17 ms·
Chicago successfully taxes streaming services
- gabea 8y agoWould we ever see legislation that would require companies to not increase the cost of digital goods after a tax is instituted? Alternatively, could we not just have a fixed tax contribution on goods each year rather than making it piecemeal per digital good sold? I find it weird to tax goods unless the existence of the tax is to change behavior. (not sure if that is the goal here?)
- Zak 8y agoThe article says it's a response to a reduction in sales tax collected, so it would seem the goal is to collect revenue. A prohibition on raising the price seems unlikely; that's not usually the case with other things that act like sales taxes.
- writepub 8y agoIt's always amusing that no one talks about more efficient ways to use revenues, than blindly increasing tax, when it comes to the government. Has ANY government service become any better, over time while taxes have constantly risen?
- cheerlessbog 8y agoThere are certainly jurisdictions that are arguably under taxed because they only have the funds to provide meager services. See: Kansas Experiment.
- moorhosj 8y agoAren’t lots more government services digitized now versus 20 years ago? Lots of forms and records you needed to be in-person to access are now available online. Many cities have open data programs where they make large data sets freely available via API or query. In Chicago, my local library and school have improve programming options over the past 10 years. Those are a few examples.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tomjen3 8y agoThe problem with that is that either a) you go under the margins and each sale is a loss, meaning that the company will offer no services at all; b) you stay under the margins, but not enough for the investors to keep investing (they expect higher profits elsewhere) and so the company now has no investors; c) you cut into the margin so much that it is not worth it for the company to continue developing new stuff. In the case of c they will most likely continue to develop new stuff, based on their revenues elsewhere, but at that point the high tax areas are leaching of other low tax areas where the company can afford to fund innovation. That assumes that you can find out when a company increase prices based on higher taxes, as opposed to anything else, which you cannot do. The only real solution is to tell the retirees that they are not getting the money they counted on; that is hardly unfair as I am sure nobody here expects there to be any retirement funds for them, except what they can save up.
- burlesona 8y agoThis stuff makes sense for cities, it’s just frustrating how much more difficult it makes it to operate a “mom and pop” software business. The complexity of potentially complying with hundreds of state and municipal governments - not where you are located but where online purchases originate - is a pretty significant deterrent to setting up a small side business. Imagine if every food truck had to pay taxes based not on where the truck is, but where the customers were from. On the other hand, this is an obvious opportunity for payment processors to automate. I’m surprised sales tax still isn’t built in to stripe, for example.
- reaperducer 8y agoIt was only recently added to SmugMug's processing. Having owned two businesses, I can say it's a lot more complicated than most people realize. Tax rates and reporting don't fit neatly into city, state, or even simple ZIP Code boundaries. Plus different products, even sold from the same food truck to use your example, can have different tax rates. The whole retail taxing system is a mess.
- nitrogen 8y agoThere are vendors that will calculate taxes for you, but the ones that do it right down to the address level charge a lot. Plus you are sending all of your customers' detailed purchase data to a third party.
- shittyadmin 8y agoYou don't reside there, you're not liable to abide by their laws. I run a small US company, I don't have to comply with GDPR for example. Same applies here. I don't see why any company would implement this, perhaps appeasing regulators at the federal level.
- boulos 8y agoI assume you mean well, but it’s not about your residence (or for businesses the place where they are incorporated) but rather where you do business. Just because I’m in California doesn’t mean I can do business in the EU without complying with their laws. Same goes for Chicago. You’re not required to do business there, but they can fine you for non-compliance if you are doing business. Note: all of this is in reference to “software companies” as the GP said, and doesn’t touch on “corporate nexus” and stuff like that.
- chrismeller 8y agoIt seems odd that this is referred to as the “Netflix” tax while most of the money has been collected from Eventbrite and Fandango, both of whom sell tickets to events physically happening in Chicago and both of whom would already be subject to a variety of other locality taxes as a result. Even Netflix charges sales tax (or VAT, such as in Europe) in locations that require it (based off your billing address), so I find it hard to see this kind of thing as anything more than greedy governments taxing something simply because they can and know it’s big money.
- reaperducer 8y agoIn Chicago's case, the tax is more about desperation than greed. But yes, greed is what got that city's government where it is today fiscally.
- dontbenebby 8y agoI thought the main reason states collect tax on Amazon purchases is because they have a presence in a state (distribution centers, warehouses, etc)? I'm confused how the legal thinking goes that a company not based in Chicago, offering services on the internet, can be taxed. (They don't even ship DVDs to most customers, whereas Amazon was shipping physical goods)
- reaperducer 8y agoIt's an entertainment tax. Netflix supplies entertainment to people in the city of Chicago, and so the city of Chicago taxes that entertainment. Same thing with concert tickets and other forms of entertainment.
