9 ms·
China’s new ‘social credit system’
- lelima 8y agoDoes anyone have visit China and presence the social system in first person? I've heard that some people like it (Chinese co-workers), as they feel everyone acting better, but they don't live in China at the moment.
- Gys 8y agoI guess they do not realise what is coming? > '...one of the ways that people can improve their own social credit score is to report on the supposed misdeeds of others.'
- johnchristopher 8y agoNow, that's Orwellian. As described in the book. It's not the cameras, the government agents in the shadows or the spying technology... It's the end result of everyone spying on each other that made the world of 1984 so inescapable to Winston.
- arethuza 8y agoFrom what I remember of 1984 I don't think everyone was spied on all the time - it was mainly the Outer Party members (~13% of the population) who were scrutinized so closely as they were the source of potential threats to the Inner Party. Most of the characters in the book, apart from O'Brien, were Outer Party members.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoThe proles were relatively free to do whatever but they were too poor to do much of anything which is why they were left free. That said, the real life 1984 that we see slowly emerging in a piecemeal manner worldwide (faster in some places than in others) seems to mostly effect the lower and middle classes.
- chupasaurus 8y agoWell, everyone would have a telescreen in their pocket. China has a big surveillance playground in Xinjiang region (paywalled: https://www.wsj.com/articles/twelve-days-in-xinjiang-how-chinas-surveillance-state-overwhelms-daily-life-1513700355 https://www.wsj.com/articles/twelve-days-in-xinjiang-how-chi...), including random microphone recordings.
- cyphar 8y agoI would argue the key aspect of something being Orwellian is the redefinition of language such that arguments against the government's position cannot be made anymore. The idea of people being spied on by their neighbours in 1984 comes from real-world examples that Orwell was drawing on at the time (the Hitler Youth and the purges under Stalin). While it is very dystopian, I would classify it as being extreme totalitarianism and not Orwellian. Almost all recent totalitarian regimes I can think of had people informing on their neighbours.
- johnchristopher 8y agoYou are absolutely right. I can't edit to correct myself. The redefinition of language is more `Orwellian` than the all-spying. My point is that the spying in 1984 is most of the time seen as being done by Big Brother and its agents against the people but it was quite clear to me when reading it that it was more about everyone keeping an eye on everyone to report to BB, people were doing the watching and there was no escape (I seem to remember there's a line about how they don't know if the camera work but that doesn't matter because you can't prove it and people could be spied on by anyone anyway). Maybe it's time I pick it up again.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI would say that having people feel that it is acceptable to inform on their neighbors is a key element of a proper totalitarian society. This is why I routinely go off on people when they suggest calling the cops (or some other external authority) over petty differences. I don't want to see that kind of behavior left unchallenged let alone normalized.
- gerbilly 8y agoYou don't have to go to a book of fiction to get an example. Some Chinese are still old enough to remember the Cultural revolution. During this time people were interrogated for days by their peers in so called 'struggle meetings' in an attempt to change their supposed incorrect behaviour. Reporting someone as a bourgeois person could cause them to disappear.
- ImaCake 8y agoThe soviet satellite republics strike me as another real world 1984 dystopia. You can watch whole movies about the terrifyingly real East German Stasi.
- icebraining 8y agoIn the novel itself, Ingsoc is said to be similar to the CPSU. Orwell was drawing direct inspiration from the USSR under Stalin, as well as from other real world events.
- sgift 8y agoThe Securitate (The secret service of Romania) would be another equally terrifying example.
- sgift 8y agoPeople are easily manipulated. You only need the right incentives and tricks. As long as they are convinced or can be convinced that only bad people will be prosecuted (they are good people after all, right?) many people will welcome this. Reminder: Why do you need privacy if you have nothing to hide?
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>As long as they are convinced or can be convinced that only bad people will be prosecuted (they are good people after all, right?) many people will welcome this. Everyone is the hero of their own story.
- shaobo 8y agoDoes NY Post have a source/reference for this?
- clouddrover 8y agoHow does it affect their social credit score if they don't like it?
- lelima 8y agoThey opinion don't affect the credit score, they currently live abroad. How can we evaluate the system? number of people likes / dislikes? National level of happiness?
- rqs 8y agoHow long your since co-workers been out of China? I'm in China right now but I don't think that system has changed people's behavior that much. Plus, I think it's stupid to put a score on everybody's head ("Oh, you're below 10, we can't be friend" stupid). Based on my observation, people acting better usually because now they can and willing to, rather than been forced to. In our city for example, we used to have many jaywalkers. But that number dropped since the administration constructed better pedestrian crossings (underground tunnels, foot bridge etc). People still jaywalking when those infrastructure is unavailable.
