18 ms·
Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher”
- alasdair_ 7y agoOne solution to the problem of schools ranking kids with a B average versus a C average is simply to not let individuals set the grades at all. Have a national set of standard exams (as is done in the UK and many other countries). This doesn’t solve the issue completely - schools turn into “SAT prep centers” to an extent - but it definitely helps compare students and teaching across multiple schools.
- tracker1 7y agoThis is already happening in the US... many schools are teaching for the testing. Those that come up with the standards are making bank providing course materials and publishing. They publish disposable workbooks instead of textbooks to ensure they change each year and require new purchases. I'm surprised more districts, teachers and schools haven't worked to create more open curriculums.
- tlear 7y agoOr even better have colleges administer their own exams. Oral ones are best ;) this is how it worked in USSR. Nobody cared what marks you had in high school as village school and good city schools were completely different. You came to exam and had 3 hours and 5 problems(example of physics entrance exam to KGU) you then went and presented your solution if you had any to examiners. They could grill you to explain your solution
- Pulcinella 7y agoAnother solution is no traditional grades at all. Introduce standards based grading (tldr: grading if a student met the learning standard or not).
- romwell 7y agoThe title is misleading (it was meant to be intriguing, but doesn't convey the summary of the article well). The letter, in fact, is a well-balanced rebuke to Caplan's treatise "The Case Against Education". The tl;dr of the treatise is that schools manufacture signaling instead of value, with the implication that they inherently cannot produce value. This rebuke is that the schools produce signaling because they are incentives are aligned this way. Producing signal vs. value becomes a prisoner's dilemma, where it's rational to focus on manufacturing signal. Ergo, the schools and educators are not to blame. Hate the game, don't hate the player. I agree with the rebuke.
- ikeboy 7y agoThis is a rebuke only to the extent that "the emperor enjoys the breeze" is a rebuke to someone pointing out that the emperor is naked.
- romwell 7y agoNot quite. It's like someone someone is pointing out that the emperor is naked, and the rebuke is "Have you considered that we are all at a beach, and invited the Emperor to go skinny dipping with us". Merely pointing out that the emperor is naked, without sufficient consideration for context, implies that there is something terribly wrong with the emperor. You'd think that the guy just walks around naked! Now with context, you understand that if you expect the Emperor to be clothed, then perhaps you shouldn't have spent the whole week convincing him to go skinny-dipping with you, and then act surprised when you are both at a beach. The fault, if any, is with what you asked of the Emperor. So here we are with education. We tell our kids to do well in school so that they could go to a good college and get a good job (a chain that revolves around signaling!), measure the education by signaling it provides (acceptance rates, employment rates out of college), and then insert surprised Pikachu write books about how education is a waste because it's about signaling!
- ikeboy 7y agoI think many if not most people involved in academia would strongly disagree that it teaches you nothing. Caplan's thesis was certainly not widely accepted prior to publication.
- jessriedel 7y ago> with the implication that they inherently cannot produce value. Where in Caplan's book does it say this? To the contrary, I believe he points to specific cases where we know schools could produce more value (e.g., spaced repetition) but do not.
- btilly 7y agoThe most obvious example of this game theoretic problem in teaching is the phenomena of "teaching to the test". Focusing on preparing students to generate the right signal, rather than laying the foundation for long-term comprehension of the material.
- drngdds 7y agoI don't disagree, but this is a simple point and all the math language doesn't really add anything to it.
- padobson 7y agoAnybody up for a grand bargin? I'll trade you Medicare-for-All in exchange for a complete privatization (w/ vouchers) of education.
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoPrivatization would make these sorts of problems worse, as schools compete more vigorously to sell signalling value to parents. The fix is to monopolize signalling value through legal fiat - make it illegal to ask job applicants or allow applicants to disclose the school they attended, and replace it with an examination and/or interview based certification monopoly.
- bunderbunder 7y agoAnd, indeed, what studies are available seem to confirm this. Not just for private schools - charter schools also tend to underperform the public schools. Granted, kids who go to them do tend to get better test scores, go to better universities, have more successful careers, etc. But that's because the whole education industry is a massive exercise in selection bias. The most careful studies I've seen, though, seem to indicate that, all other factors being equal, a typical kid is going to learn more in public school than in private or charter school. This rather mirrors my own experience. I did 2 years of public high school, and 2 years of college prep. I can say that it's absolutely true that my classmates were generally smarter and more studious in the prep school. But the prep school was also easy. It really didn't particularly matter how much effort I put into my homework. As long as I didn't blatantly blow it off, my teachers would dutifully send my parents a report card full of the As and Bs they were paying for. By contrast, it was the public schools where I had the teachers who'd keep ratcheting up their expectations until they could sense that I was actually working to try and get good grades on my papers.
- hakfoo 7y agoIn terms of actual student performance (as opposed to grades), I'd expect parents to be a major factor. They're going to build support networks-- running the fundraisers, supporting extracurriculars, keeping an eye on student performance and scandals. When we provide "options" -- charters, private schooling, even public magnets-- the parents who are motivated and concerned enough to build those networks tend to pounce on them. The "default" public school loses its champions and ends up producing worse outcomes for everyone whose parents aren't tuned in.
