5 ms·
I frequently think that the China is not actually the bad guy here. To me, tech transfer sounds like a good business practice. If I were going to spend billion
by amluto 8y ago
I frequently think that the China is not actually the bad guy here. To me, tech transfer sounds like a good business practice. If I were going to spend billions of dollars buying something, I would seriously consider demanding the IP and know-how to make more of it myself in the future. That way I would have some assurance that my purchase wouldn’t become unsupported and this worthless and that I won’t get price-gauged once I’m locked in. Cough, Oracle, cough. And having one’s major purchases translate to economic growth seems entirely reasonable.
It seems to me that people mostly have problems with tech transfer because it appears to be the government mandating it. Maybe the right solution is for everyone else to start doing tech transfer, too.
Tech transfer to a limited extent for drugs in particular sound like a pretty good idea.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoIt removes much of the incentive to build new tech if you have to turn it over and let someone steal it. I wouldn’t go into China with any proprietary tech as a foreigner.
- quotz 8y agoEU and US should form a committee or even a court regarding China IP theft and should pursue act on this with full fury
- mrep 7y agoOr we should just tell China that if huawei wants to sell their 5g tech over here, they need to force tech transfer the 5g tech over to us to do so.
- wil421 7y agoNo you can’t do that. The US and EU do not agree with this type of governance. It would set a bad precedence.
- quotz 7y agoWell, they should put tariffs and sanctions, sounds quite reasonable. EU and US is the only economic factor in the world after all. Whos gonna China sell to after that? Africa? Russia? :D
- z2 7y agoNot sure if that was sarcasm, but surely there's South America, South and Southeast Asia, and Australia. Though, obviously not all these places are on good terms with China either.
- Canada 7y agoForget politics, let's just see how well Huawei's Androids sell outside without Play infrastructure. My bet that people will only choose China's consumer software offerings is if they have absolutely no choice.
- mindslight 7y agoGiven that having the source code to a system is a necessary part of modern security practice, it would actually be a very good precedent. This assumption that it's alright for communications infrastructure to rely on trusting black boxes as long as those black boxes were designed by "allied" companies is madness. It doesn't particularly matter whether the gear is made by Qualcomm, Cisco, or Huawei - it's all suspect. The ultimate path forward is for mobile nodes to stop trusting the network, entirely. But that's a long row to hoe with regards to access authorization without leaking identifiers.
- wil421 7y agoWho is competent enough to review code? The governments? The crappy companies who the government would inevitably out source it to?
- mindslight 7y ago
- jimbob45 7y agoThere's a happy middle ground here. Patents expire after 20 years and that's a form of tech transfer. Maybe China's 1 year is too short and the US' 20 years is too long?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI don't understand the parallel being drawn. The US doesn't require you to file for a patent if you'd rather keep your technology secret.
- mistermann 7y ago> I wouldn’t go into China with any proprietary tech as a foreigner. How about if you didn't own the company outright but were only a senior executive, and your pay was directly linked to YOY profit increases, ignoring the risk of having that technology stolen and used against you 5-10 years down the road?
- ptah 7y agoyes it makes sense for countries to do this to avoid getting raided by foreign companies that have them over a barrel
- cameldrv 7y agoOf course technology transfer is good for the transferee. I would like a pony too. What the article is talking about is the forced joint-ventures. Do you want to open up a factory to make your product in China? In many industries, that is not legal. You have to find a Chinese partner to do a joint venture with. You can't just pick any company to do the joint venture with either. Practically it needs to be one that has politically connected owners, so that you don't have endless problems with permits and inspections. Even though the law states that technology transfer is not a condition of the JV, any politically connected JV partner is going to do what politicians ask of them, which is demand technology transfer. Therefore to do business in China, you're forced to transfer your tech. Meanwhile in the U.S. if you want to start a business, you fire up Stripe Atlas and you're done in ten minutes.
- tracer4201 7y agoWhy is forcing a joint venture a bad deal? Isn’t that choice? You don’t have to do business in China. Some of my friends that are the most angry about this topic, will on the other hand, defend American companies who pay low wages saying no one is forcing the workers to take those low paying jobs.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThe problem is that China insists they don't do forced technology transfers, and gets angry themselves when e.g. the US cuts off Huawei. If the government openly said "you can't do business in China if you don't want to give us your tech", I don't think anyone would get angry about that, but it would put them in a substantially worse market position than they currently enjoy.
- A2017U1 7y agoBut you can't do business in China without handing over your tech and partnering with locals. Needing that translated, stamped and signed on fancy paper is irrelevant. The message is loud and clear to anyone wanting to do business. Sovereign nations are allowed to make laws. They are under no obligation to make things easier for foreign multinationals.