4 ms·
This spec literally defines a way of doing so without attribution - the various confirmation mechanisms are all done using stateless and cookieless network requ
by olliej 7y ago
This spec literally defines a way of doing so without attribution - the various confirmation mechanisms are all done using stateless and cookieless network requests - all the site operator gets is confirmation that someone did something.
The alternative is a browser breaking all the tracking mechanisms and then getting blocked because it’s “blocking ads”.
This provides an API that allows ads to work, while also allowing a browser to block all the tracking techniques currently being used.
That way web sites can have a revenue stream without gratuitously violating their reader’s privacy.
- 0xffff2 7y ago>The alternative is a browser breaking all the tracking mechanisms and then getting blocked because it’s “blocking ads”. That's fine. That's the browser I want. If a website doesn't want me to visit, that's fine. I won't.
- dcbadacd 7y agoI'd rather make it as hard as possible for any adtech to track me, a "standard" is the worst that can happen.
- olliej 7y agoDid you read the article, it specifically does not allow the site to track you.
- the_gipsy 7y agoThe spec is about doing attribution, literally. It makes the attribution anonymous just to work around privacy advancements that have been adopted recently. Until browsers get blocked for being anonymous, this is never in the interest of the user. And if a site doesn’t work unless I turn off adblock / switch browser, then it’s most likely bad on multiple levels.
- cfarm 7y agoAgree. To add, if we accepted this as the attribution source of truth, there would be large conflicts of interest from companies like Google who own an ad network and also Chrome. They would basically claim all Adwords traffic is awesome.