- logicx24 7y agoGame theory is a useful framework for this problem in the sense that almost any double-sided market can be trivially formulated into a game-theoretic framework. But viewing college admissions as a Nash equilibrium doesn't meaningfully clarify the problem. That said, I generally agree with the article. America's elite private universities have almost always been about signalling over substance, an orientation that can be traced back to their origins as bastions of elite privilege. Our recent attempts at reform, via affirmative action and more recently, the SAT adversity score, have been nothing more than attempts to spread the benefits of signalling to new, heretofore underrepresented, groups. The real solution, of course, is to tear this reputation market down. We need to work to remove the signalling benefits of so-called "elite" institutions, and in doing so, remove their stranglehold on access to a number of prestigious jobs and career paths. How do we do this? I'm not sure, exactly. The radical solution is to nationalize all universities, redistribute their endowments more equitably, and enforce a singular admissions and educational process on all of them. This enforced uniformity would destroy "elite" signalling. There are incremental steps to this, though. Implement new rules to force colleges to expand their enrollment to maintain non-profit status (and thus retain untaxed earnings from their endowments). Pour more money in flagship public universities to create strong alternatives to private education (i.e. make a UC Berkeley for every state). And so on. Reduce the distinctiveness of the elite privates, and their value as signalling institutions decreases.
- 0815test 7y ago"Tearing the reputation market down" is not generally a good solution, people want to acquire reputation for sensible reasons and tearing one market down just leads to it being replaced by other, generally suboptimal markets. What you actually want to do is (1) stop subsidizing reputational games heavily, so that agents who engage in them don't get to externalize their cost to third parties, and (2) try to outcompete the standard reputation game by signaling the same desirable qualities more cheaply. The latter is sometimes difficult to do in the case of education, because conformity is itself something that people might want to signal, and it's hard to outcompete prevailing standards while conforming to them. But providing alternatives is still valuable, because sooner or later you'll get a positive unraveling cascade where people realize that the advantages of conforming to the existing standard don't justify the cost, and it's better to switch to a cheaper alternative. (It's something that's mostly unpredictable however, since it works on the principle of a popularity contest where the prediction itself is what people are constantly optimizing for!)
- tptacek 7y agoThis letter is making some pretty superficial observations that I don't think hold up. The background you need for the letter is the debate between "human capital" (H.C.) and "signaling" in education; H.C. is a longhand for "intrinsically valuable", and signaling is a shorthand for "indirectly valuable by improving the student's reputation". First, the author (correctly, I think? I suck at math but this sounds correct) believes that AP Stat would be better for H.C. than AP Calc, which is mostly about signaling. School districts have to decide which courses to carry, and the author presumes they carry AP Calc to minmax for prestige college admissions. Second, the author observes that schools have varying levels of rigor; a better, rigorous school might give a C where a weaker, more generous school would give a B. The weaker school produces graduates with higher GPAs, again minmaxing for college admissions over H.C. Problems with both observations: 1. It's not clear that AP Stat disadvantages students versus AP Calc. The author didn't make the argument that AP classes in general optimize for signaling --- that argument seems harder to defend. So why don't high schools sub out Calc for Stat? "Because colleges would have a problem with that" doesn't seem like the answer. So what are we left with? "There are better high school math curricula than the ones we have now?" Lots of people already agree with that. 2. Selective colleges already account for the differing rigor of different high schools. A 3.4 at one school is not necessarily as valuable as the 3.4 of every other school.
- swivelmaster 7y agoI think you've misunderstood. I believe the H.C. argument is that statistics are far more valuable in real life than Calculus, but Calculus is more heavily valued as an "advanced class" for signaling purposes.
- wolf550e 7y ago> First, the author (correctly, I think? I suck at math but this sounds correct) believes that AP Stat would be better for H.C. than AP Calc, which is mostly about signaling. It seems you agree with 'tptacek
- educomments 7y ago> 1. It's not clear that AP Stat disadvantages students versus AP Calc. This is what stuck out to me. Isn't AP Calculus the obvious choice if you have to choose between AP Stats and AP Calculus? 1. Calculus is really, really useful. Maybe AP Stats is also useful, but singling out Calculus as an example of useless signalling sets off really loud alarm bells. 2. If you want a STEM/Engineering degree, at least one Calculus course is required. More importantly, often a long sequence of 2-4 courses (Calculus I, II, III and ODEs) are required. Because of that long list of sequentially dependent required courses, getting one or two calculus courses out of the way in high school is enormously useful (like, "graduate a semester earlier for each course" useful). AP Stats is not at the head of this sort of long sequential course dependency. 3. The AP Stats course has a major disadvantage: lots of colleges/majors that require a stats course don't accept AP Stats as credit because they require a calculus-based statistics course.
- hatefuck 7y agoWhat’s really funny about this is the troop of elephants in the room. 1. for some students, all the money in the world won’t change the fact that they permanently suck. 2. the fundamental premise of what we think of as education simply works by luck. Some people cannot be educated. They suck as children. They suck as adults. They die stupid and shitty. Meanwhile, operating according to a curriculum that is jam packed with garbage that is not engaging and has no practical applications to the situations confronted on the ground, in real life, means most “education” is a thumb twiddling waste of time. The net output of this is a system that spitballs for personalities that might serve best as paid thinkers, and the rest get ejected into vocational scenarios with pieces of paper. In short, fuck the lot of you. Everyone is dancing around hot potatos of brutal truth.
- NoNameHaveI 7y agoFrom the article: "Schools of standard C produce graduates who are more ready for college. Schools of standard B produce graduates who appear more college ready." I just left a job teaching community college in Iowa, who is now boasting the nation's highest high school graduation rate. Having taught community college in a different state, I can honestly say that many, if not most, community college students I saw were just not ready for college. Doesn't matter what the graduation rate, or even GPA was. They were just not ready for the responsibility. Far too many could not even be bothered to read directions.
- gnicholas 7y agoDoesn't this overlook the fact that there are standardized tests, which allow colleges to ascertain the relative grade inflation at various high schools? Also, they are repeat players, which further mitigates the information asymmetry.
- tracker1 7y agoThen they add offsets based on race and income disparity.