6 ms·
State of the art MRI machine costs $3 million up front. Would take 20 scans a week, every week, for 10 years to break even on that investment at $300 per scan.
by hammock 7y ago
State of the art MRI machine costs $3 million up front. Would take 20 scans a week, every week, for 10 years to break even on that investment at $300 per scan. Not counting physician & staff time or cost of capital.
- dillonmckay 7y agoFor reference, I recently went to an MRI ‘center’ and their business hours are 7:30am to 10pm 7 days a week. So, even charging $500 and booking every 30 minutes, payback on investment is much less than a year.
- cheschire 7y agoThat sounds so ridiculous compared to Germany, where grocery stores aren’t even open 7 days a week.
- Spooky23 7y agoMy insurer pays like $450. The hospitals seem to be doing ok, if anything there are way too many MRIs out there.
- masklinn 7y agoA few years back that was the "japanese problem": the price of MRI machines started falling but the act itself (whose price is set by policy / negotiations) hadn't been revised yet, so every clinic started getting one, which contributed to the price falling, and a price revision or two later the price was revised to ~$100, but the cheap MRIs and habit to use them remained. We're talking circa 2010, around the time of the obamacare debate in the US.
- Someone1234 7y agoOnly 20 scans a week? A scan takes 30-60 minutes. So even if they only work 8 hour days and assume an hour for lunch/flex that's 35 scans per 5 day week. If they use it on weekends at all or run it for more than eight hours, that's just gravy. I'm not sure where you got the 20 scans a week number.
- ChrisLomont 7y agoBecause scans are not booked wall to wall every hour of every day. Needs more likely follow a poisson distribution with ample waits in between uses. To try and pack it that densely, with the large variation in how people show up at the hospital, would cause bottlenecks and loss of service. 20 a week is a more common number for most places. Here's actual data [1] measured on site. The usage is indeed around 50%, so the 20 is a much better answer. [1] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/MRI-scanner-utilization-rate-over-the-3-week-data-collection-period-MRI-scanner-type-and_fig1_51852320 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/MRI-scanner-utilization-...
- DuskStar 7y ago40% utilization means that it was in use for 67 hours per week. I don't think an MRI takes three hours. (In the case of the study listed, the utilization figures might be out of ~35 hours, which would make things different - but they also exclude scans scheduled in advance)
- ChrisLomont 7y agoThe link states "As a result, in our study the maximum hours per week on each scanner was limited to 35 h for the Vision (no hours on Tuesdays), 39 h for the Harmony, 32 h for the Sonata (no hours on Wednesdays) and 38 h for the Avanto." Why guess 67 when you can look at the answer?
- DuskStar 7y agoBecause from my reading that's not the number of hours they used the machines, but the number of hours in which the machines were available to be used. And since they also state that their utilization figures only include emergency cases (and exclude scheduled scans) I don't consider it a particularly relevant source in the first place.
- ChrisLomont 7y ago
- raverbashing 7y agoYes but you don't do 20 scans a week, you do that per day
- fatnoah 7y agoLooks like you're pretty close: https://www.radiologybusiness.com/topics/business-intelligence/maximizing-mri-throughput-efficient-scheduling https://www.radiologybusiness.com/topics/business-intelligen... >Ultimately, UVI increased appointment slots to 407 a week, efficiency was boosted to about 82%, and it is averaging 433 examinations per week. That's for four machines.
- tptacek 7y agoIsn't 20 scans a day something like 15 hours of continuous, back-to-back scanning?
- lostlogin 7y agoSome scans are very fast. For a basic knee scan done well it’s 10-15 minutes of imaging time and lumbar spine scans are a couple of minutes longer. With 2 staff the changeover can be a minute of 3. With good scheduling the scans that are similar are booked back to back and equipment changes are minimal.
- DuskStar 7y agoAre you saying that you wouldn't have your multi-million dollar imager running as much as possible?
- tptacek 7y agoI'm saying that it seems like a most optimistic, best-case scenario, and not the average case.
- stevesimmons 7y agoWhen my partner needed an outpatient MRI, we got it done the next day by accepting the 11pm time slot. This was at a private hospital in Australia in 2006. We were super impressed by everything that department did to maximise utilisation. It was like a production line!
- 0x54D5 7y agoOut of all the things that the feds could be subsidizing. This one seems like a no brainer to me. Seriously we subsidized agriculture to avoid people starving. Why not MRI machines to avoid people dying from avoidable diseases? Instead of it being a luxury we could scan everyone once every 6 months. Who am I kidding? That actually requires a forward thinking government.
- benaadams 7y agoNHS isn't a for profit healthcare system; and they'll break even earlier on the early detection and diagnosis as since it covers you for life treating you early is less expensive then treating you later when the treatment costs would be higher. Considerations would be different if the MRI scanner was running as for profit; or you could switch coverage so the later costs would be borne by someone else.
- CWuestefeld 7y agotreating you early is less expensive then treating you later when the treatment costs would be higher. This is true retrospectively, for anyone who it turns out really has the disease. But studies show that prospectively (when you don't know if somebody actually has a given disease), the cost of preventative care - including follow-up tests and unnecessary treatments - exceeds the benefit that you outlined. EDIT: add quote to clarify what I'm responding to.
- hammock 7y agoWhich makes sense intuitively. You're trading away risk.
- mattkrause 7y agoThis is a little circular, in that we do the preventive care that we actually do is the sort that we think is effective. If it were obvious that these whole-body scans were cost effective, the NHS would have people lining up.
- lostlogin 7y ago10-20 scans per day is a full days work in MRI for an 8-9 hour day. I’m an MR radiographer.
- wpdev_63 7y agoWell if you are not including external costs, you can get a MRI machine at around $100k to $500 depending on your needs[0]. [0]:https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/IN-16CT-Hospital-Medical-equipment-16_60812954431.html?spm=a2700.7724838.2017115.41.3ae63774V7iQ8X https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/IN-16CT-Hospital-Medi...
- Konnstann 7y agoNot only that, but it's also an X-Ray and CT scanner. What a bargain! In all seriousness the product linked is a CT scanner, which are way less expensive in general.