- Mirioron 8y agoAnd if every city and town has their own tax that's different in some way? Then what? Or alternatively, could Netflix ban all residents of Chicago?
- boulos 8y agoYes, Netflix chooses to serve Chicagoans, and if they’d prefer not to, they can. There have been a few “make the customers angry, so they write to their representatives” attempts throughout history, but I doubt a 99 cent tax for Netflix is enough to risk it. As a related thing, look at Spotify vs Apple on the App Store. That 30% is material.
- Mirioron 8y agoBut I don't think this is actually possible in the EU in the long term. They want to do away with companies only serving digital services to some EU member states, but legislation still applies per country. What if the rest of the world decides that this stuff is great for taxation as well? Then you won't be dealing with the tax code of an American city, you'll be dealing with the tax code of a city in some small country.
- 8y ago
- Shivetya 8y agoChicago is in the hole for nearly thirty billion dollars. They have been floating the idea of a ten billion dollar bond with the debt structured in a way which lets current politicians escape the fallout from its payment and not having to raise property taxes. The state of Illinois is not well off either with debts estimated at the low of one hundred thirty billion to two hundred fifty billion. An Illinois proposal just to fix state pensions would result in a forty four percent property tax increase for thirty years. Chicago has a narrower group of people to draw from so besides tourist and sin taxes they have to go after any product consumed by residents of the city and that includes digital. Why is this all happening, because there is a well hidden largess in government employee payroll and worse in their pension system. Illinois alone is estimated to have over twenty three thousand retirees pulling down one hundred thousand dollars a year or more. A lot of this is from the higher end positions in city and county governments but you can find police and fire there too. People complain about the disparity in corporate executive level pay to employee should also take a look at the disparity between the same in state and city governments let alone the disparity in retirement to even every day workers in the state. A 100k retirement not counting full benefits is equivalent to nearly forty eight dollars an hour. So expect more digital taxes in your future. PS: the Chicago debt is only for pensions, they are down tens of billions more in deferred maintenance and similar debts.
- gfodor 8y agoPulling or cutting the pensions of retired public service workers (many of whom who risked their lives to protect the public) would, beyond the ethical questions, eliminate the credibility of the city's promises to those who sign up for such jobs and hence would likely greatly reduce the quantity and quality of recruits.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 8y agoThe current proposed solution is just to cut back benefits on new job offers - though obviously if they cut back too much no one decent will want to work there.
- 8y ago
- 60654 8y agoFor what it's worth - the title is a bit misleading. The tax began its life as an extension/adaptation of an existing 9% "amusement tax" on patrons of amusements (movie theaters, bowling alleys, etc) in the city. But until 2015 it only included physical businesses, not any of the new online replacements. The definition is now expanded to include online games, streaming movies, movie tickets sold online, etc. Also, this has been in effect for a while now (e.g. my Netflix bill went up by $0.99 a year ago) and all the various online businesses have already implemented it. Not sure why the article is bubbling up now, just as the new mayor is about to take office. :) For more history see https://www.forbes.com/sites/kellyphillipserb/2018/05/29/chicagos-cloud-tax-on-streaming-services-like-netflix-survives-legal-challenge/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kellyphillipserb/2018/05/29/chi...
- writepub 8y agoBasic question: what is the legal basis for cities to tax something? I understand physical goods sold within a city benefited from infrastructure and security the city government offers, and agree to a tax on them. But digital goods and services? The city already taxes internet connectivity, property tax, ... Taxing digital goods further is just double taxation, with no benefit provided in return by the city to the consumer, or producer of digital goods
- lr4444lr 8y agoThey derive their right to tax as recognized entities from the states wherein they are incorporated. There is no limit to what they can tax according to their charter, as long as no higher jurisdiction forbids it.
- writepub 8y agoThat's way too broad and not how it ought to be. THIS is why you see rich cities like San Francisco and Chicago preaching ever higher taxes, while simultaneously providing worse services for it's citizens. There's a feedback loop missing where there are actual consequences to the city council when quality of service isn't delivered, but instead, city politicians indulge in emotionally appealing demagoguery, further increase taxes, line their pockets and continue to not deliver
- sjy 8y agoSo in other words, voters continually vote against their own long-term interests? I don't see how this is going to be solved by getting the democratically-elected state legislature to pass laws restricting the cities' taxing powers.
