4 ms·
This article caused me to remember something I heard on a Youtube video and wanted to follow up on. Essentially, is there (and if so what is) the framerate of
by freedomben 7y ago
This article caused me to remember something I heard on a Youtube video and wanted to follow up on. Essentially, is there (and if so what is) the framerate of the universe? It makes logical sense to have a minimum bundle of time based on Planck's constant, so I did some googling and found the answer (I have not checked this math)[1]:
> The Planck time is 5.39 × 10-44 seconds. No measurable time can be shorter than that according to quantum physics.
Converting to FPS, that gives us:
> One thousand eight hundred and fifty-five billion billion billion billion frames per second. 18.55 septillion FPS!
So if like me you wondered if a trillion FPS is close to the maximum possible frame rate in the universe, the answer is nope!
[1]: http://www.librador.com/2009/01/16/The-frame-rate-of-the-universe/ http://www.librador.com/2009/01/16/The-frame-rate-of-the-uni...
- klank 7y agoDon't confuse "our math breaks down at this point" with "it can't physically happen". Planck time is the time at which, if you want to do physics, you have to take into account quantum mechanics and gravity (i.e. understand quantum gravity). Something we don't know how to do. But it doesn't necessarily mean time is discrete. Maybe it is. Maybe it isn't. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_time#Physical_significance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_time#Physical_significa...
- freedomben 7y agoThanks for the link. I was referring to measurable time (since for frame rate we must have discrete intervals), but it sounds like that is still up for debate.
- pier25 7y agoDoes the same reasoning apply to the Plank length or is that one discreet?
- lodi 7y agoAs I understand it, currently everything points to space and time (really, spacetime) not being discrete. I'm copying and pasting a previous reply I made the last time this came up. --- I'm no physicist, but the layman explanation I've heard is that the concepts of Planck length and Planck time do not imply that spacetime is discretized into little "voxels"; instead these quantities are just limits on the uncertainty of any possible measurement. As I understand it there are two contributing facts: a) the Heisenberg uncertainty principle states that there's a tradeoff between certainty in position vs momentum, so if you're more certain in a particle's position you're less certain of its momentum. (For photons, momentum is proportional to frequency, i.e. wavelength, and frequency is proportional to energy.) b) By mass-energy equivalence, anything with energy has mass, therefore higher frequency photons are more "massive". A single photon of sufficiently high frequency would form a black hole. Putting those two together, to measure distances accurately you need higher and higher frequency photons with shorter and shorter wavelengths. For example, radar creates blurry images at ~5cm wavelengths, while ordinary photographs can be razor sharp with wavelengths of only ~500nm. The Planck length is just the wavelength at which the photon would have so much energy that it would collapse into a black hole and break our current mathematical models. That's why it's nonsensical--with current models--to talk about lengths smaller than a Planck length, but it doesn't mean that space itself is quantized. Similar argument for time. (Also, the same logic applies to other particles like electrons, protons, and even up to macroscopic items like baseballs; everything has a wavelength...)
- posix_compliant 7y agoSemi-related question: if photons can have various frequencies, does that mean protons can have various frequencies?
- skygazer 7y agoAKA temperatures?
- posix_compliant 7y agoI think temperature is a property based on the average kinetic energy of particles in a system. The frequency of a proton, I imagine, would be an intrinsic property.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kibwen 7y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but the Planck time concerns the smallest possible observable unit of time, but not necessarily the smallest possible unit of time, correct? As a bystander I get the impression that [science currently thinks that] it's beyond the limits of science to prove whether or not a unit of time smaller than the Planck time exists, and since there's no natural law that says that things only exist if they are provable, that means that the "tick rate" of the universe might be smaller than the Planck time.
- whatshisface 7y agoPlanck time is not the smallest observable unit of time, it is the smallest time step that present-day physics makes predictions about. Subtly, present-day physics might actually break down on timescales longer than the Planck time: it's not that we know it doesn't break down until Planck time, we know that it must break down at Planck time.
- platz 7y agoSusskind might say that it's not useful to take about a phenomena at all unless you have a theory about it. It might really be a boundary, but we don't know
- codethief 7y ago> Planck time […] is the smallest time step that present-day physics makes predictions about What are those predictions? Do you mean that > we know that it must break down at Planck time ? If so, do you have a source for this prediction? (I'm not asking why present-day physics must break down at extremely small scales. That prediction is more or less well established. What I'm asking is: Why is it the Planck scale that's so significant?) My impression was that most statements involving the Planck scale these days are rather numerology than actual, verifiable science [1]. [1] https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/185939/is-the-planck-length-the-smallest-length-that-exists-in-the-universe-or-is-it-th https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/185939/is-the-pl...
- ascar 7y agoA billion is 10^9 and a septillion 10^24. So a billion billion billion is already 10^27. One of your numbers is wrong.
- colejohnson66 7y agoA billion is a million millions in Britain, but a thousand millions in the US. His numbers are right, just a different scale
- NikkiA 7y agoThe UK hasn't used the long scale billion since 1974
- colejohnson66 7y agoI could swear I read somewhere that they still did. Oh well
- TkTech 7y agoThe only English-speaking countries left that still occasionally use the long-scale are Canada, Mauritius, Seychelles and Vanuatu. This is because they are bilingual nations that also speak French, where the long-scale is still used. Trying to do locales in Canada is always fun, since we can't make up our mind. "How far? 100km." "How tall? 5ft"
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago>A billion is a million millions in Britain // Not really. I think you'll struggle to find anyone who uses that now.
- ascar 7y agoEven if that would be the case and we use the long scale (million/milliard/billion) system, which I actually grew up with in Germany, a billion would be 10^12 and a septillion 10^42. It still doesn't add up.
- bufferoverflow 7y agoThis camera doesn't actually take 4 trillion shots a second. It shoots a light, takes a frame, shoots the light, waits a tiny bit longer, takes a frame, and so on. The phase shift is 1/(4 trillion) sec, but the actual framerate is much much slower.
- gugagore 7y agoThe same trick is used by some oscilloscopes for high-time-resolution sampling of periodic signals. I wonder if they also average the same phase-out shift multiple times to reduce noise (improving the bit depth of a single frame).
- ricardobeat 7y agoThat is how these cameras usually work, but not this one; the article describes a system of overlapping, time-shifted exposures instead, from a single event.
- kmm 7y agoThat is how an earlier trillion FPS camera worked, but in this case they do capture a handful of frames of a single event at a 100 femtosecond resolution. https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.122.193904 https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.12...
- agumonkey 7y ago> 18.55 septillion FPS! intel has some room to grow I see
- GuiA 7y agoFPS implies a single final render target. That’s a big assumption to make of the universe!