5 ms·
So the illegal part here is the lack of protections for the environment and workers, which is valid, but there's no reason for "recycled" to be in scare quotes;
by yjftsjthsd-h 7y ago
So the illegal part here is the lack of protections for the environment and workers, which is valid, but there's no reason for "recycled" to be in scare quotes; the process described is literally recycling. Unregulated recycling that's bad for the environment, but it's still breaking down waste into useful raw materials, so it still counts.
EDIT: Another objection to the framing here:
> “American people should address this issue. You have to fix your own problems. Don’t dump waste into Thailand — or any developing country.”
... or, you could not accept it. Y'know, "fix your own problems" rather than pointing your finger at big bad America.
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoAmerica exercises significant control over our poorer trade partners, and we have great power here. We could require oversight and review of our e-waste recycling partners, or we can just dump our waste out of sight and claim no responsibility in the matter. One approach would solve the problem, and one shifts blame to someone much less power to really solve the problem.
- Scoundreller 7y agoThat’s still hard to do. I think consumers would care more if we just held unreliable manufacturers to account. Either make stuff that keeps working or the manufacturer has to pay to repair it. We do it with cars (lemon law), why not everything else that’s repairable. Spare parts must be available, or else. Repair schematics must be made available. A competitor can reverse engineer anything anyway, so the benefit of being secretive is outweighed by consumer interests. Finally, more effort toward “second-lifing” old stuff instead of shredding it. E.g. old phones as security cameras.
- jolfdb 7y agoYou don't need all those weird rules, all you need is a recycling tax on the product, and let market forces sort it out.
- Scoundreller 7y agoHow do you determine the tax? Is the government to determine how long different car models and manufacturers will last? Even if you charge a flat tax ($50 per laptop), there’s still little incentive for the manufacturer to provide ongoing support. Don’t underestimate the power of marketing to convince people to ignore the future.
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoThat $50 flat tax will also make it harder for anyone new to compete (the practicality of which seems to be getting higher instead of lower with all these SBC's and the like). Don't underestimate the power of law to shape the future of companies, and which ones survive.
- Scoundreller 7y agoWe probably could do better with re-use. A lot of stuff isn’t as disposable as people think, but they throw it out anyway. A broken HDTV could be a matter of re-seating a Cable, replacing a fuse (why aren’t they resettable???), or a new backlight or power supply board. But the average person will just toss it to the curb. Even if they tried to repair it in Asia, it’s already further destroyed. In other words, we should treat waste electronics more like wrecked cars.
- andihnesq 7y agoThe illegal part is that you are not a Cab, Sir. May they call you a cab? No they may call you something quite completely else. They may. Who in the trucking industry knows.
- andihnesq 7y agoWe might call each other anything, by the time all the down-votes ensue. Vote schizophrenia
- Scoundreller 7y agoWell, if you think there is an issue to resolve (e.g. schizophrenia), have you contacted someone you trust?
- tomc1985 7y agoThere are a lot of weasel words and problems with tone in the article. It struck me as more a propaganda piece than anything else.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI agree, but still some useful points made: there’s lots of garbage poorly processed overseas, and one country trying to fix the problem can just push the problem elsewhere. A coordinated approach is required. Or improve the supply side (which is already happening, like RoHS and more integration). E.g. Set top boxes aren’t the size of VCRs anymore.