- macspoofing 8y agoHate it. There's nothing wrong with taxes, but this kind of tax is onerous. It adds a shit ton of overhead if you have to maintain tax rates for every municipality in US, or the world. This is where I wish government would figure something else out. Have one state or (preferably) federal agency levy one tax, and then figure out how to disperse the collected income to municipalities - instead of each municipality creating its own tax for specific online goods. It just sucks. And by the way, big companies will figure it out because they have entire departments to deal with garbage like that. It's the small companies that suffer from this bureaucracy.
- sjy 8y agoIt's not hard to "figure something else out"; this problem became a political issue in Australia in the 1980s and was finally solved with a federal goods and services tax in 2000, the proceeds of which are distributed back to the states by an apolitical bureaucracy. There are no more local or state sales taxes. I am sure other countries have found similar solutions. The difficulty is overcoming the political and constitutional barriers to further consolidating federal power in the United States.
- frosted-flakes 8y agoYep. Canada has the federal General Sales Tax (5%), and most provinces have a separate Provincial Sales Tax (varying rates). Some provinces have combined these into the Harmonized Sales Tax, which is collected by the Canada Revenue Agency and the provincial portion distributed according to their respective rates. Other levels of government are not permitted to charge sales tax, or even income tax. Most cities' primary sources of income are property tax and development fees.
- techsin101 8y agoAll taxes can be consolidated into one tax, Wealth tax! which can directly account for everything. i.e. Live in NYC vs suburbs. Got 5 kids vs single. No income, sales, federal, city, county, state, capital, property, SS... list goes on. If you're rich you pay more if you're not you don't. How do you know how rich someone is? Total wealth. Federal government should ban any other taxes that state would want to implement
- whack 8y agoInstead of trying to tax purely digital activities, why not just raise the income/property taxes on the people who live or work in your city? This would be a lot less regressive, and would prevent people from getting around it just by changing their credit card billing address. Not to mention the beauracratic nightmare of requiring SaaS companies to keep track of every customer's physical address and local tax regulations.
- SilasX 8y agoBecause raising progressive taxes that are already high make it likely you’ll trigger a death spiral where high earners flee, raising the taxes you need to levy on the rest, etc.
- malandrew 8y agoYup. I would argue that that death spiral is a feature not a bug. Governments will do every thing they can to hide the extent of their taxation by nickel and diming its citizens, testing the limits of how much can be raised before people flee. If people could see the some total of the various taxes they pay, they'd be shocked. I'd love it if Stripe or other payment processors started reporting taxes to credit card companies so we could see the total sales and other taxes we paid across all transactions on top of our income taxes.
- Eridrus 8y agoBecause it's easier politically to implement regressive taxes. Property owners in particular are politically powerful and sympathetic. They're also very motivated because the tax increases would be large and these folks are highly leveraged in their investment. So we get things like Prop 13 in CA, or property tax increase caps in NY.
- OrgNet 8y agojust make Netflix (and all video streaming services) illegal and force them to distribute their content through the cable network (a bit like it is illegal to create city fiber networks) /s
- mindslight 8y agoMaybe instead of putting on a show in court, Netflix et al should simply stop asking people for their physical addresses? I mean, that is the underlying vulnerability that will allow this push to succeed. We were so excited for the promise of the Internet to overturn all this legacy bullshit. Then the legacy bullshitters got here, built a bunch of proprietary services on top of HTTP, marketed them as progress, and are slowly reimplementing the status quo! The Internet option, piracy, has been here the whole time. It's just "inconvenient" people say, as they repeatedly complain about new inconveniences caused by centralized services. In reality, it's simply the poverty mindset - a little bit of self-actualizing work today would pay off tenfold down the road. I look forward to the next phase of storage getting cheap enough, along with streaming services fragmenting themselves, that it becomes trendy to trade USB keys with friends.
- bscphil 8y ago>Maybe instead of putting on a show in court, Netflix et al should simply stop asking people for their physical addresses? I mean, that is the underlying vulnerability that will allow this push to succeed. That's an interesting point. There are internet services that don't require an address to pay for something. What are their legal obligations, if any, with respect to local taxes? I assume quite a few local laws don't explicitly make this a loophole, so does that mean anyone doing business online has the legal obligation to collect address information? That would be an odd situation, and it doesn't seem to be the one we're in. It seems like the situation on the ground is that in reality only companies big enough to attract attention are at risk from this. My understanding of the legal situation is that the federal government in the United States provides the legal basis for ensuring that a business in one state or city abides by the laws of another state or city when it sells to its residents. But they seem uninterested in actually enforcing this. It's interesting to think about what would happen to companies of various sizes should they refuse to implement this tax. Small / medium size companies? Probably nothing. In fact it's unlikely that many of them will implement it. Suppose Netflix refuses; it now becomes illegal for Chicago residents to purchase Netflix subscriptions (unless they have some mechanism for the citizens to pay the taxes themselves, as some states do; this usually doesn't happen though). But Netflix can say "no problem", we just make web servers available over the Internet, we don't check whether someone's logging in from Chicago. What does Chicago do? They either ban the Netflix domain at the local internet level, or (more likely) they get the Federal government involved and have fines put in place to penalize Netflix for not paying taxes to Chicago. I'm not a lawyer though, and it would be interesting to get one's point of view of one here since questions about jurisdiction come up here all the time, e.g. whether US companies have to comply with EU laws.
