7 ms·
We already know how to safely operate nuclear power plants: the US Navy has been doing so for decades with no incidents. We could have imposed a similar level o
by pdonis 8y ago
We already know how to safely operate nuclear power plants: the US Navy has been doing so for decades with no incidents. We could have imposed a similar level of discipline on civilian nuclear power plant operators back in the 1970s, when commercial plants started being built in the US in quantity. Or we could have done it after Three Mile Island (which harmed no members of the general public but clearly showed inadequacies in the way civilian nuclear plants were operated). The fact that we didn't is a political problem, not a technical or operational problem.
Furthermore, even the operational problem is now nonexistent with newer reactor designs. Older designs, like the reactors at Three Mile Island, required the operators to correctly execute a fairly complex procedure in the event of a problem to prevent the reactor from being severely damaged or destroyed; the TMI operators failed to do that. Also, as Fukushima showed, older reactor designs require reliable backup power for decay heat removal. Newer designs have neither of those requirements; you can literally pull the shutdown switch and walk away and there will be no problem.
So while I don't disagree with what you say about complex systems in general, I don't think nuclear reactors, with today's designs, are even that complex. We know how to design and build them so that it is impossible to operate them unsafely. We just don't have the political will to do it.
- The-US-Navy 8y agoYeah, and the Navy can also impose the death penalty and lock people in jail and throw away the key for fucking up on the job. Great example. Let me draft my resume.
- newsoul2019 8y ago>> civilian nuclear power plant operators Maybe you just solved the problem. The Navy should operate the civilian nuclear power plants.
- mimixco 8y agoThe problem is scale. Today's nuclear plants are just big scaled-up versions of the Navy's original small reactors for ships. Unfortunately, scaling the power output also scales the risks and consequences of an accident.
- jwr 8y ago> Today's nuclear plants are just big scaled-up versions of the Navy's original small reactors for ships This is true, and Perrow's book contains an interesting discussion of this. The Navy had requirements which are different from civilian power generation: they needed small and relatively lightweight reactors whose power output can be quickly adjusted, and where fuel can be replaced quickly. None of these requirements make sense for a stationary civilian power plant.
- pdonis 8y ago> None of these requirements make sense for a stationary civilian power plant. Yes, and not having to meet those requirements makes the reactor easier to design, operate, and maintain.
- pdonis 8y agoI've had the idea for some time that the US government could easily expand nuclear generating capacity by simply passing a law providing for a nuclear reactor, operated and maintained by US Navy personnel, to power every military base on US territory. Any excess power produced by the plants would be sold to the commercial grid at prevailing rates, or even at a slight discount. The program would probably pay for itself.
- onli 8y agoThere are actually a bunch of US navy incidents related to nuclear power listed on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_military_nuclear_accidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_military_nuclear_accid.... It's a sound assumptions that there are many more we would not hear about.
- pdonis 8y ago> a bunch of US navy incidents related to nuclear power The only US Navy incidents I see there are: - Loss of the USS Thresher--the reactor was shut down because of a subsafe problem (water leaking into the submarine because of a failed weld), not anything to do with the reactor. The leakage was severe enough that, as noted, the sub could not surface and sunk past crush depth. - Loss of the USS Scorpion--the cause is unknown, as noted on the Wikipedia page, but a reactor problem is not among the causes considered possible. Most of the possible causes involve some kind of event causing a hull breach and flooding. [1] - Various incidents involving radioactive reactor cooling water or related substances (such as the resin used to clean the reactor cooling loop). These do qualify as "incidents", but they have nothing to do with incorrect operation of the reactor or any inherent danger or factors not being understood in the reactor design. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Scorpion_%28SSN-589%29#Theories_about_the_loss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Scorpion_%28SSN-589%29#The...
- onli 8y ago> but they have nothing to do with incorrect operation of the reactor or any inherent danger or factors not being understood in the reactor design. To the contrary, society's inability to deal with the radioactive waste created by running these reactors is one of the main concerns against nuclear power.
- pdonis 8y ago> society's inability to deal with the radioactive waste This is a political problem, not a technical problem. The only country using nuclear power that even has the political problem is the US. As noted elsewhere in this thread, every other country that uses nuclear power reprocesses the spent fuel and does not have a nuclear waste problem.
- sq_ 8y agoIf anyone wants a deeper look at an operational group of reactors that are designed to be as safe as possible and difficult to operate unsafely, I highly recommend checking out Canada's CANDU reactors [0]. This video [1] is a pretty interesting and reasonably short look at their safety systems/precautions. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CANDU_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CANDU_reactor [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yx_XoqXNtRM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yx_XoqXNtRM
- pfdietz 8y agoThe remnants of AECL were sold for just $15M. They didn't get sales of the new generation CANDUs, and the Canadian government eventually got tired of subsidizing them.
