3 ms·
Most of those already have known downsides from initial early adopter programs. Dams = disrupted fisheries, solar = rare earth mining pollution, wind = dead mi
by nostrademons 8y ago
Most of those already have known downsides from initial early adopter programs. Dams = disrupted fisheries, solar = rare earth mining pollution, wind = dead migratory birds, UBI = lazyness, universal healthcare = long waiting times, self-driving cars = nobody to blame when they crash, electric vehicles = battery disposal.
It's like how we knew that the Internet obsoletes privacy long before Facebook came out, and have known that burning fossil fuels causes global warming for at least 30-40 years, and knew that there was shit in the meat since The Jungle came out in 1906, and knew that heavy industry causes pollution for about 150 years. We didn't care because the benefits to us were greater than the future drawbacks. As time goes on, we take the benefits for granted, but the drawbacks loom ever larger.
- rapind 8y agoWhich early adopter program for UBI illustrated laziness? I'm actually opposed to UBI because I think everything is relative and it's really just upping the baseline, but from everything I've read it hasn't produced laziness in practice.
- nostrademons 8y agoThere were experiments done in the U.S. in the late 60s and early 70s that showed a moderate (17% for women, 7% for men) reduction in work areas: http://www.bostonfed.org/economic/conf/conf30/conf30a.pdf http://www.bostonfed.org/economic/conf/conf30/conf30a.pdf It should also be noted that the same studies showed general increases in health (particularly mental health) and in education, so this is not an unambiguous loss. My point is that usually when you fix one metric, you introduce losses in other metrics. There's no free lunch (and if there were, people wouldn't work as hard to feed themselves).
- pjc50 8y agoImproved mental health while doing less work should not be described as laziness! Individual have a sustainable workrate, and can exceed that for short or medium term periods, but at the cost of long term health. Calling "not exceeding your long term sustainable rate" "lazy" gives you something like the Japanese salaryman culture.
- novok 8y agoI think the greatest danger to a UBI program is something like easy student loans made tuition more expensive. It will just make the basics more expensive and you are back to square one. You would need to break the regulatory capture that artificially make housing & healthcare expensive before you can implement a UBI program successfully.
- nostrademons 8y agoYeah, I think inflation's the biggest risk. It hasn't shown up in any studies so far because they've been too small. If 1000 people have an extra $2k/month it doesn't measurably affect prices; if 100,000 people have an extra $2k/month suddenly everything becomes more expensive. Ultimately the fix for everything is more supply. Build more houses and the price of housing comes down. Train more doctors (or nurse practitioners) and the price of health care comes down. Both of these industries have strong institutionalized cartels, though.
- HillaryBriss 8y ago> Ultimately the fix for everything is more supply. I always thought this was the biggest problem Obamacare (well intentioned though it is) left unaddressed. It looks like the ACA lacks the reforms that would allow supply to grow to meet demand.
- nradov 8y agoYes the bottleneck in producing more licensed physicians is currently the number of open residency slots in teaching hospitals. We need more funding for those. Every year some students graduate from medical school but are unable to actually practice medicine because they fail to get matched to a residency program.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoyes. also, though globalization is a two-edged sword, in this case it might have really helped the consumer with something the consumer really needs. i mean, the ACA might have additionally: * made it mandatory for US insurers to reimburse for care given by selected medical providers operating in selected foreign countries * allowed nurse practitioners to operate in all 50 states * eliminated barriers that, in effect, prevent doctors from foreign medical schools from entering the US and obtain a medical license * allowed US patients to order pharmaceuticals from Canada or other countries * allowed more pharmaceuticals which are already approved in foreign countries to be used in the US without additional FDA approval these sound like desperate measures, but many many US patients are actually quite desperate
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoSome of your examples are unsupported by research. E.g. Uuniversal healthcare wait times: https://theconversation.com/wind-farms-are-hardly-the-bird-slayers-theyre-made-out-to-be-heres-why-79567 https://theconversation.com/wind-farms-are-hardly-the-bird-s... Wind bird strikes: https://theconversation.com/wind-farms-are-hardly-the-bird-slayers-theyre-made-out-to-be-heres-why-79567 https://theconversation.com/wind-farms-are-hardly-the-bird-s... And of course UBI = laziness is a moral judgement, not a rational argument about how humans should spend their time in a highly automated planetary economy. If you research the source material for these points, the rhetorical slants are obvious. The first is to encourage emotive responses ("bird strikes are bad and windmills cause them") while taking them out of context ("windmills kill far fewer birds and cause less migratory change than many other human activities"). The second is to exclude important contextual information and cherry pick figures to make a point. E.g. Canada's public health care system has long waiting times - which are clearly bad. But it's misleading to compare them directly with the shorter median waiting times in the US - because that excludes the >500,000 families bankrupted by the health system in the US every year for whom the waiting times for future treatment are effectively infinite. Decades of these kinds of distortions have made informed public debate very difficult. Building up a contextual and robust picture of the trade-offs of any activity takes a while, and the picture is only useful if it compares like for like across as many dimensions for as many competing possibilities as possible. That rarely happens in public debate - and it should.
- nostrademons 8y agoOne of my points is that you can't separate the emotive response from the consequences of new developments. There's a cognitive bias that humans have (novelty bias) where when there's a great new technology or social change, we usually only see the positives, unless you're zooming in very closely and examining the development with a specifically critical lens. As the technology becomes more familiar, we become blind to its benefits and just take them for granted. Instead, our emotions zoom in on all the downsides - those little details that are insignificant in the bigger picture, but which become very annoying when everybody's using the technology every day. This is why life continues to suck despite 400 years of solid technological progress, even though nobody realistically wants to go back to the Middle Ages.