5 ms·
Knowing a bit about how Basecamp works after reading all of Jason Fried and DHH's books and blog, I can't really see how there could be a gender gap over there.
by onion2k 8y ago
Knowing a bit about how Basecamp works after reading all of Jason Fried and DHH's books and blog, I can't really see how there could be a gender gap over there. No one has to negotiate. The salary for a role is dictated by the market average for that role rather than the person doing it. No one has to negotiate a raise. Everyone gets the same raise to keep inline with the Bay Area market rate. Given those two things it'd be very hard to pay one person less than another if they're doing the same job regardless of any demographic differences between them.
Basing the salary on the role rather than person doing it seems like a really good idea to me.
- mariogintili 8y agoIt could create a black market where people underperform after seeing their peers underperform(wether on purpose or not). Different people have different performances when they perform the same trade...
- krautsourced 8y agoBlasphemy!
- wccrawford 8y agoIt could, but I'm sure they still have performance reviews. They might get paid the same regardless of effort, but at review time they might also get fired for not putting in enough effort.
- fuzz4lyfe 8y agoWhat I have found is that top talent will leave due to the lack of a pay differential between average and high performing talent. We all want our work to be recognized and paying everyone the same is a great way to get rid of the ambitious. If they pay in the top say 5% nationally that's less of a problem but if you are paying whatever glass door says the average is expect churn among high performers as they move to where that behavior is actively rewarded. Similarly such a policy probably encourages low performers to apply. This strikes me a managerial laziness, they aren't going to bother to put the effort in to decide who on their team should be rewarded.
- matwood 8y ago> This strikes me a managerial laziness It also avoids hard conversations. Now they do not have to tell Joe that he makes less than Suzy because Suzy is a better performer. But, maybe that's a good thing. Since we all lie to ourselves and think we are better than we are, Joe probably thinks he's killing it. And, since many people lose whatever maturity they have when talking about their performance vs. someone else particularly when there is money involved, that whole conversation can be skipped. The problem as you say though is what happens to Suzy. She will not be happy making the same as Joe since she will also think (and be correct) that she is a better performer. So either they only hire the same level performers (which is possible in a small company), or they start inventing job title/levels. At the end, it's trading one set of problems for another. I applaud them for trying out new ways to structure company wide compensation though.
- bluedino 8y agoI'm guessing low performers don't get hired or stay long. Either way, it's a good reason to not give two shits about what your co-worker makes.
- onion2k 8y agoWhat I have found is that top talent will leave due to the lack of a pay differential between average and high performing talent. I'm going to start coming across as a weird Basecamp fanboy/stalker soon, but on this particular point people don't seem to ever leave Basecamp. It's very rare for they to be hiring, which wouldn't be the case if they had a high level of staff turnover. What you've found is not applicable to them for some reason.
- jolfdb 8y agoIs it advisable to fire someone who does 80% productivity instead of paying them less and saying thank you? Bonus culture says No.
- onion2k 8y agoI don't know of any company that deals with someone who is underperforming by accepting that shortfall and paying them less. That would be weird.
- funnybeam 8y agoActually it’s extremely common but better known as performance related pay. This is framed as paying staff a bonus based on how well they have contributed but is often used to distribute the same pool of money, avoiding giving staff salary increases and effectively giving poor performers a pay cut.
- swombat 8y agoA kind of pay gap can still sneak in by having roles that are typically favoured by women being less well paid. Also via women being penalised for taking time off to have children (in the US, probably quite a significant thing given the paucity of holidays). And another pay gap that's still quite insidious is when women are passed over for promotion to the next level that has a higher pay grade. This is not quite as bad as two people doing the exact same job being paid differently, but it can still lead to a pay gap, and some of those factors are worth being conscious of and addressing.
- onion2k 8y agoBasecamp's maternity/paternity policy is "Paid Parental Leave: When you welcome a new baby, Basecamp encourages you to take up to 16 weeks maternity leave and up to 6 weeks paternity leave, at 100% paid salary. Single fathers, or primary care givers, can also take up to 16 weeks." (correct as of 2016) As I understand it that's amazing compared to most American companies. It's roughly equivalent to what you get in progressive European countries.
- gdfasfklshg4 8y agoScandinavian countries have more like a year parental leave.
- mcv 8y agoIt's comparable to mainland Europe, and better than some: in Netherland, I believe paternity leave has just been expanded from 2 days to 2 weeks. 6 weeks is significantly better, but probably falls short of what Scandinavian parents get.
- gdfasfklshg4 8y agoPaternity leave is still shocking in many countries.
- throwawayosiu1 8y ago