6 ms·
Paul Graham: “Airbnb happened because its founders could not pay their rent”
- minimaxir 8y agoThe tweet is very justifiably getting criticized. > let’s discuss the “friends and family” round, shall we? > the whole entire funding round built into the startup narrative that is predicated on the idea that you might have friends/family with enough disposable income to write you checks to fund your startup. https://twitter.com/EricaJoy/status/1130135288896876549 https://twitter.com/EricaJoy/status/1130135288896876549 It's a bit disappointing seeing other VCs in the replies defend Graham's comment.
- adventured 8y agoTo accomplish almost anything on this planet you have to network with other people. That includes feeding yourself consistently day to day, holding a job and acquiring any amount of formal education. Speaking in strict terms, humans are nearly useless without other humans. What's the point of the criticism exactly, when typically even the most basic of accomplishments requires social networking between people? It makes perfect sense that one of the most valuable skills, and most valuable assets you can possess, is networking with other people. There are a lot of success examples of people that were not born into super valuable social networks. From Marc Andreessen to Jack Dorsey, from Jack Ma to Larry Ellison, from Robert Noyce to Jerry Sanders. You know how I got my first VC round ever? I built a prototype (wasn't great), I was entirely self-taught in all regards (not a single minute of formal education in my trade), and I emailed a prominent venture capitalist cold. It was built in a few months, on an old raggedy PC with a shitty monitor, using free software. I came from nowhere, poorville USA, with not a single connection to anyone in the tech industry. What I had, is something to demonstrate. The only critical, truly valuable components in all of that, is that I self-educated and I took the initiative to reach out and connect (it costs little other than the willingness to have doors shut in your face until one opens). The US happens to possess the world's greatest public library system. There are in fact few excuses. Email people, connect, start networking, contribute, read some books about how to do it from your nearby public library. How much do you want it? I wanted it pretty bad, it's a choice you make.
- mskvsk 8y agoYes, Airbnb founders are privileged, but the mob attacking Paul is missing the message. If you are underprivileged, well... tough luck, you're not gonna build a unicorn. However, you can build a $1000, $10000, or $100k startup. Also, people there are conflating the terms "rich" and "privileged." You can have everything Airbnb's founders have and still be poor. Paul should be more careful with wording, though.
- goto11 8y agoI would have thought it is the other way around. You don't need a privileged background to turn a $100k into a unicorn. This is a question of different factors. But a privileged background will make it a lot more likely you can get to to a $100k startup in the first place. Because you can take more risks, fail more, bootstrap longer, rely on friends and family etc. Almost every successful entrepreneur have multiple failed startups in the baggage. But you are already privileged if you are able to fail multiple times and still bounce back.
- mskvsk 8y agoYes, privileged background is an amplifier and higher starting point. But you don't need any money to make a startup today. Generally, you need a computer with internet access. Although, even a computer is optional as I know some founders who started with just a smartphone (they were building Instagram accounts). Having said that, there are some people on this planet who are truly underprivileged and can't afford not even a device with internet connection but the very idea that startups could be built by individuals. That's scary.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> But you don't need any money to make a startup today. Generally, you need a computer with internet access. And free time.
- mskvsk 8y agoAmong many other mandatory things, yes. But money is not one of them.
- wilg 8y agoTangent: Is Airbnb even something worth celebrating? Doesn't it suck up the housing stock and hurt lots of communities?
- philwelch 8y agoNot really. Airbnb dynamically allocates (on a nightly basis) the supply of bedrooms within a given community. If there were enough bedrooms, it wouldn't have as large of a net effect. Since there aren't enough bedrooms in many communities, Airbnb seems to "suck up the housing stock". Incidentally, having taken multiple business trips to SF (as well as traveling there for interviews), it's plainly obvious how Airbnb is so successful there. Hotels in SF are terrible.
- eigenvector 8y agoSome local governments seem to think that residents shouldn't be competing in the same market for bedrooms as business travelers (or travelers generally) that are willing to spend $200+ per night. Preventing direct competition between the long-term rental and hotel markets is supposed to prevent locals, who provide value to the economy in other ways (income taxes, participation in the employment market, etc.), from having to compete with the price-inelastic demand of short-term travelers. If an apartment can rent for $1000/month in the long-term market, or $200/night in the short-term market, it could provide higher value to its owner on Airbnb while being vacant 83% of the time. But the total value to the community is diminished. Creating so much rental supply that the nightly price of hotel rooms is effectively driven down to the cost of long-term rental (so that long-term renters aren't 'crowded out') would require a massive amount of excess supply. But who would willingly continue building such supply right as returns were falling off a cliff? Like any company, Airbnb should be subject to and comply with local laws.