- jwr 8y ago> no incidents I would respectfully suggest that you read the book I quoted. I also thought there were "no incidents". The book is from 1983, so it specifically describes the 70s and early 80s. There were plenty of incidents and accidents, it's just that few of them resulted in major releases of radioactive material. My take on this after reading about some details is that we were just lucky. Some might say it is outdated — but I followed up on some of the stories described there and checked more recent developments. Specifically, the San Onofre plant which gets a mention in the book. You can read about it on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Onofre_Nuclear_Generating_Station#Shutdown,_2012_and_closure,_2013 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Onofre_Nuclear_Generating_... — now tell me that we know what we're doing and that we "know how to safely operate nuclear power plants" after reading things like: > On investigation, the replacement steam generators from 2011 in both units were found to show premature wear on over 3,000 tubes, in 15,000 places.[47] Plant officials pledged not to restart until the causes of the tube leak and tube degradation were understood. Other honorable mentions: > "The firm Bechtel was ... embarrassed in 1977, when it installed a 420-ton nuclear-reactor vessel backwards" at San Onofre > In 2008, the San Onofre plant received multiple citations over issues such as failed emergency generators, improperly wired batteries and falsified fire safety data. Again, I am not against nuclear power. I'm just pointing out that we have way too much hubris and the rosy picture of "no incidents" is not entirely true. Also, which newer designs do you mean?
- ip26 8y agoWe have accumulated a lot of stories that can be a bit hair-raising. But looking back, the actual rate of casualties is much higher for coal, oil, & gas. Which makes this feel like obsessing about airline fatalities (0.2 deaths per 10 billion passenger-miles) and ignoring automobile fatalities (150 per 10 billion vehicle-miles) I mean, look at it from the other angle. At San Onofre, a vessel was installed backwards. It then proceeded to deliver power for 25 years & was decommissioned. Additionally, we're reading about all this mismanagement as a result of regulatory oversight. Not as a result of a post-catastrophe investigative report.
- patejam 8y ago
- stephenr 8y agoHas the US Navy worked out what no one else has yet? What to do with all the toxic waste? Hiding it in a mountain and hoping for the best is hardly a solution. The US Navy also has effectively as much money as it ever needs to “decommission” reactors. How many private reactors have their decommissioning costs adequately covered? Everything I’ve read says most estimates from time of construction were woefully inadequate and thus any money that may have been squirrelled away to pay for decommissioning will fall way short of what’s required.
- ars 8y ago> Has the US Navy worked out what no one else has yet? What to do with all the toxic waste? I don't know about the Navy, but we do know what to do with the toxic waste. I didn't realize people still thought it was a problem. Nuclear fuel reprocessing plus breeder reactors can almost completely burn up all the nuclear fuel, leaving only short lived elements behind, and no long term storage issues. The only reason we don't do it today is economic plus arms control.
- gpm 8y ago> The only reason we don't do it today is economic [...] Which would appear to be a disqualifying issue since the entire reason people are advocating for nuclear and not renewables is economic.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe salient point is that it's uneconomical primarily as a result of purposeful regulatory obstructionism. It costs a lot because opponents want it to cost a lot. Moreover, that is a temporary issue. You have a lot of money from oil and coal lobbying against anything that could replace them, but you don't have to reprocess the spent fuel this year, or next year, or ten years from now. You can do it thirty years from now when the coal lobby is dead and gone because nobody burns coal anymore by then. And storing it for that long is much easier than needing somewhere to put it for thousands of years.
- mimixco 8y agoI know of no technology that would allow a plant operator to simply walk away. Even spent fuel rods have to be cooled for years in a swimming pool (with constantly added fresh water) or they too will heat and catch fire. Care to explain your "carefree" nuclear or give an example of a plant that has solved this problem?
- Reedx 8y agoGen IV is passively safe: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_IV_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_IV_reactor
- mimixco 8y agoSadly, it's also non-existent!
- imtringued 8y agoYes, we already see cost overruns for existing nuclear reactor design which should be well understood by now. A new design isn't going to make nuclear power more predictable in terms of safety and costs.
- pfdietz 8y agoReactors on Powerpoint slides have excellent safety records!
- jacquesm 8y ago> in a swimming pool I don't think they use swimming pools for that purpose.
- mimixco 8y agoI would hope no one would try to swim in one, but if you empty the pools where the vast majority of America's nuclear waste is stored, most people would say the resulting cavity strongly resembles a swimming pool.
