7 ms·
This works out well for Japan. Why wouldn't it for the US? The way I see it, only those highly qualified shall apply. If an american can do the job, then an am
by snvzz 8y ago
This works out well for Japan. Why wouldn't it for the US?
The way I see it, only those highly qualified shall apply. If an american can do the job, then an american should do it.
- craftyguy 8y agoI wonder if trump's mail order wife would have had enough merits in this system?
- briandear 8y agoHN Guidelines: “Be kind. Don't be snarky... Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It destroys intellectual curiosity, which the site exists for.” If you want to make a comment about the First Lady, you could have said “I wonder if Mrs. Trump would have qualified under the proposed standards.” That could have then led to a discussion of how visas had been allocated in the past. Calling her a mail order bride adds nothing to the conversation and instead just serves as a cheap shot based on a dislike of Trump rather than a debate on the policies.
- craftyguy 8y ago>Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It destroys intellectual curiosity, which the site exists for.” Half the posts on 'hacker' 'news' are for inciting political/ideological battles, including this article. It has nothing to do with the guidelines for what types of articles should be posted on 'hacker' 'news'. Or did you selectively choose to ignore those?
- dang 8y agoThat's not even close to true, though I can understand why it might feel true.
- legohead 8y agoIt sounded fine up until this line: > he proposed moving away from the current system that favours applicants with family ties to the US If a citizen is in the country and they want to bring their family over, that should be their right.
- Supermancho 8y ago> If a citizen is in the country and they want to bring their family over, that should be their right. I do not agree. What constitutes family is arbitrary, but there are generally allowances (in most countries) for spouses and children who are still minors (eg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_nationality_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_nationality_law). The allowances for spouses and children are not ubiquitous around the world. The Clinton administration had a bit of trouble figuring out custom rules to what constituted "family". How many generations? What about anyone married to them and then from there on. It's legally logical to assume there's no connection between my French citizenship (received as an adult) and my brother (who is an adult).
- klipt 8y agoUS immigration law already has strict quotas for siblings. The backlog for sibling greencards stretches back decades. So sponsorship is possible in theory, but little used in practice. The main sponsorship that's currently easier in the US than other countries is parents of citizens, who are considered immediate relatives and are not subject to quota.
- briandear 8y agoExcept Europe, Canada, the UK, Australia, China and almost every other country in the world would disagree. Immediate family is one thing, however US immigration family preference means that a illiterate cousin of an applicant has priority over a highly accomplished person with no family in the US. Spouse and minor children, certainly, and Trump’s proposal is in line with Europe and Canada in the regard. In fact, his proposal is more like Canadian immigration policy. Honestly, Trump could propose single payer healthcare or universal pre-K and the anti-Trump crowd would oppose it. A helpful exercise for people of both parties is to ask if you would agree with a given policy if “your guy” had said it.
- KirinDave 8y agoExcept Japan's undergoing major immigration reform over the last decade precisely because it doesn't work well. Not that immigration to Japan even if you're rich and well positioned is such a good deal.
- mc32 8y agoThey have other issues like very low birth rates. Ours is low, but not that low.
- KirinDave 8y agoWe have better birthrates because we oppress more of our native population. Uneducated and/or poor people tend to have more kids because this is a rational strategy to grow a supportive family unit
- jedberg 8y agoI used to agree with you. I thought merit based was the best system. Until it was pointed out to me that it's a very biased system towards wealthy people from wealthy countries. Merit based systems are usually based on advanced college degrees. Who are the kinds of people that get advanced college degrees? Well first you have to have had access to good primary education, and then good secondary education, and then a good undergraduate education. People from poor countries tend not to have those things, even the smart people from poor countries.
- mc32 8y agoOur immigration system is to benefit Americans (a better economy is good for Americans). We don’t have the responsibility to make things better in other countries. It’s their government’s responsibility, not ours. Now, if they want to become the fifty first state in the union and we go thru the process and bring them in, ok.
- ggggtez 8y agoIf you take the step to agree that this would bias towards wealthy people, I'd take the next step and argue there isn't really evidence that letting only wealthy people become citizens actually makes the US a better place. "Give me your cold, your tired, your huddled masses yearning to be free". Being an American isn't just about capitalism.
- mc32 8y agoThat’s a private poem, not a government policy, never was. We have a responsibility towards fellow Americans. If the Chinese have a bias against people from their countryside, it’s not up to us to fix their mess. We want people who can come here and contribute, not be welfare for them because their own country isn’t doing the right thing. We would not be doing “the right thing” by Americans if we subsidized this either.
- ng12 8y ago> "Give me your cold, your tired, your huddled masses yearning to be free" That poem was written one year after the Chinese Exclusion Act was passed. We really need to stop using it as justification for anything.
- robbrit 8y ago> This works out well for Japan. I don't think Japan is really a model you want to copy. The decades of a stagnant economy despite low interest rates shows that something is wrong. Also, highly-qualified people aren't the only ones who make things better for everyone. Some sort of citizenship path for entrepreneurs would help, given that our number of new businesses have been in decline for years.
- ng12 8y agoJapan is still the third largest economy in the world. I'd say that's a pretty good model as far as countries go.
- tuberelay 8y agoJapan has almost negligible immigration. I don't think they even record statistics on it - last time they did a few years ago it was a total of 8000 people for a population of 125 million, compared to sweden which took 180,000 with a population of 10 million. Japan is probably the closest the world has to an ethnostate and could well be described as ethno-supremacists. They don't cop any flack for this because they're not westerners and only white people can be guilty of racism and xenophobia because colonialism (which ignores the fact that japan was a brutal colonial overlord to korea and taiwan).
- busymom0 8y agoNot just Japan, Canada has it too. I immigrated from a South Asian country to Canada and even though it was a long and tiring process, it makes me appreciate this country more because it ensures the clean background, hard working and skilled ones get to come in. It took me 7 years to get my PR after University and another 2 years for citizenship.
- godelmachine 8y ago>>”It took me 7 years to get my PR after University and another 2 years for citizenship.” Was it Canada or USA citizenship?