- williesleg 8y agoI'm sure they'll use it to fix the roads and bridges. Just like in NY. Shot to hell.
- tomohawk 8y agoI love Chicago, but its basically bankrupt. They can raise taxes all they want, but they won't be able to raise enough to cover the problems they've created.
- morpheuskafka 8y agoSales tax should be earned by a state, as a way to finance the services they provide to businesses that sell products within their state. I say earned, because if it's the tax is not worth the benefits, new businesses will locate elsewhere. It's reasonable that business pay for the emergency services, roads, infrastructure, etc. that they use. Streaming service sales do not in any way increase the costs faces by a locality, so they shouldn't be taxing it. If Chicago wants to tax companies like Netflix they should convince them to locate there.
- tzs 8y agoSo how does a business actually deal with collecting and remitting this? Is it a special case they have to deal with separately from sales taxes, or is it treated like a sales tax? If it is a sales tax, do the sales tax service companies like Avalara and TaxCloud and Savos handle it for you as long as you set the right tax code [1] for the item? [1] Sales taxes often vary depending on the type of good. E.g., some states might charge a different rate for food ingredients than they do for prepared food, or for food sold through a vending machine. The tax service companies assign a code to each category of goods that might have a different tax rate so that when you ask them to computer tax on an order you can supply the appropriate codes for each line item so they can compute the right tax.
- nullwasamistake 8y agoChicago is a financial disaster and it's dragging Illinois into the fire. The situation is worse than detriot before it's bankrupcy. It's so bad that illinois is the only state in the union with a negative population growth. And, doubly, the only state to have that honor several years in a row. The debt is unsustainable and they tax everything. Just a few years ago they started taxing soda cans, and hybrids since "they don't pay as much gas tax". They may have successfully taxed streaming but it's just another example of how incredibly desperate they are. Illinois is drowning under pension promises from their massively bloated government. Enough that every Illinois citizen owes something like $20,000 to the state pension systems. They're squeezing money from stones
- drewbug01 8y ago> Chicago is a financial disaster and it's dragging Illinois into the fire. Cook county (Chicago) and the 5 suburban counties contribute more revenue to the state coffers than the entire rest of the state combined. The rest of the state receives a higher share of that revenue than Chicago and its suburbs (ie - they get more than they put in). [1] > The situation is worse than detriot before it's bankrupcy. Highly subjective, but having personally lived in the Detroit area before its bankruptcy - and currently living in Chicago now - I disagree. > It's so bad that illinois is the only state in the union with a negative population growth. Not so. Multiple states have experienced negative population growth year over year; and multiple states had experienced it multiple years in a row. [2][3][4][5] Your comment is demonstrably, factually incorrect. Please support your opinions with facts, or label them as your own opinions. 1. https://opensiuc.lib.siu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1059&context=ppi_papers https://opensiuc.lib.siu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=105... 2. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1R7AN4o7m3coGcnWSJsKdhbLwUI1qUwYyVB4r5haKJyw/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1R7AN4o7m3coGcnWSJsKd... 3. https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2018/comm/population-change-2010-2018.html https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2018/comm/popu... 4. https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2018/comm/population-change-2017-2018.html https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2018/comm/popu... 5. https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/popest/2010s-national-total.html https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/popest/2...
- grayed-down 8y agoSuccessfully taxes streaming services? Shiiit, there's no such thing as successful taxation in Chicago. The city and it's crook county are corpses.
- techsin101 8y agoAgain only tax that should exist is wealth tax. Otherwise you can create as many taxes out of thin air as many words one can think. This complexity has real cost to entrepreneurship and thus GDP. Simple progressive ONE wealth tax can account for all matters indirectly. Funny for country founded because of taxes to have dozens on dozens of taxes, an entertainment tax? Really? If you live in SF and make 90k you're taxed the same if you made same amount in North Dakota somewhere. Make sense??? One is touching upper class status wise and other is one less paycheck away from being homeless. Right now we have income, capital, sales, bunch of business taxes, ... Each state City county has its own rate. Whenever it comes to taxes we seem to accept everything, it's taboo subject to talk negatively about any aspect of it despite there being real inefficiencies and better alternatives