- gpm 8y ago> the US Navy has been doing so for decades with no incidents. The USS Seawolf, Theodore Roosevolt, Swordfish, Proteus, Puffer, and Long Beach all had publicly known incidents involving the release of radioactive material... and given the navy's (legitimate) tendency to classify stuff I see little reason to believe this is the extent of the issues. http://www.lutins.org/nukes.html#subs http://www.lutins.org/nukes.html#subs
- pdonis 8y agoThese incidents involve release of radioactive reactor cooling water. Those do qualify as "incidents", but they have nothing to do with incorrect operation of the reactor or with any inherent danger in the reactor design or some key technical issue not being well understood. I should have clarified that I was talking about incidents that show that some key technical issue about designing and operating nuclear reactors is not well understood. The only incidents of that type on the page you linked to occurred in 1959, very early on in the US Navy's nuclear program.
- bassman9000 8y agothe US Navy has been doing so for decades with no incidents On reactors less than 200MWe. 1GWe is another game when vessel is huge and pressurized. MSR is the way to go.
- bigbadgoose 8y ago> We could have imposed a similar level of discipline on civilian nuclear power plant operators ... when commercial plants started being built in the US in quantity ... Three Mile Island (...clearly showed inadequacies in the way civilian nuclear plants were operated). The fact that we didn't is a political problem, not a technical or operational problem. Scaling any operation is going to introduce error. It's exponentially harder to control 1,000 outcomes in a civilian operation than 10 outcomes in a military operation. And when the failure scenario is nuclear debris beyond sovereign borders, it gets dicey. So the real political problem seems to be, "I don't want to be any part of Chernobyl, USA"
- sampo 8y ago> 10 outcomes in a military operation According to Wikipedia, US Navy has 70 active nuclear submarines, and 11 nuclear aircraft carriers. So 81 not 10. There is also a number of decommissioned ones.
- pdonis 8y agoComparing any reactor the US has ever built, commercial, nuclear, or even research, to Chernobyl is not in any way justified. Chernobyl was a seriously flawed design that no country but the Soviet Union would ever have considered building.
- opo 8y agoI agree with your main point that reactor designs today are safer designs than those from the 1960s. Though you also wrote: >...Or we could have done it after Three Mile Island (which harmed no members of the general public but clearly showed inadequacies in the way civilian nuclear plants were operated). The fact that we didn't is a political problem, not a technical or operational problem. All indications are that much was learned by industry and the NRC after TMI: "...The NRC said the TMI accident also led to increased identification, analysis and publication of plant performance information, and recognising human performance as “a critical component of plant safety”. Key indicators of plant safety performance in the US have improved dramatically. Those indicators show: • The average number of significant reactor events over the past 20 years has dropped to nearly zero. • Today there are far fewer, much less frequent and lower risk events that could lead to a reactor-core damage. • The average number of times safety systems have had to be activated is about one-tenth of what it was 22 years ago. • Radiation exposure levels to plant workers have steadily decreased to about one-sixth of the 1985 exposure levels and are well below national limits. • The average number of unplanned reactor shutdowns has decreased by nearly ten-fold. In 2007 there were about 52 shutdowns compared to about 530 shutdowns in 1985." https://www.nucnet.org/all-the-news/2009/03/23/three-mile-island-led-to-sweeping-and-permanent-changes https://www.nucnet.org/all-the-news/2009/03/23/three-mile-is...
- pdonis 8y ago> All indications are that much was learned by industry and the NRC after TMI That's true, the industry did learn a lot from TMI--and it made no difference, because it was already too late as far as public opinion was concerned. The US government and the media spun TMI as showing that nuclear power just wasn't safe enough, and the public believed it. As a result, we have nuclear generating about 20% of US electricity, when it could be more like 75%. Imagine if the US had not had to buy any foreign oil at all after, say, 1990.
- sadris 8y agoThe US military has lost 8 nuclear warheads. To say "no incidents" might be a bit of a misnomer.
- pdonis 8y agoI was not talking about warhead incidents, I was talking about reactor incidents.
- petre 8y agoThe US Navy is a military organization, they are disciplined and have very clear procedures. Even so, accidents do happen. Also naval scale reactors are safer. Commercial utility size reactors are upscaled versions of naval or laboratory reactors, where you cannot make the same safety guarantees. Take it from Alvin Weinberg: https://youtu.be/iW8yuyk3Ugw https://youtu.be/iW8yuyk3Ugw Also, in the case of an accident, the ship usually goes down and the reactor is naturally cooled and shielded by water. Then the accident us probably classified, because we don't want Russia recovering an US sub, like the CIA did at great taxpayer expense. I think that SMRs are a way forward, even if it's a temporary solution until other safer, non pressurized reactors are developed. They draw from navy reactors and can be produced in a factory under strict QA, transported on site by truck and installed by qualified staff using clearly documented and reproductible procedures.
- abstractbeliefs 8y agoI like what you're saying, but that they are military doesn't make them infallible. While they have procedures and discipline, so do commercial operations. For every corner that is cut to save cost in commerce to make the business viable, in the military sphere there is the pressure to do more with shrinking budgets, and the mentality that the military is too important to be regulated out of