- brighttank 8y agoI've been living in Beijing for over ten years. So far I haven't heard anyone complain about it. I know it's hard for Westerners to understand but most middle class Chinese are likely to see it as a good thing. The whole time I've been here I've read a constant stream of stories about fake food, fake medicine, fake milk-powder (which killed many babies), fake products, all types of fraud, etc. Add that to the general anti-social behaviors (such as spitting in the street) and you can see why many people recognize the need to "improve peoples' behavior" as Orwellian as that might sound to Western ears. Middle-class urban Chinese also distinguish themselves from rural Chinese which they see as kind-of backwards. That's why there's little appetite for democracy ... nobody thinks those people should be voting.
- yorwba 8y agoWhich specific system were your coworkers talking about? One of those run by private financial companies like Alipay or WeChat pay? One of the small-scale experiments run by various municipalities? The country-wide blacklist of people who did not comply with a court order to pay their debts? Something else? "The" social credit system looks very different from the monolithic apparatus of totalitarian control that people imagine it to be, so many different views can be simultaneously true.
- 0898 8y agoShouldn't it be "a distopian nightmare"? I'm sure 'an' is correct since that's the headline the NY Post wrote, but I'm just curious why.
- johnchristopher 8y agohttps://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/dystopian https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/dystopian > Relating to or denoting an imagined state or society where there is great suffering or injustice. > ‘the dystopian future of a society bereft of reason’ > ‘the utopian dream that became a dystopian nightmare’ No, I'd say the NY Post made a typo.
- m1sta_ 8y agoThe NY Post is a rag. Never feel the need to trust it. It is not the NY Times.
- pawelmurias 8y agoAre the rules of what costs you social credit score available?
- anvandare 8y agoProbably (although it makes more sense for them to be vague) but you shouldn't really care about the paper rules anyway, instead here are the real rules: Rule One: there are no rules. Rule Two: you must pretend Rule One does not exist. Instead pretend that there is a set of clear, objective, and just rules that apply to everyone equally and fairly; that it is possible to live without ever violating a rule; that no one is above the rules; that the rules aren't made up on a need-to basis by the powerful. Rule Three: arguing against the rules is against the rules.
- brighttank 8y agoYes, as well as how you earn it back. Eg, by donating blood and other kinds of "good deeds"
- bsaul 8y agoThe only positive side is that china’s regime is comiting suicide with this system. Seems like nothing was learned from communist russia. Intellectuals will flee, then top scientists, nobody will trade with them anymore, political opponents will be sent to camp, until finally it will all collapse under economical meltdown. My only concern is that civilians don’t pay a too high price in the process.
- fuzzbuzz 8y agoNorway has just landed some major deals for exporting fish to China. And nor the goverment or the majority of the population seem to bother what China is doing. Money talks, while human rights are censored.
- maxheadroom 8y ago>And nor the goverment or the majority of the population seem to bother what China is doing. I think this has a lot to do with the, "It doesn't effect me, so its not my problem," mentality that is still pretty prevalent in the globalised world. As the lyric goes, "Credulous, at best, your desire to believe in angels in the hearts of men."
- bsaul 8y agoI don’t think the general public is aware on what’s going on in china in details. They think it’s still pretty ok. But the direction the country is taking is pretty clear, and we soon should hear about nightmarish events more and more. Once one major western country starts taking a public stance and back it up with actions, the others will follow.
- Consultant32452 8y agoThe US has just barely started to make some noises with this mini trade war, which I believe will result in some tariffs remaining in place encouraging some of our manufacturing to move from China to central America.
- raxxorrax 8y ago
- duxup 8y agoWe've seen with Leica that China is willing to punish outside companies, they are willing to reach outside China and threaten Uighurs in Australia. I wonder if we see the social credit system exported / applied to those outside China under the guise of security or good behavior as a sort of pay to play deal.
- sneak 8y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Gong_practitioners_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Go...
- adinobro 8y agoChina currently doesn't have a "credit score" like most of the rest of the world. They also don't have a national police database so this is their attempt to do both at once. If you look at the information these two things seem to make roughly 90% off your score. Everything else is basically an experiment. Each district is doing it differently to find out what works the best and that will then be merged into what the country does. (The scientific process ... using data to inform policy) I visited Guangzhou in 2018 and was expecting it to be crazy since it has "the worst levels of noise pollution in the world" https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/mar/08/where-world-noisiest-city https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/mar/08/where-world-n... but it was almost crazy how quiet the city was. After the report come out they went around the whole city putting in traffic lights and fixing up all the intersections. There is still traffic but it is now more organised than any Chinese city I have been to. I ask the locals about it and they love the cameras, the order and the reduction in noise pollution. They freely admit that without the cameras most of the other Chinese people would just not obey the road rules so they are glad that the cameras are there. I image "social credit" will be similar. Lots of people here just don't pay bills because there is no credit history and there are no debt collectors (well not like in the west anyway). If you owe money to the wrong people then it is better to just disappear but for most companies, they have no power and they cannot do anything.