- philwelch 8y ago> Creating so much rental supply that the nightly price of hotel rooms is effectively driven down to the cost of long-term rental (so that long-term renters aren't 'crowded out') would require a massive amount of excess supply. But who would willingly continue building such supply right as returns were falling off a cliff? Nightly rooms are always going to have a premium over long-term rentals. In a healthy market, this merely accounts for the increased risk and hassle of having a new guest every couple nights instead of having a single tenant for a year or more. It's not actually cost-effective to repurpose inventory unless you have an even-worse shortage in one market than you have in the other. Deliberately separating markets by fiat, incidentally, doesn't really work out, and other instances of this behavior (eg zoning) is another root cause of this problem.
- floatingatoll 8y agoAirBnB happened because the founders found a way to skim off short-term rental property taxes, labor taxes, and room taxes into their own pockets as revenue. If AirBnB property listings were taxed appropriately as short-term rentals in all jurisdictions, with time sheets filled in and paid out to each property operator, their business would have collapsed within a year. They are a very poor example of value creation, and I’m stunned that PG considers them a positive example of anything. Show me a business that creates value that didn’t already exist and praise that and I’ll root from the sidelines. Instead, PG chose a skimming racket.
- jdsully 8y agoThe founders found a way to utilize otherwise vacant housing. After they got big people started buying specifically to lease on AirBnB but that would have been considered crazy before they effectively changed the culture around this. It was this cultural change that created value.
- eigenvector 8y agoIt was considered crazy before because it's largely illegal, and there was no global online platform where you could anonymously advertise and take payment (with credit cards!) for an illegal service. Airbnb solved the trust problem inherent in providing or consuming an illegal service.
- new_realist 8y agoVacant housing existed because of a conscious choice by society to preserve the residential character of non-tourist districts. Tourists are generally well off, because travel is discretionary or paid for by big business. Now that these wealthy travellers are permitted to parachute in anywhere, rents rise and residents lives are made harder. Like your den? Too bad, you'll have to share it with strangers now in order to afford your house. AirBnB is a gift to rich out of towners.
- jdsully 8y agoJust because the value creation goes to the well off does not mean value wasn’t created.
- perfmode 8y ago> One thing I found interesting is Brian Chesky was in Uber's seed round in 2010. I tried doing the math to see how that was possible if he hadn't been rich (seems a stretch) pg: It merely says he was an early investor, not that he invested in 2010. > "First Round ultimately led Uber's $1.58 million seed round, with participation from more than 30 other investors, including Amazon's Jeff Bezos, Ashton Kutcher and Airbnb founder Brian Chesky " pg: Sure enough, you seem to be right, at least if this article is. By 2010 he may have had some money. I doubt he invested much though.
- perfmode 8y agohow did cheeky become an accredited investor by 2010?
- new_realist 8y agoYC specializes in exploiting poor entrepreneurs. They've taken the traditional VC model and turned it into a high volume sweatshop.
- Simulacra 8y agoBackground does count for something, and I can see the point about it being a safety net, but I think this is splitting hairs. Someone had a problem, and they came up with a solution, something we've been doing forever. No one is guaranteed an equal upbringing, an equal safety net, or wealth, but we can guarantee that everyone has a chance to chase what they want. Inequality, IMHO, will always exist. But so long as there's a chance to chase an idea, there's hope there will be equality that everyone will find equally just.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> but we can guarantee that everyone has a chance to chase what they want. Except some people are starting within arm's length of the rabbit and some people are not only starting the next state over, they're chained to a concrete block. "everyone has a chance" is bollocks when those chances range from "virtually certain" to "virtually certainly zero".
- ksec 7y agoI think Matthew Prince, Founder of CloudFlare has an interesting reply. >Oh Paul, you know better. I had to borrow money from my mom to pay my taxes when we were starting Cloudflare. But I certainly came from a relatively privileged background, and so did the AirBnB founders. It’s hard to take risks if you don’t have a safety net. #bereal And Pinboard's take on it. >This is a masterpiece of the tweeting arts. Two of the founders of AirBnB went to RISD (a prestigious American design school), while the third was a Harvard grad. The conceit that 'rich kid' refers to one's account balance, rather than social class, makes me drop my monocle https://mobile.twitter.com/Pinboard/status/1130238808140800000 https://mobile.twitter.com/Pinboard/status/11302388081408000...