3 ms·
> "Materials known as superconductors transmit electrical energy with 100% efficiency." What is the level of (in)efficieny for say power lines? And power cords
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
> "Materials known as superconductors transmit electrical energy with 100% efficiency."
What is the level of (in)efficieny for say power lines? And power cords, etc around the office/house?
That is, of the electricity produced, how much is lost due to how it's transported? Does decentralizing production (e.g., solar panels on your own roof) help in any way?
- krageon 7y agoI'm normally not a fan of responding like this, but here goes: If you really do not know these things that is of course perfectly acceptable, but if they truly interested you you could very easily find the information about this out there. After all, it is knowledge you get in any highschool curriculum that even smells faintly of technical information. Given that you do not yet have this (as you miss other, related knowledge), giving you a good response that doesn't involve a lot of theory is very hard. Certainly a response that makes you aware of the nuances in this subject would involve some study. If that does not scare you, I invite you to take a look at a place like this: https://www.khanacademy.org/science/electrical-engineering/ee-electrostatics/ee-fields-potential-voltage/a/ee-electric-potential-voltage https://www.khanacademy.org/science/electrical-engineering/e... and study some of the source material.
- jacquesm 7y agoThere is no such thing as a dumb question and if there is one thing that I love about HN it is that people will take the time to answer questions.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoNot only will people answer, it's answers from people who actually know (and are willing to share).
- amirhirsch 7y agoThis isn’t a good answer. On average in the US we lose 7% of power in transmission and 8% in power conversion. I pulled these numbers out of thin air, but it’s probably accurate to within a factor of 2 for wherever you are. A home solar power system might mean 7% lost in dc to ac and then you still lose 8% for conversion so basically 5-20% of all the power you produce is lost before it reaches its destination. A more didactic answer might start with defining power, P=IV (power equals current times voltage) and “ohm’s law” V=IR (voltage equals current times resistance) and suggest this means that the power lost to the resistance of transmission line with resistance R is P=I^2R. Since the current you send is proportion to the voltage (One megawatt can be 1Amp at 1000000 Volts or 1000Amp at 1000 Volts, you want to use as high voltage as possible when transmitting long distances. The limiting factor on voltage is the amount of insulation required. Usually power transmission uses three-phase alternating current, which sends power by varying the voltage on three lines each 120 degrees (1/3 period) offset from one another. It’s reasonable homework to read about why AC is better for transmission and also how three phase AC works and determine the economic value of laying three cables instead of two, with variables for the cost of wire, fixed costs per mile, and cost of electricity. ~50% of transmitted power is used to drive three-phase synchronous AC motors. Resistance is related to the resistivity (denoted with a Greek rho) of the material and the cross-sectional area (denoted A) and length (L) of the wire: R=rhoL/A Resistivity is a fundamental property of materials and is related to the free movement of the outer shell of electrons of atoms in a crystal lattice. Superconductors do not have resistance and can carry an extremely large current as a result. Unfortunately superconductors have a maximum magnetic field capacity and require extremely low temperatures requiring cooling with liquid helium or nitrogen.
- jacquesm 7y agoSmaller than or equal to about 1 percent is fairly normal for high voltage lines, lower voltage lines carry more current for a given amount of power and will experience higher losses.
- skosch 7y agoThe bit of heat produced in a power line isn't a huge deal. The more important applications will be in electronics and electromagnets. For instance, it would make nuclear fusion reactors cheaper and easier to build.
- atupis 7y agoAlso batteries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_magnetic_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_magnetic_energ...
- chiefalchemist 7y agoSo this isn't about advancing scale and distribution, it's at the end product and product sub-component level. Good to know.
- jerf 7y agoIt is also possible it will enable some setups that aren't currently possible. Part of why transmission loss in power lines is as low as it is is that we build plants near to where the electricity is going to be used, so it's not some sort of physics law that the loss is that low, it's engineering. Right now, the "plate the Sahara in solar to power Europe" solution is not technically feasible due to the transmission loss across that distance. Obviously that's a special case of the general problem of natural power sources not being where people live. If we can transmit power without loss, we get some more options than we have now. I'd still guess the bulk of the value would be in more local uses, but there are some interesting large-scale possibilities, including power transmission.
- sfasfsafd 7y agoYa, but the science popularizers always make it about transmission :S
- ben_w 7y agoThe inefficiency/losses depends on the distance, the voltage, and a few other things. In practice, losses are about 5% in the USA. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission#Losses https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission#...
- Faark 7y agoUS grid: losses are 5%. EU grid was in the same ballpark. The wiki page [0] is the source and was pretty much the best summary i could find when i was looking for it a while back. I'd love to read better material about it. Btw, losses seem to include theft. Wonder if much of a thing that still is. > In general, losses are estimated from the discrepancy between power produced (as reported by power plants) and power sold to the end customers [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission#Losses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission#Lo...
- TrevorJ 7y agowow, that's way better than I would have imagined.
- TallGuyShort 7y ago5% loss isn't that bad, but that's because they're being limited in a lot of ways to keep the efficiency high. Dropping current and increasing voltage, for instance. If you had a 100% efficient conductor, you could do things like transmit monstrously high levels of current without having to worry about stuff like that.
- MayeulC 7y agoTrue, although the superconducting effect is lost under high electric fields. A superconducor rejects magnetic fields (a bit like a Faraday cage). What if you cranck it up high enough and force the superconductor in place? You lose superconductivity. For that reason, there is actually a limit to thew current that can be transmitted, though it is much higher than with conventional cables (you still can't power a city with a hair-thin cable, IIRC).
- sfasfsafd 7y agoInsignificant: EEs can lower the losses by increasing the line voltage [0], at the expense of other challenges (namely taller pylons). It's about 5% over the length of the line. Consider the other losses: - Thermal (gas turbine) cycle: 40-60% lost (the big one) - Transformer loss: 1-2%. You pay this every time you step up/down, so it adds up. - Capacitive coupling: I dunno, but length dependent. It has to be about the same as Ohmic losses since once it's large you switch to DC lines (and take an Ohmic loss hit from lower V) - You're house's power factor (which, unlike industrial users, you're not charged for). [0] in the sixties very large V lines were introduced (0.75 - 1.0 MV ??). They work, but it's not considered worthwhile.
- sfasfsafd 7y agoAlso, super conductors are limited by the amount of magnetic field, and therefore current they can carry [0] (above that limit they become normal conductors). Lowering T bellow Tc, increasing P increases the amount of current you can carry. Point is, they're kinda useless for transmission. [0] MRI magnets are superconducting for the efficiency of superconductors, not for the field strength! The strongest magnets are not made of superconductors but out of copper pipes: electrical conductors with coolant pumped through them!