linked at the bottom ("All models are wrong [but some are useful]") is closer to the right way to think about this. With complexity comes additional explanatory power. Something with perfect explanatory power has infinite complexity. But the tradeoff is not linear in most problem domains; we can first add those concepts to our model that maximize the explanatory power relative to the complexity they introduce. And much of the world, physical and social, can be explained in fairly simple models, which is excellent. For things that are less well captured with simple models, or for which precision is so important we wish to shrink the error term further, then great, pile on more complexity progressively.
- hotBacteria 7y agoTwo points not mentionned: 1- The question of access: A theorical exhaustive map of the brain would be easier to access than an actual brain. 2- Tools: A map is not a piece of paper anymore. A 1:1 map of Earth doesn't seem absurd, as long as we can navigate it with levels of details
- mrob 7y agoA cycle accurate emulator is a 1:1 model of the observed behavior of the original hardware under normal operating conditions (it doesn't model probing it with an oscilloscope, or running it at the the wrong voltage or temperature etc.). It's more useful than the original hardware because its state can be saved and restored and examined, and you can set breakpoints and watchpoints, and easily interface it with other software, and it can run at different speeds to the original.
- sytelus 7y agoYou are confusing between useful systems vs explainable systems vs understandable systems. All models, 1:1 or not are useful in some sense. You might also be able to explain some event or behaviour of the system using a model. However, understanding requires building abstractions graph that can allow an arbitrary chain of reasoning and inference. As system becomes complex, such abstraction graph might result in similar complexity resulting in inability of a human to store in memory and execute inference/reasoning over it.
- dearrifling 7y agoHaving a complex model that describes a complex system is not unusable though. There is a reason we want to accurately simulate the Navier-Stokes equations with complex boundary conditions.
- phoe-krk 7y agoTo quote the original article: "As a model of a complex system becomes more complete, it becomes less understandable. Alternatively, as a model grows more realistic, it also becomes just as difficult to understand as the real-world processes it represents" If your model is simple enough to represent the original system accurately, then the original system is not complex.
- dearrifling 7y agoIf your model is simple enough to represent the original system accurately, then the original system is not complex. My model can be complex enough to represent the original system and still be useful. I can iterate on design and make measurements without building the real thing.
- phoe-krk 7y ago> My model can be complex enough to represent the original system This does not mean that your model is not complex. It means that the system is simple. At least, it is simple enough to be represented fully in a model. I think this paradox refers mostly to systems that are too complex to be represented in any model at full accuracy, and must therefore be simplified.
- AstralStorm 7y agoThe paradox invokes an absolute. How do you even know the system is "too complex"? Maybe it is too complex for humans but not for a galaxy brain?
- 7y ago
- lanevorockz 7y agoI keep on saying this about the sociology research. They keep on using single variables to track complex systems and they end up failing. All of the lazy social justice fields end up causing immense damage.
- meuk 7y agoThis seems to be more of a tautology than a paradox.
- gouh 7y agoWe don't necessarily create complex simulations to understand them, but to have those simulation available to then build for e.g reinforcement learning models. To take a simple example, if you have a high-school wagon-rolling-down-a-slope Newton Physic exercise, then you can capture in your mind everything which explains the problem. But then take https://youtu.be/a3jfyJ9JVeM https://youtu.be/a3jfyJ9JVeM , it's still Newton, but so many constrains that we cannot picture in our mind everything and we are not even solving the problem with a close form equation anymore. But we have modeled a simulation which enable us to make experiments and build locomotion algorithm. Actually, you don't even need to understand Newton or Physics to implement that paper, you can just see it as optimizing a black box. In the future I could see that happen at larger scale. For eg we put everything we known about the brain or cells in a simulation, we can't picture what's really going on because the system is too complex, yet we can run simulations and optimize models to find for eg new cures, treatments, etc.