14 ms·
Isn’t Android open source? So why can’t Huawei simply fork it?
by EGreg 7y ago
Isn’t Android open source? So why can’t Huawei simply fork it?
- qwertydog 7y agoI think the main issue is the play store is off limits i.e. no existing android apps
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThe play store is unavailable within China anyway, so alternatives certainly exist.
- enriquto 7y agoThe play store is not the sole way to distribute apps. You can download the .apk files, or get them by mail, or use another play store that has the same apps. The play store is just a repository of some apps.
- lol768 7y agoI believe the Play store is treated 'special' though - F-Droid can't install apps in the same way unless you're rooted and install the priv-app.
- zmmmmm 7y agoOn a phone licensing the Play Store sure. But on a Huawei phone free of those restrictions they can make it use any store they want without any special restrictions. Of course, it becomes a question what that means for security, but still.
- bluGill 7y agoThat seems like a violation of anit-trustlaws. I'm surprised the FSF hasn't pursued this route against google.
- josinalvo 7y agoI did not root my phone yet, and I install apps with f-droid just fine. The only thing I had to do, if I recall correctly, was enabling third party apps instalation
- lol768 7y agoTry it again and watch the process closely. You'll get an additional prompt when you use F-Droid that doesn't appear with the Play store.
- josinalvo 7y agoIndeed there is an extra confirmation step, and it freezes some processes (specifically, those that alter the screen, like red shifters)
- JohnFen 7y agoI don't think that the lack of Google Play would be a huge problem. I use Android devices in the US and don't use Google Play.
- jmkni 7y agoThe OS is open source, Google Play Services isn't. When you are developing Android apps, you can leverage Google Play Services for all sorts of functionality, such as push notifications and maps, and I would say more apps do use these than don't. Huawei can still put Android on their phones, but not with Google Play Services. This means that many Android apps just won't work. They also can't supply the Google Play Store, which means that they need an alternate way to distribute apps.
- snaky 7y agoHuawei could make their own Play Services, API-compatible with Google, then all apps would work the same. Maybe that's what they actually do now.
- sbarre 7y agoAs the article says, Amazon spent _years_ trying this approach and ultimately failed with their phone project. So sure it's possible, but it's not as easy as you perhaps think?
- rob74 7y agoWell, yes, but maybe the failure was more due to not many users being willing to accept that much vendor lock-in, rather than issues with Amazon's Android version?
- snaky 7y agoAmazon tried to make their own copy of Play Store, not Play Services.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoAmazon's phone failed because it was a new product in a very crowded market that didn't offer anything new of significance.
- bregma 7y agoAw c'mon, it's just software.
- kuschku 7y agoGoogle has spent the last decade cutting apart the open part of Android and making it more and more proprietary. Launcher, Phone app, Messages, Contacts, Calendar. All proprietary. Notification API, Location API, SMS APIs and step counter APIs, and even the new app format. All proprietary. It's a huge undertaking building an app for Android today without using Google's services, and sometimes even impossible. If you want to verify a user by sending a code through SMS (think Whatsapp sign-up) you either have to use the proprietary API, or you'll be banned from the play store. Using the open source API instead gets you banned because it allows you to read all SMS — and Google never cared to build a new open source API because they already have their proprietary API anyway. And nowadays you don't have APKs anymore but often app bundles, a special format which only the Play Store can parse. And if you create a new app today, per default you don't even get the signing key to publish APKs yourself, but only Google gets to keep it.
- rapsey 7y ago> Google has spent the last decade cutting apart the open part of Android and making it more and more proprietary. Replacing those bits is still less work than writing your own entire OS. There are even open source projects to replace those bits.
- kuschku 7y agoYes, microG exists and is amazing — but even it is only replacing an absolutely tiny part of the APIs, and even those it can’t replace fully yet and a lot of work is still to be done. I remember days when Android was still open, nowadays I’m fighting against the ever-increasing restrictions with my open source apps with every single OS update.
- acct1771 7y agoNo, no, no - GP isn't saying replace the bits that support the proprietary Google services. They're saying that there's easy and simple drop in replacements, app and service wise that can hook into better services/ones you host.
- tw04 7y agoWhy do you think Google is working on Fuschia? The second a major competitor forks android in any meaningful way, I guarantee they switch to Fushia and stop all further contributions to Android.
- rurban 7y agoThey not only forked it, they also improved it. They are e.g. the only one who built their own secure Annex K C11 extensions, besides Android Bionic. Android first did it with an old HP stlport, and then Bionic did it with C++ (Google style). Huawei did it in 1998 already in C. They also are using safer xen compartments, as Amazon did until recently or Qubes is doing. kvm is fast, but certainly not secure. Personally I trust Huawei more than Google, and esp. LG, Sony or Samsung. The current war on Huawei looks like Huawei is denying the US their backdoors into the baseband layer on 5G. Loosing 5G would be big for US intelligence, and good for privacy. China getting access into 5G backdoors is not as worrying as continued US abuse.