5 ms·
>> At the same time I don't think expense will be a setback for autonomous vehicles. The reason being that if vehicles are fully autonomous there would be no re
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> At the same time I don't think expense will be a setback for autonomous vehicles. The reason being that if vehicles are fully autonomous there would be no reason for any individuals to own them. It would make more sense to have them operate like a taxi service. This is because without the costs of having to pay for a driver, it would be cheaper to just order an autonomous vehicle whenever you need to go anywhere than it would be own your own vehicle.
I have a better idea that we can implement right now without waiting for autonomous driving to become a real technological capability.
We could make big cars with many seats and have them driven around town by humans- just a single human could drive a single vehicle capable of transporting 50, maybe 100 others. We could have those big cars stopping at predetermined points around the city, so that people would know where to get on and off. And we could support that service by asking the users to pay a small fee upon boarding the big car. This would cover the costs of the driver, and the big car, and still leave some to pay for infrastructure, etc.
These big cars would probably have relatively restricted areas of operation, but, for the foreseeable future, so will autonomous cars (which have to be geofenced) and, like I say, we already have the technology for those big-cars-with-many-people-sitting-in-them-and-a-single-driver that I'm talking about.
And since a whole bunch of people would be carried by one or two of those big cars per day, instead of each riding a single (autonomous or not) car, we could drastically reduce the number of automobiles-per-person, and, therefore, the CO2 emissions, thereby reducing pollution and protecting the environment to boot.
So? Anyone want to invest on that?
- vivekd 8y agoGetting off topic here but actually I would love to invest in transit. And judging from the kickstarter in the link below so would many other people. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/crowd-funded-bus-takes-a-run-at-transit-starved-liberty-village-1.2771419 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/crowd-funded-bus-take... Unfortunately in my city (Toronto) and I would assume in many others it's illegal to run a private bus service. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/liberty-village-shuttle-bus-axed-1.2916451 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/liberty-village-shutt... So we're stuck with the government monopoly burdened with the enormous costs of public service transit unions with some transit union workers making six figures for things like being bus drivers or ticket collectors. Then you have bus routes that are not decided by numbers business purposes but by politics. Finally you have rude drivers and buses and trains that smell like urine. And you have buses and trains provided by special favored contractors that are technologically and mechanically less than what is available. My aging mother says it hurts her body to ride the bus because it doesn't provide a smooth comfortable ride. So if we want funding into buses and trains we can start by dealing with the political quagmire that has made buses and trains inefficient and unfriendly to users. But the familiar government cry of "just keep throwing more money at it until the problem is solved" is likely not the best solution.
- username223 8y ago> transit union workers making six figures for things like being bus drivers or ticket collectors You say that like it's a bad thing. We also have "tech workers making six figures for things like increasing engagement on social networks by 0.1%." What do you think about that? > Finally you have rude drivers and buses and trains that smell like urine. This would change right-quick if congestion pricing pushed wealthier people onto public transit.
- pferde 8y agoI have utmost respect for anyone who can safely and responsibly drive a huge vehicle full of people, day in and day out, on cramped city streets with precision down to centimeters on some complicated turns and crossroads. If anything, good bus drivers aren't paid enough.
- jryle70 8y agoDo you know what the disadvantages of your vehicles? they don't take riders to their house. They don't allow riders to bring along any oddity of luggage. They aren't available at the moment notice. They aren't personal escape room when one is needed. I'm sure you know what kind of vehicles providing such comfort. So take the high moral ground all you want, be snarky all you want, but the real world is a strange and messy place. Car has it place, along with bike, scooter, planes, trains. Until teleporter arrives.
- low_poly_shiba 8y agoPeople who rely on public transit adapt to public transit. For example, they become more savvy about how much stuff they own and what they carry around.
- chroma 8y agoI adapt by taking Uber/Lyft instead. I got fed up with crazy people threatening and attacking me on public transportation. Thankfully, I'm fortunate enough that I can afford to be driven around. I hope that in the future such a pleasant experience can be made available to everyone in the form of autonomous vehicles.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> I got fed up with crazy people threatening and attacking me on public transportation. As usual, this seems to be very different between EU and US citizens. I've been using public transport of all possible types (trains, boats, busses, trams...) in more than half a dozen EU countries since I was a wee bairn and I've never been threatened or attacked on any of them. Like, not even close. The absolutely worst thing that has ever happened to me on public transport is some guy puking his guts out on a London bus on a Saturday night. And that was just once. And it was more like "what an idiot" than "oh god I'm scared". Which tells me that this is nothing to do with public transportation, as a means of transport, but with - other issues, for example various social issues that are particular in the US. Or people are just exaggerating the misery of taking public transport in the US? I struggle to believe it's really that bad as you say, for instance. Public transport descriptions by US citizens always sound a bit like The Warriors, to me, and a bit unrealistic, to be honest.
- rorykoehler 8y agoBuses are great but cars are 2x as quick to any destination more than a few km away (at least in Singapore). I don't own a car fwiw.
- asdff 8y agoBuses really need to be grade separated from traffic, but most cities are reluctant to remove a lane out of a road to make it possible. I believe rio de janero has a huge BRT (bus rapid transit) network. Grade separated, and they are pretty much a subway with rubber wheels and it's waaay cheaper to build even an elevated roadway vs. a tunnel with rails that is more constrained with how sharp you can turn and what elevation changes your track needs to avoid. In Los Angeles, BRT busses are twice as long as well, all the more riders in one go.
- anticensor 8y agoYou would need to split subway-like buses and less frequent suburban buses. Suburban buses need to navigate streets.
- rorykoehler 8y agoI wish they also did this for bicycles and e mobility devices