5 ms·
This. The government artificially restricted supply, driving up demand, and then pulled the rug out from under taxi drivers by refusing to regulate ride hailing
by taneq 8y ago
This. The government artificially restricted supply, driving up demand, and then pulled the rug out from under taxi drivers by refusing to regulate ride hailing in a similar manner.
At least there are buybacks happening in some countries now to try and fix the whole mess: https://thewest.com.au/news/wa/government-to-introduce-taxi-plate-buyback-scheme-ng-b88433015z https://thewest.com.au/news/wa/government-to-introduce-taxi-...
- kjeetgill 8y agoTo temper this slightly, there are ways to artificially restrict supply without involving financial instruments. Just have a regular permitting/lisence system.
- Scoundreller 8y ago> I can only assume taxi companies must have lowered their prices to compete by now, but I'm not sure Doubtful. “Fares“ were strictly regulated by the regulators. With rideshare competition, taxis have become a lot less likely to moan that your ride is too short, or trying to charge extra just because there’s a ton of demand at that time.
- gruez 8y ago>then pulled the rug out from under taxi drivers by refusing to regulate ride hailing in a similar manner. Did the government make any express guarantees that for-hire vehicles would be regulated like taxis? If not, I'm not sure how this is any different from any other type of regulatory risk. >At least there are buybacks happening in some countries now to try and fix the whole mess That seems like the wrong solution to me. It's basically a scheme to socialize the losses.
- p1necone 8y agoFrom my perspective Uber are taxis, and it seems very strange that they weren't regulated as such from the beginning. (Regardless of whether the way local government regulated taxis was good or not)
- ars 8y agoBecause they were more like chauffeur services, which existed even before taxis. If those were not regulated, neither should Uber. Taxis are hailed from the street, everyone is isn't. Even before Uber you could call limo firms, that actually just used regular cars, and have them drive you, and those were not regulated either.
- p1necone 8y agoAh I see. In my country (New Zealand) the primary way of getting a taxi is to ring up the taxi company and get them to send you one.
- skinnymuch 8y agoYou can also do that and the system is awful across America. Not dependable at all. Customer service and support is usually awful too.
- p1necone 8y agoThe system seemed relatively alright when I used them before Uber was a thing. Using an app is easier than calling a taxi company though - although the main difference is just that Uber and co are much much cheaper than the taxis used to be. (I can only assume taxi companies must have lowered their prices to compete by now, but I'm not sure).
- taneq 8y agoI'll say this for Uber - the quality and price of our local taxi services have improved significantly since they came on the scene.
- taneq 8y agoFor-hire vehicles weren't able to practically compete with taxis until smartphones became capable of "virtual hailing". Uber changed the rules of the game by exploiting this loophole (which was clever of them, no argument there) but in practice they offer the same service that taxis offer but without the regulatory oversight. It's like the government mandating that electricians have an electrical license to take call-outs but the law mentions a telephone line so any old Joe can take call-outs if they use a mobile phone. The intent of the law is the important aspect. The letter of the law can and should be changed to match the intent.