4 ms·
Had a conversation recently about all that. People ask if the industry will wrap up and move from China. I ask them in response: where would they run away to
by baybal2 8y ago
Had a conversation recently about all that.
People ask if the industry will wrap up and move from China.
I ask them in response: where would they run away to? Vietnam?
Vietnam's entire light industry output is like of one Dongguan's district.
India has a lot of workforce, tons of it, but the entire light industry ecosystem has to be built from scratch, or brought along with you.
They can't run away.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIf negative pressure is sustained long enough, alternatives will be developed. How long has China held a dominant position in electronics assembly? Less than 20 years...and that would be generous. So things can change, definitely not overnight, but in a few years.
- zhongjiewu 8y agoI agree, if there is a region with the labor force and good policy for investment plus infra and a few other things. Vietnam is a close enough option, but other options are not abundant, so more than just a few years would be a plausible answer for me.
- baybal2 8y agoChina for long was a phenomenal combination of size, quality, and a price for workforce you can't find anywhere. Eastern Europe - mass higher education check, everything else no India - size yes, but nothing else, and there is "license raj" on top of that. One sweetener is the future domestic market appeal Vietnam - mini-China, good primary and vocational education check, size OK, industry, some leftovers from pre-privatisation era, check - pretty much same as China was in that regard. Pakistan... very cheap for sure, existing industry is nonexistent, (though Pakistan once had a backend FAB in late eighties!) and with Rupee hitting the bottom now, you can overlook how poor the logistics will be.
- the-rc 8y agoWell, before China, it was Japan. They dominated the 80s and a good chunk of the 90s. They still have a lead in markets such as cameras and are fairly competitive for technologies like Flash, which they actually invented. Samsung passed Toshiba a decade ago or so.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoDon’t forget Taiwan and Korea.
- the-rc 8y agoYeah, those have been displacing Japan along with China. I mentioned Samsung, but was mostly focusing on Japan as an example of a country whose star can and did dim, as a potential parallel for future China. It has taken longer than the few years the parent poster cited. It's also worth noting that China still has a long way to go when you look at particular markets such as semiconductors, where export controls have slowed them down.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoJapan was displaced by them significantly in the 90s, then China displaced everyone mid 2000-2010.
- dillonmckay 8y agoChinese entrepreneurs have been opening factories in Africa, actually. Relevant podcast: https://hbr.org/ideacast/2017/11/the-hardscrabble-business-of-chinese-manufacturing-in-africa.html https://hbr.org/ideacast/2017/11/the-hardscrabble-business-o...
- walkingolof 8y agoThey can’t run away, but, automation will make millions unemployed, that is almost a worse problem, none to blame !