8 ms·
Whats worse is they could all pull it off if they invest in existing Distros and hire people to build out the main infrastructure they need. If they rely on leg
by giancarlostoro 8y ago
Whats worse is they could all pull it off if they invest in existing Distros and hire people to build out the main infrastructure they need. If they rely on legacy Windowd OS' the licenses for new OS' wont matter. They need secure systems to avoid being hacked by external malicious state actors.
I would love to see some countries adopting Linux for government systems and funding research and development e.g. maybe fund Libre Office or the KDE one more and then build out other tools to be cross platform.
- 1f60c 8y agoThe French police uses a custom distro based on Ubuntu 16.04: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GendBuntu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GendBuntu
- jeroenhd 8y agoWhy are they using a custom distro? Is it just different graphics or do they have changes significant enough that a customised Ubuntu installer wouldn't suffice?
- notatoad 8y agowhat's the difference between a custom distro and a customized installer?
- Mikeb85 8y agoLikely it's simply Ubuntu + some custom repos + different graphics (because why not).
- kakwa_ 8y agoThey have some customized parts. For example, IIRC, they use a smart card to authenticate on their workstations, and also on their web applications. For that you need to customize a bit (better out of the box support for pkcs11 devices, integrate the Certificate Authorities needed, drivers). There are a few contributions to open source projects: A few years back, they were contributing to a fork of Thunderbird called Trustedbird for example. There are also a few individual contributors inside the Gendarmerie, for example Xavier Guimard creator and one of the current developers of LemonLdap (SSO portal). Also just as a side note, this distribution is used by the Gendarmerie, which is not exactly the national Police. In France you have both a Police Nationale and the Gendarmerie National. The Gendarmerie is military personel (the Police is civilian). I'm guessing national sovereignty plays a small role in that (VS using MS Windows, which is completely controlled by a US company, bounded to the US government).
- lozenge 8y agoWhen you run Windows you can use GPO to override loads and loads of behaviours, and WSUS to customise which updates get picked up by the computers. When you run Linux you do it by creating custom packages and changing the package manager to point to a different server, at which point you have created a "custom distro".
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago> Whats worse is they could all pull it off if they invest in existing Distros and hire people to build out the main infrastructure they need I don't know about that, I've seen what kinds of systems the existing distros build and I'm not impressed. Which isn't to say that Microsoft would definitely better, seeing as they are doing their best to become a Linux distro themselves while embracing all the bad behaviors that entails, but your statement certainly isn't a given.
- justwalt 8y ago> while embracing all the bad behaviors that entails What do you mean by this?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoIncreasing user hostility (see: forced updates "for your own good"), poorer quality software released more often, no QA, ridiculously convoluted dependency management...
- stefco_ 8y agoWhat distro are you using that has these issues? My Debian server has been running solidly for years without crashing or (automatically) updating. I've also never had any problems with QA or package management; everything installed with the system package manager has always run, installed, and updated smoothly. I'm not a linux expert, but what you described are all issues I associate exclusively with Windows and, to a lesser extent, recent MacOS, both of which I also use frequently.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoA server is generally a single purpose device, and the server stuff in Linux is pretty mature because people make money off of it. Run Linux on a Desktop and it's a whole different story. Shit breaks all the time, the package dependency spaghetti is insane, no one seems to test anything (or they don't listen to the people who do), etc.
- rileyphone 8y agoFunnily enough North Korea runs their own Linux distro, Red Star OS
- freeflight 8y agoFor anybody interested in a more detailed look on Red Star OS, check out this CCC talk [0] [0] https://youtu.be/8LGDM9exlZw https://youtu.be/8LGDM9exlZw
- Hydraulix989 8y agoMy fiancee who is from South Korea thinks very highly of the North Korean engineers' skills. Even under hunger and adverse conditions, they can produce their own Linux distribution and nuclear weapons program.
- acct1771 8y agoIt's not funny at all, IMO, it adds a unique identifier to each file created on the OS for tracking dissidents. Technically interesting, though.
- ethbro 8y ago"... and hire people to build out the main infrastructure they need." There's a reason Microsoft was successful for years: they built turn-key solutions, and added new turn-key features their customers requested. Switching from that sort of IT to a linux-based, 'we need a system architect' model doesn't happen overnight. There's organization shift, cultural shift, firing unneeded people who won't retrain, retraining people who are worth it, and hiring talent to fill gaps. Not to mention that talent's more expensive and less easily certified (e.g. all the official MS rubber stamp programs). Not impossible, but it's a LOT of work. With dubious chances of success.
- teh_klev 8y agoBasically Total Cost of Ownership (TCO). This is something people forget about. OS and app licenses are likely a drop in the ocean compared to the operating costs of supporting your infrastructure (regardless of whether it runs on Windows or Linux). [edit: TOC -> TCO]
- ethbro 8y agoTOC seems to conveniently leave out risk as a factor too. At least at the sales level. And yet the amount of failed systems migrations I've seen... If I have a 50% chance to cut my IT budget by 15%, if I remake my org, is it worth it?
- teh_klev 8y agoI've seen some spectacular cockups over the years and eye watering sums of money burned because no-one factored in risk properly. And they more often than not happen on government projects, and usually some big name consultancy is heavily involved - Capita, PwC et-al.
- ethbro 8y agoHaving worked the consultant gig for a bit, we never talked about risk. Honestly, because most customers sponsoring projects were morons. If you told them there was a 25% chance of failure, they'd go with someone else who claimed a 0% chance of failure. I finally decided most of this was just sponsors covering their ass. If they initiated a project with risk and it failed, that reflected on them. If they initiated a project and the consultants claimed (winkwinknudgenudge) there's no risk, then if it failed those lying consultants were the only ones to blame.