11 ms·
Is it increasing, or is it being identified more often? I have teenage and early 20s age children. They and all of their peers have been diagnosed with anxiety,
by irrational 8y ago
Is it increasing, or is it being identified more often? I have teenage and early 20s age children. They and all of their peers have been diagnosed with anxiety, depression, and a host of other mental illnesses. When I was growing up I can't remember any kids in my high school (I had a graduation class of 900+ students) being diagnosed with any sort of mental illness. I've wondered if the frequency with which people are experiencing mental illness has increased, or if the rates have remained stable but diagnosis and reporting levels have improved.
- cheeseomlit 8y agoDiagnosing more people does not necessarily mean diagnosis is improving, especially when the criteria are purely subjective (and there are perverse incentives for pharmaceutical companies to diagnose more people)
- 50656E6973 8y agoIndeed, there is a huge conflict of interest and positive feedback loop: 69% of the DSM-5 task force had ties to the pharmaceutical industry. Diagnosis rates grow each year, and the number of ambiguously defined mental illnesses increases with every revision of the DSM. These data points are used as justification for further increases in funding, which in turn increases diagnosis rates. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DSM-5#Criticism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DSM-5#Criticism
- krageon 8y agoWhile I do agree that you can see some of the industry and view it as a huge problem, the "ambiguously defined mental illnesses" are easily explained to be a result of the fundamentally subjective nature of the field itself. We don't need "pharmaceutical industry" conspiracies to explain why things are going where they are going.
- TheOperator 8y agoI would actually blame insurance companies more than pharmacutical companies for the trajectory of the mental health field as they won't give doctors money to treat their patients if they don't first slap their patients with a stigmatised label. This pressure increases the pressure to make it so more of the population is defined as being mentally ill so they can get medical treatment.
- 50656E6973 8y agoYou don't think conflicts of interest can create perverse incentives or be problematic? Conflict of interest != criminal conspiracy
- myth_drannon 8y agoJust yesterday we had "City residents live with mental illness at higher rates than general population" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19920393 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19920393 Maybe population density is increasing and causing mental issues.
- fsloth 8y agoLarge cities have 15% more of everything when compared to a more loose population. Economic and creative output, but crime and disease as well. It's a statistical fact that no one has been able to explain fully.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoIs it not trivially explained by network effects?
- fsloth 8y agoBy network effects, most likely yes, but not trivially. Geoffrey West's 'Scale' is a popular introduction to the topic, and I highly recommend it.
- johnsimer 8y agoSee the recent HN post on diffusion and how certain things can only diffuse in cities https://www.meltingasphalt.com/interactive/going-critical/ https://www.meltingasphalt.com/interactive/going-critical/
- P_I_Staker 8y agoIf anything, shouldn't that result in decreasing suicide rates? Either that or treatment is worsening health outcomes. This would be extremely troubling. I tend to think that depression is both on the rise, and historically under-treated. In fact, it's most likely still under-treated. I'm neutral on the efficacy of treatment.
- sjg007 8y agoTreatment works. There is a subset of treatment resistant though.
- phkahler 8y agoAnd there is a subset that is adversely affected.
- DanielleMolloy 8y agoYes, and with 1 in 6 Americans on them it seems that a critical mass has been reached that doesn't want to hear about adverse effects of their fix anymore. So there is a lack of serious discussion about them.
- cwkoss 8y agoDoctors are frequently prescribing SSRIs where no study has shown them more effective for that indication than placebo. Many doctors still believe the "correcting neurotransmitter imbalance" theory of SSRI action which appears to be on its way to being disproved.
- tellak 8y agoAbsolute bullshit. To say there are no studies demonstrating better effectiveness than placebo is a tired old meme. It is true that SSRIs don’t have a profound effectiveness over placebo like some drugs.. but that does not make them useless. Current understanding is that they are effective, just not very much. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(17)32802-7/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... This meta analysis has John Ionaddis as one of the coauthors (if you don’t know why this is interesting look it up). Also nothing is easily “disproved” in medicine (or most science) so even if “neurotransmitter imbalance” is false, you’re still wrong nothing is on the way to being disproved. Furthermore, current understanding of SSRI effectiveness is not based on “correcting neurotransmitter imbalance”.
- coldtea 8y agoIs it being "identified more often" or is it made into a thing when it's not more often (because experts follow fads too, because it helps sell drugs, because it helps justify various programs, plus it's not like measuring such issues it's some hard science, so nobody will be able to prove otherwise anyway). "Kid's bored at school? Get them some ADHD drugs!". (Not that there aren't legitimate cases, but there's also mass over-prescription).
- DanielleMolloy 8y agoPeople who downvoted this statement should google "disease mongering": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disease_mongering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disease_mongering They may also want to check out Allen Frances: "Saving Normal". Mental health problems are real. Overprescription due to capitalist reasons is real too. They both do harm.
- dev_dull 8y agoDo you live in the Bay Area?
- irrational 8y agoI do not.
- jatins 8y agoI have late 20s friends and have seen the similar behaviour. A lot of people I meet say they are in a bad place mentally. Also, pardon my ignorance, but I am also curious what counts as being diagnosed with "anxiety" disorder? As in are there definitive definitions of these things?
- TheOperator 8y ago>I've wondered if the frequency with which people are experiencing mental illness has increased, or if the rates have remained stable but diagnosis and reporting levels have improved. Both although I'm very skeptical that diagnosing more people as mentally ill is the same as an improvement. The criteria to be diagnosed with a mental illness has loosened. Probably the most extreme example is the DSM-V declaring bereavement over 2 weeks to be a form of mental illness - depression. What has been considered normal human behavior for most of human history has been medicalized. I've seen no evidence that increases in diagnosis in the last 2 decades have improved mental health in the developed world. Metrics like the suicide rate have gotten worse during that time. Self-reported anxiety and depression is on its way up. This is not to say you cannot find individuals or groups helped. However the increase in labelling causes insecurity/stigma, while the field itself like all field does have some deadweight costs. The mental health field also, even if it effective are getting overwhelmed by broader societal issues.