- icebraining 8y agoMuch, if not most, of the rest of the world doesn't have a credit score either.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoYou mean the US-style credit score, right? Because I can't imagine a country that has banks giving out loans without at least credit worthiness analyses that are essentially credit scores, but lazily computed. And lazily-computed credit score is still credit score. E.g. in Poland, we don't have "credit score", except that the bank will happily calculate it for itself whenever you ask for a loan, which means we have to keep our interactions with credits and debts in mind, the same way Americans do.
- rayiner 8y agoThe implementation is somewhat disconcerting, but I’m not sure the underlying policy isn’t a good idea. Culture matters. When I go to Tokyo and see people walking a couple of blocks to cross the street (there isn’t necessarily a cross walk on every block), or carrying their litter with them, versus what I see in say New York, I’m astounded. Similarly for the fact that nobody has ever asked me for a bribe in the US, versus what you might see in Bangladesh. These virtuous behaviors are a better way to live and make life better for everyone. China seems to realize that and be trying to change culture in a systematic way. It should probably be done more by carrot than stick, but there is a a kernel of a good idea in there. (I should note that Western countries had their own large-scale nearly universal social indoctrination and social credit systems—organized religion. Indoctrinating virtuous behaviors is a social function that needs to happen, the question is how do you do it. Note also that Chinese cities exist at a scale where the informal mechanisms for social credit break down. If you litter on my street, people will see you and they will notice. We regularly talk about neighbors who display antisocial behaviors. In New York? Outside maybe your condo board there are no such mechanisms.)
- chasd00 8y agoThere is no good idea inside constant surveillance.
- rayiner 8y agoOur successful societies originated in a state of constant (public) surveillance. When you do something in public in small town USA, people see you and that information ripples through the informal social networks. Historically, institutions like churches and schools facilitated exchange of that information. Those things breakdown when you have Chinese cities with millions of people, most of whom just moved there from somewhere else not that long ago. It’s not just a problem in China, either. If you drive to DC from Annapolis, you’ll see car after car violating the HOV restriction on US 50. Like 80% of vehicles in the HOV lane are single occupant. How do you solve that? Or people blocking the box in DC? Or people taking lefts from K Street during rush hour, when they are prohibited? There is a cost to all that—it slows things down for everyone and undermines deliberate traffic planning. I’d support, for example, cameras that automatically ticket violators.
- lawlessone 8y agoHow can they not see treating people this way will push them lower and lower?
- AFascistWorld 8y agoBelieve it or not, majority of the people actually like the CCP and the system, they just hate corrupt officials.
- PixyMisa 8y agoThat's the goal.
- mrobot 8y agoArticle reads like an advertisement for his probably shitty and poorly sourced book.
- Millennium 8y agoIn a society that does not put enough pressure on people to grow up and function, it is tempting to look at this as a possible solution. Coupling it to government power, though, is an outright horror. Any social credit system needs to be run independently, by society, not by the state (not least because of people's unfortunate tendency to remember that there is a difference).
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>In a society that does not put enough pressure on people to grow up and function, it is tempting to look at this as a possible solution Which is exactly why these kinds of developments should be worrying to the west. We're becoming less and less capable of having discussions and drawing hard lines when it comes to maturity and personal responsibility.
- archagon 8y ago> grow up and function What exactly do you mean by this?
- raxxorrax 8y agoYour comment suggest you are from the first world and that your parents did not put enough pressure on you. Otherwise your reflection upon your wealth wouldn't result in this tirade. You have been credited -13 social $$$. Authorities have been informed. You will also need to clear your room, because your social credit indicates that it is just a bit too nice for you.
- linyu0219 8y agothe media bias score of nypost base on adfontesmedia is only 20,selected Story. https://www.adfontesmedia.com/ https://www.adfontesmedia.com/ . https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/new-york-post/ https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/new-york-post/ https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-ratings https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-ratings As a chinese some mistakes in article 1.the phone bells the ban of trains or flights. all because the debt which courts can not enforce. all the methods only want you obey the judgements. 2.alipay the paypal of alibaba, has a system, like the ebay store rates, the score now can benefit the Second-hand trading. all these system is about economy. Nothing with political issue.
- linyu0219 8y agopolitical problem don't need score system.